Recognition of important varieties TPG's

Started by autocoupler, September 30, 2014, 12:54:05 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

autocoupler

OK, so lets say someone was starting to get interested in slabbing their collection of Australian rare varieties. Do the TPG's currently have the ability or desire to do this, so far as possessing the necessary  knowledge and experience goes. When you look at current local price guides, there are so many hugely important coins missing from the lists, it begs the question of how would TPG's know anything about these rarities. It really is laughable that such an important part of our coin history has been ignored by local publishers for so long, their lists border on negligence in my opinion.

I realise that a meagre few of our important early rarities have found their rightful place in the listings i.e. 1916 halfpenny mule, 1919 and 1920 penny dot above / dot below, 1920 penny dot above, as well as the 1933/34 penny over date. Unfortunately this is where it ends, the guides are just so far out of date it's not funny.

 Incredibly there is no reference in the price guides to 1920 penny dot under lower scroll with London obverse, the extremely rare 1920 penny dot over lower scroll London obverse, the 1921 penny with London obverse, 1924, 27 and 31 pennies with Indian obverse, or indeed the extremely rare 1931 penny with dropped 1 Indian obverse. If we add the 1953 Melbourne penny with different 5 and 3, as well as the 1955 and 56 Perth mules, there's 10 coins that the TPG's would have very little knowledge of, but all of which attract significant attention whenever they turn up at auction.

Back to the original question, would the TPG's have the expertise to accurately process the above coins.
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

oh my florin

The TPG's I believe have the general policy of recognising coin varieties only when recognised in McDonalds guide from what I can remember from an old thread. They will sometimes recognise varieties not recognised in McDonalds however it is rarer for this to happen as they want to be completely sure. wwwww or drakesterling should be along soon to provide an authoritative answer on this however.

Fordprefect

Rob the Elder

autocoupler

Quote from: 'Fordprefect' pid='60209' dateline='1412045456'Just for your perusal, emu is a forum member.
http://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/publishedset.aspx?s=120231

Thanks for that Rob, I reckon that seals it then. Apart from about three examples, the TPG's appear blissfully unaware of these important coins. What a shame it is that some of the rareities exhibited by EMU666 don't occupy top billing as they would if not thrown in with the common mintages.
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

Fordprefect

The TPG's are aware of these varieties, the lack of
a Creditable 3rd Party identifier that they can point too
is what is missing.
(Renniks 2nd Edition dosn't cut it, nor Fred Lever's guide)
Rob the Elder

Goldseeker

Message rec\'d from Jens Coins 18 Jul 23: 
Bruce Mansfield passed away today 18 Jul 2023 – Acute Myeloid Leukemia


robbiegal


Goldseeker

Message rec\'d from Jens Coins 18 Jul 23: 
Bruce Mansfield passed away today 18 Jul 2023 – Acute Myeloid Leukemia


autocoupler

Quote from: 'Fordprefect' pid='60212' dateline='1412053543'The TPG's are aware of these varieties, the lack of
a Creditable 3rd Party identifier that they can point too
is what is missing.
(Renniks 2nd Edition dosn't cut it, nor Fred Lever's guide)

I think the two publications you refer to are excellent guides to generate awareness of the overall theme of variety collecting, and  Fred Lever for example does offer up articles to do with the various reverse and obverse combinations. Unfortunately, a core group of rarities which includes those mentioned previously, tend to get lost in a sea of, for the want of a better term, lesser individuals. Just as importantly, the publications could make better reference to mintage, grade progression and associated values.
 
I realise that some information relating to mintage may be difficult to obtain, but a perusal of auction house results and archives, as well as results from internet auctions would confirm relevant information for grade and values.

Having said this, and with reference to the post by OMF, if McDonalds have become the bench mark, and the source of material by TPG's, it's up to McDonalds to get it right.
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

nealeffendi

I'll add my tuppence worth.
There can be no accurate estimate for the mintages of the varieties as even the mintages for each year are estimates and the varieties were not generally noticed for years. The mint records are woefully lacking and at best some educated guesses using the records have been made.
Even sampling a large horde (or multiple hordes) will give a rough low accuracy figure as regional variations in both distribution and survival really screw things up.
I prefer Freds catalogue over the big 2 (Renniks and McDonalds) any day for pre decimal varieties. If the TPGs are waiting on them to provide the lead then that is a sorry state of affairs. I think we have been waiting since the Millenium for the McDonalds Opus and Renniks are but a shadow of the editions of 40 years ago. The TPGs would be better off dropping some emails to Walter and Peter (both PCGS affiliated dealers) to ask them what varieties should get recognised on the slabs. Peters already slabbed coins must have hi-def images stored in the PCGS database and that would provide a better reference than the 2 catalogues ever could.
Besides the die pairs already listed there are a few more that also deserve to be recognised, if they can recognise scores of VAM numbers for their silver dollars then why not a few of the different wide and narrow dates for our coins?

robbiegal

there are also other Australian numismatic experts who are not necessarily PCGS dealers but who are recognised for their knowledge of the Australian coinage and it's rarities
the Australian numismatic world is much bigger than generally talked about here

who would you go to for the verification of say,  the 1930 proof penny?
I am not sure who you mean by "Peter'.
Maybe also, not Walter (not casting any nasturtiums at young Walter) but  numismatists have to earn their credibility and reputation within the numismatic world both domestically and internationally. There has to be proven numismatic/historical knowledge and expertise or say a Mint connection in order  to be recognised as having a certain authority.  The Belinda Downies and the other dealers/numistacists of her calibre are also considered to have a certain expertise.
PCGS could confer with Australian experts for rarity verification and there is a possibility that they do.
I am not entirely convinced that PCGS rely 100% on Maccas as their only reference for Australian coinage.
 
A proper numismatist will refer to reliable historical records, expert advice and auctions records.
But take the 1930 penny, if PCGS went on Mint records alone, well they say it doesn't exist but expert opinion says it does. So a reliable numismatist etc. is required for the verification, not a book that simply lists a comprehensive reference listing of Australian coinage.

It is possible that PCGS get such a small amounts of the variation of the die pairs etc that it may not make it a viable business proposition to include in their descriptive systems. The English may make the same complaint about their varieties ?

nealeffendi

Robbiegal, the Peter that I'm referring to is emu. He works at Stuart Andersens (sp?) and if you look at his PCGS varieties set that Ford posted you will see that his coins have much better photos than you will find in the thumbnail photos that catalogues might show.
Does it matter how young/old Walter is? He has shown himself to be highly knowledgeable on pre decimals (and how to assess PCGS grades) and his Bluesheet is a better catalogue than the 2 main printed ones.
The number of variety pennies is low compared to the number of normal ones, but the low numbers paradoxically makes it a prime (untapped) market. Nobody is going to slab say normal EF 1927 pennies, but even VF Indians are perfect for slabbing as most variety collectors know how desirable they are in even VF30. Must be several hundred out there that are good enough to slab. Also a TPG could use it as a differentiation point from other TPGs by offering to slab varieties. With computers printing labels it isn't a costly burden to add Indianor English to a slab or database and it pushes collectors who want complete registry sets to  buy and slab variety coins.
I have more variety pennies in VF to EF than EF to Unc in the common version. The normal ones will be taking a trip to California first as the lack of variety recognition means the varieties are better of staying raw until they are recognised.

robbiegal

ok
didn't mean any insult WHATSOEVER TOWARDS Walter for being a (sweet) younger numismatist in the Australian coppers market and knowing Walter personally I do hope that he would realise that

gold, that is a completely different story of expertise with the Eigner boys
 
and I have no intention to start an argument about any particular person especially Walter, as I respect his numismatic abilities but if I wanted a 1930 proof penny verified I would not go straight to Walter, I 'd go to Tony Byrne  or the Downies etc  and Walter would respect my doing that

yes, I would confer with Peter or Fred and have sent coins to both of them for their eagle eyes opinion - which I respect 100%. and yes, I have met Stuart as well


ask Peter or Fred who they would and do refer to for a strictly professional  and reliable second opinion on any of the Australian  rare coins or rarer die varieties
I rest my case

I suppose that on reflection of the point that I am trying to make is that certain numismatists have certain speciality knowledge and a lot of that knowledge takes time and commitment to that speciality

and not a single person always has it all

the experts all confer with each other and formulate opinions based on either a consensus or a shared common ground

yes I'd overwhelming agree that Dr Peter would be a true die variety specialists just as Fred is but they form these opinions in collaborating with other experts as well

just as you Neil have your speciality knowledge in the pre-decs as well

Just as the Purple Penny is becoming the key experts in the Australian error coins, esp. the decimal errors

I have a bias towards my coin dealer as he is one of the few people who (quietly) values, catalogues and identifies rarities in it's entirety in the  national collection, not many can lay claim to that expertise and very few in the numismatic industry have the expertise to do so

PCGS are an American firm and their leaning is to the local USA auction market, understandably, I appreciate their grading methods for wear and mint state of surface integrity but beyond that they offer very little numismatic expertise for the Australian market regarding our minting methods, the metals used for our earlier coinage or the die pairings etc.

and yes, for some collectors that is a serious omission, I don't disagree with that

Australians can apply to work with them (PCGS) as well -  I read their job ads
 and if they took more interest in the Australian market they'd seek out and employ the services for our expert advice

nealeffendi

RG, I know you meant no disrespect to wwww:heart:
Yes, for each particular section of numismatics you would do to a different expert.
The best experts in numismatics are not necessarily professional but amateurs (as in people who don't do it as a commercial living but as a passion). Most dealers (even though coins are their profession) know naff all about the rarer varieties. Plus they have a financial motivation to not be strictly professional by doing things like implying a variety is rare and valuable when it is just scarce. By contrast the "amateur" isn't motivated by the commerce and he can spend more time (leisure) on the research than the professional (who has to make the most of his time).
Maybe the best experts are the knowledgeable enthusiast turned dealer.

robbiegal

thanks and yep I agree with you
I have been appalled by the obvious numismatic stupidity of many so called 'dealers'  esp. the ones who only do it for the money not for any passion for aussie coinage and yes the Chris B. with his long term commitment to PCGS for aussie coins ; the Walters and Erics ; PP and the likes of those up and coming younger dealers are bringing a sophistication to the aussie collector market that has probably never been seen before.

I also know that my point of view is skewed by my own personal preferences. And I am not immersed enough in aussie numismatics to know all and sundry either,  like some here will.

But with the collapse of the rare coin company the éxpert' who was called in (?) I think it was Andrew Crellin and he is someone who has a proven numismatic reputation.
to quote
"Andrew Crellin's numismatic career began with two years at the Perth Mint, followed by over a decade in Sydney employed with two of Australia's leading numismatic dealers. In that time, Andrew wrote two acclaimed books on Australian numismatics, appraised the Perth Mint's archival collection and was nominated to the position of Secretary of the Australasian Numismatic Dealer's Association (ANDA)."  And so on.....


I would suppose they look for experience and publications, etc
for credibility. It is not a profession that has any recognised qualifications. Numismatics is more about accumulated knowledge and heavy on the mentoring.
 
I reckon that PCGS don't really care for our true blue collectors - they are after the big bucks in the rarities, IMHO.The issues that Trout is having with his pcgs slab descriptors, says it all to me. If they can't get the common old "grannie bait" (to quote) correctly identified then how the hell are they going to get a less known and rarer die pairing right?