PCGS submissions, Grading Opinions

Started by trout, December 05, 2013, 02:04:40 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

trout

The important thing for me is that they FIX this problem.
I haven't had ANY dramas with PCGS in the past and this will in NO way deter me from sending further submissions in the future.
The point of me bringing this problem up is so that other people with a similar problem may send an email regarding it as well to PCGS.

One lonely email from a person who has less than 200 coins graded would mean "Diddly Squat" to a company this large, Yet a few emails from other people MAY make them rectify this.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

nealeffendi

I am sure the service isn't perfect.  But, I don't get your attitude here, you're pushing all of the blame onto PCGS while a portion, at least, lies with the buyer who should understand WHAT they are paying for.  Which, clearly in this case, they did not.

Mark, I have read and re-read both trouts comments and the PCGS page on the Secure service and for the life of me I cannot see where Trout doesn't see what he is paying for. PCGS claims the images are an important tool for identifying if the coin is as it is claimed to be, so if Trout has no image then what security does he have?
As for using Skype to contact PCGS; I don't know if Trout has Skype (I don't), or knows how to use it (I don't), but I do know that the US is on summer holidays and with the 4th of July and the weekend he is unlikely to get much response.
Any chance that PCGS staff has dropped the ball because they have gone into holiday mode?

markn

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='54140' dateline='1404610597'Mark, I have read and re-read both trouts comments and the PCGS page on the Secure service and for the life of me I cannot see where Trout doesn't see what he is paying for. PCGS claims the images are an important tool for identifying if the coin is as it is claimed to be, so if Trout has no image then what security does he have?
As for using Skype to contact PCGS; I don't know if Trout has Skype (I don't), or knows how to use it (I don't), but I do know that the US is on summer holidays and with the 4th of July and the weekend he is unlikely to get much response.
Any chance that PCGS staff has dropped the ball because they have gone into holiday mode?

I don't necessarily think he has gotten entirely what he's paid for.  The point I am making is that the images are a VERY SMALL PART of the secure plus service level and that trout has paid $5 for secure plus NOT FOR IMAGES.  Which he thought he had.  If you want decent images you're going to need pony up for the trueview service (which is awesome) or send your coins to me (along with adequate compensation).

As to their response via email, I really have no idea.  I wouldn't even bother trying to contact them via email, just ring them and speak to a real person.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

trout

QuoteAny chance that PCGS staff has dropped the ball because they have gone into holiday mode?
A very good point :ok:
This submission was shipped on the 3rd of July.

QuoteI don't necessarily think he has gotten entirely what he's paid for. The point I am making is that the images are a VERY SMALL PART of the secure plus service level and that trout has paid $5 for secure plus NOT FOR IMAGES.

:agreed:
A bit like paying for a Pie and sauce and not getting the sauce.
I bit of a bummer but you can still eat the pie.
You would however next time you went to the pie shop ensure that they added the sauce in the bag with the pie though:angel:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

markn

Quote from: 'trout' pid='54147' dateline='1404612161':agreed:
A bit like paying for a Pie and sauce and not getting the sauce.
I bit of a bummer but you can still eat the pie.
You would however next time you went to the pie shop ensure that they added the sauce in the bag with the pie though:angel:

The analogy that sprang to mind to me was buying a salad roll and they put mangy limp cucumber on it.  Sure, they gave you the cucumber but you'd rather they'd put fresh stuff on it or not done it at all.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

echidna

Quote from: 'emu666' pid='54099' dateline='1404589317'
Quote from: 'echidna' pid='54088' dateline='1404560843'I believe that apparent dig to be due to the coin being struck through some foreign material. It's not a bagmark or a planchet problem so the coin is gradable in that respect.
If that really is graffiti it is a problem though.
I'm surprised you sent it over in the first place.

No it was bought slabbed from a big ANDA/PCGS dealer.
Yes it really is graffiti 8/8/14
Its currently at PCGS as a warranty.
They have had it for 5 months.

emu666

Quote from: 'echidna' pid='54151' dateline='1404613435'
Quote from: 'emu666' pid='54099' dateline='1404589317'
Quote from: 'echidna' pid='54088' dateline='1404560843'I believe that apparent dig to be due to the coin being struck through some foreign material. It's not a bagmark or a planchet problem so the coin is gradable in that respect.
If that really is graffiti it is a problem though.
I'm surprised you sent it over in the first place.

No it was bought slabbed from a big ANDA/PCGS dealer.
Yes it really is graffiti 8/8/14
Its currently at PCGS as a warranty.
They have had it for 5 months.

OK. I really wouldn't have expected you to send one over with a problem like that.
I've heard they take a long time for a warranty submission.

trout

I have just received a coin back from NGC in a baddy bag :dash1:

The peculiar thing is I cracked it out of a PCGS slab Graded at MS64.
Here is the pic's of the PCGS MS64 coin.

http://www.numisbid.com.au/Browse/PCGS/5669671/

Here are a few pics of the "Body Bag"



Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

robbiegal

looks damaged to me in the then 2012 photo
and still looks damaged to me in the 2014 now photo

trout

I am thinking of putting it in some acetone for a while and see if I can get the stains off.
Otherwise this IS at least a MS64 coin, I could send it to NGC for "Conservation" but it would not be worth while .
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

robbiegal

I reckon it will be stained irreparably

get yourself a crisp new one mate ... let it go to where body bagged florins go - the 'seconds album'

emu666

Quote from: 'trout' pid='54338' dateline='1404987854'I have just received a coin back from NGC in a baddy bag :dash1:

The peculiar thing is I cracked it out of a PCGS slab Graded at MS64.
Here is the pic's of the PCGS MS64 coin.

http://www.numisbid.com.au/Browse/PCGS/5669671/

Here are a few pics of the "Body Bag"






The moral of the story is


***************
Avoid problem coins
***************

trout

QuoteThe moral of the story is
NO moral NO story simply an observation Feathers.
As this is a poopy browny colored mark and not the usual Green gunky stuff  I thought is was just toning and was pretty disappointed with the grade from NGC.
The large majority of my coins I send to PCGS and am quite happy with their grading's and was quite stunned when this came back in a fair dinkum boddybag :(
This is what was on my desk when I got home this afternoon from Pannawonica.

Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

serial

Don't you just love getting packages :) any you want to show of with your new light?

trout

Quote from: 'serial' pid='54355' dateline='1404991363'Don't you just love getting packages :) any you want to show of with your new light?

:)
Talk about Christmas in July :dance::dance2::dance:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum