eBay Name and Shame?

Started by ChrisM, January 16, 2013, 12:12:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

ChrisM

Can we have a thread that allows us to name and shame bad sellers on ebay?

I have just had a pig of a time with a seller who gave me the run about for nearly 2.5 weeks.

I just want to keep it safe for us and help weed out the bad ones.

Obviously this could meet with some negative views but if we provide evidence would that be enough?

Thanks

trout

Quote from: 'ChrisM' pid='6440' dateline='1358300557'Can we have a thread that allows us to name and shame bad sellers on ebay?

I have just had a pig of a time with a seller who gave me the run about for nearly 2.5 weeks.

I just want to keep it safe for us and help weed out the bad ones.

Obviously this could meet with some negative views but if we provide evidence would that be enough?

Thanks

You have started a thread in this section, that should do it :good:
start naming :diablo:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

ChrisM

Quote from: 'trout' pid='6441' dateline='1358300930'
Quote from: 'ChrisM' pid='6440' dateline='1358300557'Can we have a thread that allows us to name and shame bad sellers on ebay?

I have just had a pig of a time with a seller who gave me the run about for nearly 2.5 weeks.

I just want to keep it safe for us and help weed out the bad ones.

Obviously this could meet with some negative views but if we provide evidence would that be enough?

Thanks

You have started a thread in this section, that should do it :good:
start naming :diablo:


:)

Only being new here I do not want to ruffle feathers. I would like a mod or admins approval. I mean this would have to be strictly monitored but proof such as messages and pictures should back up the posters claims.

JeffH

I think you will find Nevol, "Super Moderator" will be on your side.:angel:
Just a feeling I have.

Jeff
Thinking is dangerous, it makes you think. That\'s why many people avoid it.

trout

I just recived a couple of coins from the same seller.
This is the email I sent him.

Hi there,
I have bought off you on many an occasion in the past.
I asked you to combine the postage on the last 2 coins, alas you didn’t.
You did however charge like a wounded bull for the coins you posted.
The padded baggies you sent them in I can get at my post office for 80cents each add to that the actual postage cost of $1.20 and it works out to be $2 per parcel.
Instead of posting them both in the same parcel and charging me your actual costs you sent them in 2 parcels on the same day (that is ridiculess) and the postage cost me $14 instead of $2 as it should be.
It cost me an extra $12 but you still made an extra $10 by boosting the postage charges.
I am not happy at all with the outcome of this transaction.
regards
Jim

I will name and shame this seller if i dont get some sort of explanation or apoligy from him.

Postage scamming ranks up there with fakes and replacement coins in my book, They are all dodgy and unethical practices :to_pick_ones_nose_eat: :ireful: :aggressive:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Australian coin

Postage overcharge is a pet hate of mine too.
I usually try to charge actual cost for postage, the first item is $1.20 this covers me if the post office lady goes “that’s to heavy or thick” sometimes you get the nice lady and it passes for 60c.
I am always happy to combine postage, and it usually stays at the original price I DON’T CHARGE ANY EXTRA, if I have to send it in two envelope - which on a few occasions I have I just wear the cost, after all I figured that they have spent the money on a few coins to fill the first envelope anyway.

Some people want to be instant millionaires out of postage and that’s just not the way to do business,  I would rather loose a little money and have a happy customer than to disappoint someone and look bad.

markn

My only comment on this thread is do not say anything that will get me sued.  If I believe anything in here is heading that way then I'll delete it, no questions asked and no arguments will be entered into.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

stevo1962

If it's the seller that I think it is then I have already given him a wide berth after reading
his feedback.He has a trackrecord for dishonesty and apparently not sending coins
It\'s not about who you know it\'s about what you know

Australian coin

So eBay id ok?
Just don’t use names, or bad words etc.

markn

Quote from: 'Australian coin' pid='6462' dateline='1358314408'So eBay id ok?
Just don’t use names, or bad words etc.

You're all grown ups and should be able to decide for yourself.  My only advice is if you wouldn't be comfortable saying it to the persons face (and dealing with a potential punch in the nose) then you probably shouldn't say it here.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

Steveqld

I would caution against it.  Our original forum went belly up with no word from the host.  I believe this was shortly after he was sued by someone adversely mentioned in the forum.  Whilst I understand the suit was settled out of court he was probably left to pay a hefty legal bill.  I don't know if anyone ever found out for certain the circumstances.

I don't see anything wrong with giving circumstances on the forum then if members are interested they can PM the id between themselves.

trout

Quote from: 'markn' pid='6463' dateline='1358314690'
Quote from: 'Australian coin' pid='6462' dateline='1358314408'So eBay id ok?
Just don’t use names, or bad words etc.

You're all grown ups and should be able to decide for yourself.  My only advice is if you wouldn't be comfortable saying it to the persons face (and dealing with a potential punch in the nose) then you probably shouldn't say it here.

Fair enough :good;
******** is the sellers ebay id.
I recived an unsatisfactory line of BS in reply to my firs email.

I sent this email in return;

Hi again.
I asked you to hold the first coin until the bidding was over on the second coin when I paid for it.
I waited 24hrs before paying for the second coin ( I normally pay instantly) to give you time to adjust the postage costs, You didn’t.
Regardless of that, the charge of $7 to send something (unregistered) that cost $2 all up to post is unethical and bordering on a scam.
Don’t worry about the “free postage” you are as of now OFF my shopping list.
Jim

I will also be in his home town in 2-3 months due to work commitments.
I have absolutly NO qualms about going toe to toe in the middle of Smith st if the seller so desires it:angel:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

accumulator

I think Nancy had some big drama's with him Trout,i'm pretty sure she mentioned it on the other forum more than once.

stevo1962

His negative feedbacks speak for themselves
It\'s not about who you know it\'s about what you know

trout

I recived this from the seller;
Dear pommystockman,its not a scam as up front with chargesI did not wrongI pay rent staff etc like all businesses - ********

I sent this, I hope this is the end of an unfortunate episode.

Hi again,
Don't worry I will NOT be leaving any feedback for these transactions, that would just be vindictive and wrong.
I spend on average 15-20k a year on coins and numismatic supplies; it is unfortunate that you will no longer be getting any of that business.
Nothing personal about this, it is purely a business decision and you don't come up to scratch like my other suppliers.
I would suggest that you review your postage charges and practices and you could well do better with your internet based sales in future.
I wish you well with your future endeavours.
Regards
Jim
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum