eBay Name and Shame?

Started by ChrisM, January 16, 2013, 12:12:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

ChrisM

Mine is '************'

I purchased 2 sets of Unc $1 coins and a $1 proof on the 29th December 2012.

I asked for combined postage which was all ok and I paid for the coins as soon as I recieved the updated invoice.

Everything is going fine at this stage. I ask when shipping will likely occur and I was told just after new years (no issues being the crazy time of year).

On the 5th of Jan 2013 after hearing nothing from the seller I decide to ask her whats going on and I get this reply:

'Hi

It was paid on the 29th December 2012. The Business days/Postal Office open days have only been 2nd, 3rd and 4th January since you paid. I will be posting it on Monday.'


Next the 7th rolls around and I get this message:


'Bare with me- I have misplaced the 1988 Kangaroo Mint- will hunt further today- it will show up!!!!! If I can't find it I will send your current parcel with roo to follow :-)'

I replied with ok thanks for letting me know

I get this in return:

'Hi

I still can't find the mint 1988 Kangaroo

Can I tempt you with a 1988 $1 proof as replacement if it remains elusive?

Cheers'

That last message is very important. As I didn't ask or berate for that message, however it is alleged that I have been later on.

Obviously I accept the coin as it is worth more.

It is at this point the parcel is marked as 'Shipped' (7th Jan)

On the 10th of Jan I check the Tracking number I was sent to see that the parcel has just been accepted at the sellers local Post Office, 3 days after the alleged sending of the parcel. If you go back you can clearly see that she states previously that she would send the parcel on the 7th. She did not.

I await my parcel now which arrived yesterday on the 15th. I check everything and to their credit it was packaged really well. I then notice the proof coin I ordered (not the replacement) is missing. Being that it is late I left replying until today.

After contacting the seller I get a few different excuses but she states she will refund the coin. I was unhappy at this solution and wanted the coin I paid for. Unfortunately this wasn't going to happen so I asked for my refund. Which I promptly got.

This is where it gets a little wierd. Not only have I been lied to the whole time during this transaction I come to learn she has been pulling the same stunts with another ebay member.

These are the watered down replies:

Me: Hi,

I recieved my coins yesterday and unpacked them all today.

I have all my coins apart from this one. Could you please explain to me why this is?

Thanks


Seller: Hi

My records show I ticked it off and packed it. Could you count up your coins and double check the peace coin in the sets-They sometimes get confused. Let me know as I repacked your box 3 times and checked because of the missing Roo which was driving me to distraction trying to find.

If it is still missing let me know. Let me know also if you intend bidding on anything currently as I can slip a replacement in with that mail. Otherwise I will need to send a replacement.

Thanks

Seller again (before I had a chance to reply): Hi

If it is still missing I will just give a refund. Okay


Cheers

****Now according to the ebay chap I spoke to this is very suspect****

Me:
I have triple checked everything.

All the coins I recieved are in 2 x 2 Adhesive holders or 2 x 2 Staple holders.

Your add clearly states:

AUSTRALIA 1986

INTERNATIONAL YEAR OF PEACE $1

PROOF

in HOLDER with Gold Pouch

The photo shows the coin to be in a clear perspex container with a blue background.

Thanks

Seller: Hi

So is the coin missing or just the gold pouch? Or did you expect to receive the coin in perspex?

The photo was taken through the perspex of the proof set. The coin will be in a holder- can you count how many holders you have?

let me know. I can't understand why I checked it off. I will issue a refund if it isn't there as I do not have another available of this coin.

Thanks

Me:Hi,

I think I have been fair in relation to the delays and missing coins (this one and the replaced unc).

I would much rather have the coin that I purchased rather than a refund.

You claim you posted the coins on the 7th of January 2013, we both know that this is incorrect. You sent the coin on the 10th Jan 2013 as indicated by both the time/date stamp on the parcel (which is issued when you actually pay and post the item) and also by the tracking number which you supplied.

I am unsure as to what the delay was as your communications in relation to the postage was false. I paid and purchased this item on the 29/12/2012, nearly 20 days ago. Your add stated postage 'Will usually post within 3 business days of receiving cleared payment'. Due to the time of year I could understand the coins not being sent to the 2nd or 3rd of January but to leave me until the 10th of Jan is poor form on your behalf.


I do not want to leave bad feedback and hurt your score, I just want what I paid for and I will be happy. I will leave the ball in your court.

Thank you.

Seller: Hi

When I pack the coins I mark them posted so I know what I have left to pack on eBay. I put these parcels in the local post box near my home - that means they are not scanned until they hit the central post office after collection by the mail truck hence the delay in them being on the system. Sometimes these articles do not get scanned until they hit the mainland- that does not mean I sent them on the mainland but it is the first time they get scanned by a post office. I believe this depends on which route the mail truck takes and which port the freight boat leaves from. The Central Post office is on the other side of the water and the freight boats that take the mail can leave from either side. If it leaves from the central post office side, my parcels are logged on the computer system in Devonport Tasmania. If the boat leaves my side, they do not get logged untill they hit the city of destination.

You also stated you paid for the coins on the 29th December which is a Saturday. The 31st December 2012 and 1st of January 2013 was a Post Office Holiday in Tasmania. Then we had the Devonport Cup (horse racing)- also a holiday.

As I stated I could not find the 1988 Mint set roo and I spent some time searching for it. I informed you. I offered replacement of that coin. The 1988 mint roo is a $5 retail and catalogue value. Your replacement is a $15 Catalogue and retail value 1988 $1 Roo Proof Coin. That was a $10 compensation for the delays as I spent time finding the original coin, which showed up two days after I posted your parcel and which I also offered to you in the event you did not want the proof coin.


You may choose to be careful of claiming my communications are false. You may say "I allege your communications are false..." but the way you have said it could actually cause you trouble in your future communications with other people. At law it is classed as possible defamation. I know this as I am doing my post graduate law degree- ny Juris Doctor. So I say it in kindness if you are angruy about something someone has done just say "I allege your communications are false ...."

I am happy to give a full refund on your entire order. Just follow the returns directions on eBay and send the coins back. It seems the holiday delays and the lost coin delay and the $15 replacement coin have not been adequate and a refund for the order is more in order.

I am still unclear if you received the correct number of coins in holders as it appears you are suggesting the peace proof $1 1986 comes in a perspex case- it does not. It is in a holder. It is possible I did not put the gold pouch in as I packed all your coins in bubble wrap layers in an empty plastic Ferrero Rocher Case inside your box for extra protection. Could you let me know the precise number of peace coins and coins in holders you have received.

Thank you

****At this point I am thinking apparent post grad law student has no clue what defamation means. All the evidence I used clearly shows she is lying about the postage date****

It gets real nasty from this point on and I will not relay any further messages. It took 3 phone calls and a warning from ebay for this member to stop messaging me. She dropped to the level of calling me a homosexual and that I love to kiss my boyfriends. For what reason I do not know but this is the kind of person you are dealing with.


Photo of the postage label from the LPO:



Use caution

trout

ChrisM, A bloody lawyer :kez_11:
Why not come clean and tell you that they hadn’t been posted and the dozy bugger lost the coin.
Up Front is the only way to be on eBay, its easy painless and you don't have to try and remember the BS you gave a buyer.
I have had this type of thing happen to me and I simply just accept the fact that the seller is a moron and never deal with them again.
If it takes me more than 2 emails to resolve something I wipe them off my buying list and just accept the fact that I have been screwed over (Again :dash1: )
mark this one up as a loss and try and forget this moron ever existed :good:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Robster

Wow Chris- who would have thought in the gentle hobby of Numismatics that things could become so complicated. Whilst I understand your angst, thankfully the sum of money is not huge and you now know not to deal with this seller again.!
 My dear wife always refrains from purchasing from Ebay a month each side of Xmas for this very reason.! Public Holidays and the general chaos of Xmas always seems to throw the whole system into chaos. I have some life-long friends in Devonport and I assure you they are not all bad.!
Perhaps I could apply for a law degree in Nigeria (anything goes there- so I can help with any problems in the future).!  Hoping this does not diminish your obvious enthusiam.!! :angel:
\"Everything in moderation, including moderation\".

accumulator

I been the recipient of the abuse & name calling thang myself,it gets up their nose more if you remain calm & just state the facts as you have done Chris,lets ebay see what sort of people they really are & on most occasions ebay/paypal will side with you.

enworb


Fordprefect

Quote from: 'enworb' pid='6480' dateline='1358323087'This thread is doomed...
Short and to the point.....
Telling the truth or what you believe is the truth
is not a defence in litigation of a Claim of Defamation.
Rob the Elder

trout

This thread is doomed...

Why is that Matty?
A similar thread is on "The other site" and has been a worthwhile thread, started by one of our mighty moderators that has the respect and love of all of us :good:
As long as there is NO name calling and BS in the posts and there is nothing to defame the seller without proof, I can't see a drama.
It is a great “heads up” on dodgy eBay operators and helps to keep the buggers honest.
Anyway Mark will keep a tight reign on this and drag anything that will harm him screaming and struggling out the back of the server and put it down "With Prejudice"
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

enworb

The thread on CCF identifies PMD sellers. A whole different kettle of fish. Disputes, petty or not should remain private IMO. No harm in telling a few people who you may be closer friends with but putting it on a public forum is getting into the danger zone.

Steveqld

Quote from: 'trout' pid='6485' dateline='1358325264'This thread is doomed...

Why is that Matty?
A similar thread is on "The other site" and has been a worthwhile thread, started by one of our mighty moderators that has the respect and love of all of us :good:
As long as there is NO name calling and BS in the posts and there is nothing to defame the seller without proof, I can't see a drama.
It is a great “heads up” on dodgy eBay operators and helps to keep the buggers honest.
Anyway Mark will keep a tight reign on this and drag anything that will harm him screaming and struggling out the back of the server and put it down "With Prejudice"

When it comes to costs it is irrelevant whether the poster is telling the truth.  Even if they eventually win in court they would only be awarded costs on the standard basis which is a LOT less than an indemnity basis.  If it doesn't proceed to trial there are costs having your own solicitor write letters on your behalf.  

More likely the parties negotiate an outcome where both parties bear their own costs.

Goldseeker

I have had one bad transaction from an already mentioned seller in this topic and I will not buy from that seller again as a result.

I actually sold two coins today on EBay to the same buyer but I didn't show/list anything about combining postage in either of the sales.   I phoned the buyer, introduced myself and informed him that only one lot of postage would be required.   The buyer appreciated that.

All I am waiting for now is payment and the coins will be on thier way.

May I make this point.   Defaming or naming bad traders could result in trouble for the monitors of this forum.   Most of us have seen three forums close before and I am not keen to see this one fold due to legal threats and/or action.
Message rec\'d from Jens Coins 18 Jul 23: 
Bruce Mansfield passed away today 18 Jul 2023 – Acute Myeloid Leukemia


markn

OK.  I've deleted the seller ID's.  No naming names or seller ID's or linking to feedback profiles.  Linking to PMD sellers is one thing, because we can all see the images of their "errors" and laugh at them accordingly.  Other issues, like the ones raised here are best sorted out between you and the seller/buyer.  We're all only getting one side of the story and I am not putting myself or PPH at risk of legal action because a forum member decides to have a go at someone on eBay.  Sorry if you don't like that but that's the official foot going down.  If you want to share eBay ID's use the PM function or the email function.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

trout

Quote from: 'markn' pid='6493' dateline='1358330366'OK.  I've deleted the seller ID's.  No naming names or seller ID's or linking to feedback profiles.  Linking to PMD sellers is one thing, because we can all see the images of their "errors" and laugh at them accordingly.  Other issues, like the ones raised here are best sorted out between you and the seller/buyer.  We're all only getting one side of the story and I am not putting myself or PPH at risk of legal action because a forum member decides to have a go at someone on eBay.  Sorry if you don't like that but that's the official foot going down.  If you want to share eBay ID's use the PM function or the email function.

Fair enough.
whatever keeps the site alive and healthy works for me :good:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

ChrisM

Hence the reason I asked permission. All good :)

ChrisM

Although I understand the concern, especially with the one side of the argument bit. In my case it is crystal clear, I can't lie about the postage (or the so called defamation) as it is all listed clearly by ebay. Purchased on the 29th/12, shipped (apparently) on the 7/1, really shipped on the 10/1, recieved 15/1.

The information about their handling time is added by each seller. It is a pretty clear cut case and the only thing that would be up for discussion would be the messages. I am happy to screenshot them all but I don't want to go down that path.

All I was trying to do is keep people safe and not turn this into a poop slinging match, however as on most forums there is always negative people that offer no real insight. Markn I can appreciate your need to remove the names and I do thank you for atleast giving it a go :)

Nevol

A Platypus is a duck designed by a committee ( anon)