PCGS submissions, Grading Opinions

Started by trout, December 05, 2013, 02:04:40 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

nealeffendi

Quote from: 'echidna' pid='54033' dateline='1404472893'PCGS images are sometimes very poor - even shocking bad.
I've had similar.
There is nothing you can do.


Do consumer protection laws (Australian, US, Californian) cover this? Would you be entitled to a refund of at least the photography charges and perhaps the full slabbing fee as the coin would need to be removed from the slab to properly image.

echidna

Quote from: 'serial' pid='54053' dateline='1404530921'weird I submitted one 5/21/2014 and it was posted 6/18/2014 but mine was a voucher / secure/ regular
what service level did you use?


This one is a warranty submission - submitted on 12 feb.
And its a shocker.
I have no confidence in them.
I've even had grades cancelled by a third (outside) party who had nothing to do with the coin in question.
Sounds crazy but its true.

trout

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='54078' dateline='1404555867'
Quote from: 'echidna' pid='54033' dateline='1404472893'PCGS images are sometimes very poor - even shocking bad.
I've had similar.
There is nothing you can do.


Do consumer protection laws (Australian, US, Californian) cover this? Would you be entitled to a refund of at least the photography charges and perhaps the full slabbing fee as the coin would need to be removed from the slab to properly image.

I am more worried about some "Homer Simpson" type character taking my carefully looked after coin and chucking it in on that contraption and not even bothering to center the image.:dodgy:
I have NO idea what is going on at PCGS at the moment but besides the images debacle, They are creating NEW designations for coins (eg PR? DC and PR? Proof for older decimal coins?

Here is an even worse one:dodgy:

http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/29866304.html
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

echidna

Quote from: 'trout' pid='54080' dateline='1404556569'
Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='54078' dateline='1404555867'
Quote from: 'echidna' pid='54033' dateline='1404472893'PCGS images are sometimes very poor - even shocking bad.
I've had similar.
There is nothing you can do.


Do consumer protection laws (Australian, US, Californian) cover this? Would you be entitled to a refund of at least the photography charges and perhaps the full slabbing fee as the coin would need to be removed from the slab to properly image.

I am more worried about some "Homer Simpson" type character taking my carefully looked after coin and chucking it in on that contraption and not even bothering to center the image.:dodgy:
I have NO idea what is going on at PCGS at the moment but besides the images debacle, They are creating NEW designations for coins (eg PR? DC and PR? Proof for older decimal coins?


Here is an even worse one:dodgy:

http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/29866304.html

I believe Mr Magoo is currently employed there.

nealeffendi

Does PCGS forget that their company is 100% dependent on the confidence of collectors in their professionalism? Professionally handled (no fingerprints or fumble fingers), professionally graded (consistency is king) and professionally imaged.
I have nearly 100 coins of slabable quality, until I'm certain that PCGS have their act together the first batch won't be leaving Australia.

echidna

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='54083' dateline='1404559303'Does PCGS forget that their company is 100% dependent on the confidence of collectors in their professionalism? Professionally handled (no fingerprints or fumble fingers), professionally graded (consistency is king) and professionally imaged.
I have nearly 100 coins of slabable quality, until I'm certain that PCGS have their act together the first batch won't be leaving Australia.

Exactly right.
Fingerprints will show up in 5 years.
Looks great in the slab now though.
I would also wonder how they handle coins in general.
Even talking over coins will result in spotting.
I'm holding on to my raw collection too...

trout

QuoteI believe Mr Magoo is currently employed there.
I may make an expensive phone call and ask why the image standard has turned to crap.
Given that this submission was delayed , I would have imagined that they would have taken more care.
I am pretty disappointed when each of these decimals cost me nearly $30 each to be graded and they didn't even check the images.

Feeling pretty "Jaded" with PCGS at the moment , With a total cost of $1165.10 to get 43 coins graded ALL with crap pic's at $5 each that is $215 in wasted money in my opinion :dodgy:
I have another 20 coins in the system with PCGS and if these come back with the same problems I will "Dump" PCGS and use NGC in future .
I am rather concerned that if they cannot even bother to check the images, ARE they being diligent with the grades as well :angel:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

echidna



Here is an example their excellent grading.
Graded MS63RB.
Was is Homer or Mr Magoo ?
Perhaps the three stooges...

wwwww

Trout, those look like PCGS' free pics, PCGS offer a photography service, it's called TrueView and costs $10/coin. These photos are higher quality.

Echidna, PCGS slabbed that 1/2D MS63RB? It has material damage from a planchet flaw and graffiti, it should be a no grade.

echidna

Quote from: 'wwwww' pid='54089' dateline='1404561113'Trout, those look like PCGS' free pics, PCGS offer a photography service, it's called TrueView and costs $10/coin. These photos are higher quality.

Echidna, PCGS slabbed that 1/2D MS63RB? It has material damage from a planchet flaw and graffiti, it should be a no grade.

Yes the 1914 is worthless.
PCGS have had it for 5 months as a warranty submission.
No response.
The wonderfull ANDA dealer sold it to me as ex mint roll too.
No names though....

trout

QuoteGraded MS63RB.
 Was is Homer or Mr Magoo ?
 Perhaps the three stooges...
Maybe they thought the "graffiti" was part of the design, Because other than that the grade is pretty "Spot On" :Laugh2: :dodgy:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

echidna

Quote from: 'trout' pid='54091' dateline='1404561350'
QuoteGraded MS63RB.
 Was is Homer or Mr Magoo ?
 Perhaps the three stooges...
Maybe they thought the "graffiti" was part of the design, Because other than that the grade is pretty "Spot On" :Laugh2: :dodgy:

Maybe the great ANDA dealer who sold it as ex mint roll influenced the grade.
Sounds crazy but this sort of thing goes on.
In other words I would suggest that some big dealers and collectors can and do influence grades.
If anyone disagrees I can provide evidence.
No names though...

nealeffendi

WE WANT NAMES!! (pretty please)
The thing the less than honest dealers fear is naming and shaming.
The coin isn't worthless (still a desirable coin) but not worth a hefty price.

echidna

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='54093' dateline='1404563041'WE WANT NAMES!! (pretty please)
The thing the less than honest dealers fear is naming and shaming.
The coin isn't worthless (still a desirable coin) but not worth a hefty price.

No names sorry.
I believe that I can provide the name via a PM if you want  however.

trout

QuoteTrout, those look like PCGS' free pics, PCGS offer a photography service, it's called TrueView and costs $10/coin. These photos are higher quality.

These pic's are NOT free Walter, they cost $5 each.
IF you choose NOT to go the "Secure" option you get No pic's, But the submission is $5 less per coin.
I am starting to think that PCGS is getting TOO big and cocky and are forgetting about the basics.
These buggers are charging TOP dollar at the moment but NOT producing the goods as far as value for money spent lately, Are they getting complacent or are WE as collectors ?
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum