Recognition of important varieties TPG's

Started by autocoupler, September 30, 2014, 12:54:05 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

trout

Well I have to give PCGS some due because before I sent that Silver Proof set away to be graded there were many of the coins NOT listed and PCGS would have had to create new coin numbers for them and update the registry set .
They may be considered as "Grannybait" and I suppose ALL the NCLT issues come under that heading But it is NOT simply a "Walk in the Park" trying to assemble the coins in this series in Super high grades.

With the increasing amount of Aus collectors getting their coins slabbed lately I imagine that eventually we may become recognised as being an important sector of PCGS/NGC market and they will indeed start to lift their game as far as getting it right for varieties on Aussie coins.

In the meantime we will just have to "Soldier On" and get things fixed as we go :ok:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

robbiegal

agree
ps - I learnt the term granny bait from u guys here!!

trout

Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='60333' dateline='1412210693'agree
ps - I learnt the term granny bait from u guys here!!

HeHe
If it wasn't for the NCLT/Grannybait my decimal collections would be horribly skinny :)
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

serial


JeffH

Don't give the mints ideas. They will be making silver fishing flys before you know it!
Thinking is dangerous, it makes you think. That\'s why many people avoid it.

Goldseeker

My cousin has made same silver fishing flies......... he lives in Holbrook NSW.
Message rec\'d from Jens Coins 18 Jul 23: 
Bruce Mansfield passed away today 18 Jul 2023 – Acute Myeloid Leukemia


JeffH

Are they shaped like a submarine?
Holbrook (nee Germanton) -I know it well. I have cousins there too.
Thinking is dangerous, it makes you think. That\'s why many people avoid it.

autocoupler

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='60278' dateline='1412158523'Besides the die pairs already listed there are a few more that also deserve to be recognised, if they can recognise scores of VAM numbers for their silver dollars then why not a few of the different wide and narrow dates for our coins?

If forced to nominate a list of penny varieties that should be included in the general price listings, I would only include the better known die types that were derived from a viewpoint of historical intention, but leaving out those considered as being from post die damage. :angel:

Could the TPG's expand our penny list by 26 slots? There are 32 on the list but they actually already include 6 of these. The world is full of hypocracy and contradiction I know, but as the TPG's appear to have already included a die fill i.e. 1942I with missing I mint mark, that widens the scope a little. Just love those 1922's, ha ha.  

1913 left tilted 3, 1914 left tilted 4, 1915 left tilted 5, 1919 double dot, 1920 plain Indian obverse, 1920 double dot, 1920 dot above top scroll, 1920 dot below bottom scroll London obverse, 1920 dot above bottom scroll London obverse, 1921 London obverse, 1922 upright 9 common width date, 1922 upright 9 narrow date, 1922 wide date, 1922 wide date with spike on tail of 9, 1922 extra wide date, 1922 extra wide date with spike on tail of 9, 1924 Indian obverse, 1927 Indian obverse, 1929 Indian obverse, 1930 London obverse, 1931 Indian obverse, 1931 dropped 1 Indian obverse, 1933/2 overdate, 1941 k.g high dot at Y, 1942I missing I mint mark, 1943I large reverse denticles, 1951 PL missing PL mint mark, 1953 long 5 different 3, 1955Y. narrow date, 1955Y. obverse 9 hybrid, 1956Y. obverse 8 hybrid, 1957Y. wide date.
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

oh my florin

There is a 1915 right tilted. I discovered it a while ago and it goes across the Threepence and Shilling 1915 series as well.

autocoupler

That's interesting OMF. I know of three varieties for the 1915 plain penny. (1) The left tilted 5 where the left edge of the upstroke of the 5 aligns with the left side of a dot in the inner circle, (2) where the upstroke aligns mid way between the centre and the left edge of the same dot, (3) where the upstroke aligns with the centre of the same dot. Apart from the obvious left tilted version, the other two are pretty subtle. I have an example of each, and I'm thinking your right tilted 5 may be a (3). Anyhow, have a look at some info by Mike Locke. http://www.calgoldcoin.com/
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

robbiegal

really you could have gazillions of the various varieties described
i'd think the key die/pairings + the overdates which are always popular, would be ok to describe but all of the slighter varieties (of which there are a multitude of regular variations) would just be spotted by the trained eye and sell accordingly

