Recognition of important varieties TPG's

Started by autocoupler, September 30, 2014, 12:54:05 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

nealeffendi

Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='60469' dateline='1412551061'and the list could go on with our many varieties

That is a matter of opinion:heart:
If you take the position of Ian (from CAB) as to the definition of what makes a variety then every different die fault (chips, diecracks, doubled die etc), every different mint mark position (Perth mint) and myriad errors (clips, cold shuts, off centre strikes, struck throughs, filled dies, spur etc) makes a variety. That makes 10,000+ die fault varieties, a few thousand dot position varieties and virtually unlimited errors.
If you take the position of Fred Lever then all the die faults and error coins are all just interesting error coins and that limits pre decimal varieties to under a hundred. That includes the various date positions on both the bronze and silver. That number is doable for PCGS to recognise.
I love my error coins but I don't regard them as varieties.

Nevol

QuoteI love my error coins but I don't regard them as varieties.
:agreed:
A Platypus is a duck designed by a committee ( anon)

autocoupler

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='60452' dateline='1412515447'The '42 penny is not a filled die, each die was individually punched with the I and on 1 die they forgot. A few other dies did suffer from die fill but are not completely missing the 1. The '51 PL is an example of the mint mark added to the master die so the missing PL is die fill.

That's interesting Neal, thanks, I thought the 42I was die fill. And yes, was aware of the 51 missing PL being a die fill damn it, but I still think mine is a little ripper :yahoo:

You mentioned a 1957 with a big mint mark? Can't locate any info about this one, you wouldn't be referring to the wide date?
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

r9453

Two Bob coin collector.

wwwww

Quote from: 'autocoupler' pid='60211' dateline='1412051965'
Quote from: 'Fordprefect' pid='60209' dateline='1412045456'Just for your perusal, emu is a forum member.
http://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/publishedset.aspx?s=120231

Thanks for that Rob, I reckon that seals it then. Apart from about three examples, the TPG's appear blissfully unaware of these important coins. What a shame it is that some of the rareities exhibited by EMU666 don't occupy top billing as they would if not thrown in with the common mintages.

That's not the complete list of recognised varieties. See the Pop reports for the complete list of slabbed varieties. Many types (e.g. the London 1930 penny) are excluded from the Set Registry as they're too rare making the number of complete sets possible very low.

autocoupler

Quote from: 'wwwww' pid='96851' dateline='1472883965'
Quote from: 'autocoupler' pid='60211' dateline='1412051965'
Quote from: 'Fordprefect' pid='60209' dateline='1412045456'Just for your perusal, emu is a forum member.
http://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/publishedset.aspx?s=120231

Thanks for that Rob, I reckon that seals it then. Apart from about three examples, the TPG's appear blissfully unaware of these important coins. What a shame it is that some of the rareities exhibited by EMU666 don't occupy top billing as they would if not thrown in with the common mintages.

That's not the complete list of recognised varieties. See the Pop reports for the complete list of slabbed varieties. Many types (e.g. the London 1930 penny) are excluded from the Set Registry as they're too rare making the number of complete sets possible very low.

Yes that's true. My above comment of two years ago is certainly redundant, particularly as PCGS has since added many important varieties to the population and registry listings :good:
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

nealeffendi

Still missing a few like the '46 florin with the big 6. Also has goofed by reclassifying coins without regards as to what they are. An obvious example is the large denticle florin where all slabbed 1953 florins were called small denticle when they began to differentiate between small and large (I have several slabbed examples in MS63 and I've noticed that several exist in MS65). Worse yet the same applies to the 1952P pennies where the scarcer die pairs are worth 3 points but the scarcer die pairs in older slabs are worth 1 point.

r9453

Quote from: 'wwwww' pid='96851' dateline='1472883965'See the Pop reports for the complete list of slabbed varieties. Many types (e.g. the London 1930 penny) are excluded from the Set Registry as they're too rare making the number of complete sets possible very low.

As far as I can tell, the only penny (other than the 1930 London) not included in the set registry is the 1925 Broken N (PCGS# 545374) - it was included briefly and then removed. At that point the penny set reached 95 coins, it is now down to 94.

EDIT: There are currently no complete sets.

Some scarce pennies included in the registry set :

1931 Calcutta Dropped 1 #569810 (Pop 6)
1927 Calcutta #569797 (Pop 9)
1920 London /./ #569749 (Pop 5)
Two Bob coin collector.

trout

Why remove the 1925 broken "N", It's not as if it is rare ??
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

nealeffendi

Quote from: 'trout' pid='96925' dateline='1472949127'Why remove the 1925 broken "N", It's not as if it is rare ??

It wasn't a die pair but a die error and worse yet they included 2 different die errors as the same error. If they include that die error then why not the double nose queen, the 3 legged emu, the denticle pattern 1921 halfpennies, blobby 8, 1944 chipped 4 threepence etc etc. Consistency.
As for the 1930 English it should be included as a slabbed example exists and several raw examples are known with yet others rumoured to exist.

r9453

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='96928' dateline='1472949623'It wasn't a die pair but a die error and worse yet they included 2 different die errors as the same error. If they include that die error then why not the double nose queen, the 3 legged emu, the denticle pattern 1921 halfpennies, blobby 8, 1944 chipped 4 threepence etc etc. Consistency.
As for the 1930 English it should be included as a slabbed example exists and several raw examples are known with yet others rumoured to exist.

:i_agree: the 1925 broken N is not a die pair, I read that it was the result of a die clash. Also agree that the 1930 London should be included.
Two Bob coin collector.

nealeffendi

Bumping this thread after 6 years for 2 reasons.
1/ Look at all the regulars that posted then but have not visited in years. Have they all gone to the great coin bourse in the sky or what?
2/ More importantly there does not seem to be any new varieties in these past few years that the TPGs have recognised.
Surely the coins struck off dies from fully dated hubs should make the grade.
The 3 most obvious examples are:
1934 wide date sixpence(at least 4 working dies)
1946 large loop 6 florin (at least 10 working dies)
1953 medium denticle florin (at least 5 working dies)
Each of the above exists in slabs (but undifferentiated from the regular), worse yet is that PCGS isn't even consistent in how they grade the '53 Medium. Some are in slabs labeled small denticle and some in slabs labeled large denticle.
Now I have in slab worthy grade 2 of the sixpences, 3 of the big loop and 15 of the medium denticles that I won't submit under the current system. How much (grading fees) are the TPGs missing out on from me and all the other variety collectors with similar collections who are holding back such coins from submissions until they recognise the varieties?

Basilstate

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='126293' dateline='1652145934'Bumping this thread after 6 years. 
1/ Look at all the regulars that posted then but have not visited in years. 
 with similar collections who are holding back such coins from submissions until they recognise the varieties?

Yes,'Two Bob' was a accurate Poster and obviously been around Coins all his life,sadly missed,don't know what happened to Walter,always got an Email on his upcoming sales but they have stopped as well. 
Hope Fred(and yourself) get back to regular Posting,lot of Info stored in his head,it doesn't matter whether people agree,disagree or are blase it goes down as a record and keeps the Forum ticking over.

nealeffendi

Fred has 3 articles in the latest CAB. 
Perhaps 2 years of lockdowns made a mess of Walters main operation (numisbid) though he does have a limited number of choice coins on his sales part of his operation.
Still plenty of collectors out there (so why are they not in the forums?), buggers outbid me on most choice coins I bid on and it seems that prices are setting new highs for the top end stuff (especially anything graded top of the pops). 
You would think what with all the time people had stuck at home during the lockdowns that they would have spent the time online, but the quiet spell has hit this forum for 2 plus years.

Basilstate

I'm in a little group up here in the Northern Rivers of NSW,6 at the moment although 2 have major health problems and a 3rd relies on his daughter to Email on his behalf,i think they are not interested in what other people think and just swap Info. in our little Clique..
We met thru Ebay and FB but they are also not interested in Forums per se but i'm trying to explain FB Coin Groups are similar but see what happens.