I guess that what you prefer to collect would colour which varieties are more important

for example, I think that the 1962 'double nose Queen' is a stunning error variation but alas, I don't think that PCGS describe it but if I spotted a beautiful unc one on a slab i'd be quietly  very interested to buy that particular coin

autocoupler

I agree, you could come up with a list so extensive it would appear silly, but not to variety collectors he he, and we all have our favourites.

In reality, including the 6 already listed by PCGS for example, there must be in my opinion 20 or so core coins that warrant listing. Most   are so scarce in any grade and rare in high grade, they don't need to be slabbed to attract attention from existing collectors. Although, while these coins continue to be ignored by the catalogues and Third Party Graders, it just makes for one more failed transfer of information opportunity for new entrants to the hobby.      

But as mentioned previously in another post, it's a shame high grade examples that currently compete with the common mintages in registry sets are not given due recognition, as they would if allocated to a variety die registry.
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

nealeffendi

Quote from: 'autocoupler' pid='60377' dateline='1412308588'
Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='60278' dateline='1412158523'Besides the die pairs already listed there are a few more that also deserve to be recognised, if they can recognise scores of VAM numbers for their silver dollars then why not a few of the different wide and narrow dates for our coins?

If forced to nominate a list of penny varieties that should be included in the general price listings, I would only include the better known die types that were derived from a viewpoint of historical intention, but leaving out those considered as being from post die damage. :angel:

Could the TPG's expand our penny list by 26 slots? There are 32 on the list but they actually already include 6 of these. The world is full of hypocracy and contradiction I know, but as the TPG's appear to have already included a die fill i.e. 1942I with missing I mint mark, that widens the scope a little. Just love those 1922's, ha ha.  

1913 left tilted 3, 1914 left tilted 4, 1915 left tilted 5, 1919 double dot, 1920 plain Indian obverse, 1920 double dot, 1920 dot above top scroll, 1920 dot below bottom scroll London obverse, 1920 dot above bottom scroll London obverse, 1921 London obverse, 1922 upright 9 common width date, 1922 upright 9 narrow date, 1922 wide date, 1922 wide date with spike on tail of 9, 1922 extra wide date, 1922 extra wide date with spike on tail of 9, 1924 Indian obverse, 1927 Indian obverse, 1929 Indian obverse, 1930 London obverse, 1931 Indian obverse, 1931 dropped 1 Indian obverse, 1933/2 overdate, 1941 k.g high dot at Y, 1942I missing I mint mark, 1943I large reverse denticles, 1951 PL missing PL mint mark, 1953 long 5 different 3, 1955Y. narrow date, 1955Y. obverse 9 hybrid, 1956Y. obverse 8 hybrid, 1957Y. wide date.

The '42 penny is not a filled die, each die was individually punched with the I and on 1 die they forgot. A few other dies did suffer from die fill but are not completely missing the 1. The '51 PL is an example of the mint mark added to the master die so the missing PL is die fill.
The '41 high dot is probably a chip on the die (like the '39 dash after A).
We know you are passionate about 1922 so about the 1922 FBL and CBL? Or the 1922 Indian? (both from the master dies of 1920 (ex India) and 1921 (ex London).
In 1957 there is also the big mintmark variety (the product of a third reverse master used that year). There are also a few different years with true double tail coins such as 1957 (one was sold by Downies some years back). The major TPGs have slabbed and labled some errors that were knowingly produced by mint employees who pocketed them so being of possible/probable dodgy background does not make double tails not worthy of inclusion.

runway

nealeffendi you make much sense here,and Fred Lever has done immaculate work with his guides
Buy what gives you enjoyment

robbiegal

and the list could go on with our many varieties