PCGS submissions, Grading Opinions

Started by trout, December 05, 2013, 02:04:40 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

emu666

Quote from: 'echidna' pid='54088' dateline='1404560843'

Here is an example their excellent grading.
Graded MS63RB.
Was is Homer or Mr Magoo ?
Perhaps the three stooges...

I believe that apparent dig to be due to the coin being struck through some foreign material. It's not a bagmark or a planchet problem so the coin is gradable in that respect.
If that really is graffiti it is a problem though.
I'm surprised you sent it over in the first place.

markn

Quote from: 'trout' pid='54097' dateline='1404564092'These pic's are NOT free Walter, they cost $5 each.
IF you choose NOT to go the "Secure" option you get No pic's, But the submission is $5 less per coin.

You do realise the "Secure" option isn't all about the pics don't you Trout?  Read this page (and I know is says "high quality images") but there's a lot more value there for your $5 than the crappy images.  

http://www.pcgs.com/secureplus.html
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

markn

Quote from: 'echidna' pid='54088' dateline='1404560843'Here is an example their excellent grading.
Graded MS63RB.
Was is Homer or Mr Magoo ?
Perhaps the three stooges...

Are you sure it's graffiti and not struck through something?  If it is graffiti they've really dropped the ball and you should do a guarantee submission.  I have to ask though, did you actually see an image of this coin before you bought it?

As to the tin-hat theories about Australian dealers being able to influence grades.....well the Australian market is chicken feed to them, I'm not sure why they'd even consider manipulating the grade on one coin for a market that is a mere blip on their radar.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

markn

No company is perfect, and you're all posting up isolated cases and not posting up the hundreds of times they've done it right.  I suggest you email them with your issues, or better still Skype their support line and speak to a real person.  Whenever I've spoken to them they've fixed up the problems I've had.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

trout

QuoteNo company is perfect, and you're all posting up isolated cases and not posting up the hundreds of times they've done it right

Why would I post every time they get it right?
That is precisely what I pay them to do and I expect nothing less.
Up until a couple of months ago the pic's were not real flash but "Adequate" , My last two submissions pic's are total Crap that's why I posted the examples.
I have NO problems with their grading and their service so far But the total lack of quality control to let these ridicules pic's to be used is a real concern to me.
Like most business if one area gets away with dropping the ball the entire company's reputation is in jeopardy.
I don't think my piddely little 12 and 31 coin submissions is an isolated case as they were graded 4 days apart.
I have NO idea of what is going on in the imaging department But it needs to be nipped in the bud ASAP :ok:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

emu666

I'm a bit confused here.

Aren't the images taken just so the coin can be identified if anyone does a certificate verification? I believe images are normally only taken when the coin is submitted under their Secure Plus. On occasion we have had images appear on our modern (non- secure plus) submissions [which I consider a bonus as we have not paid for them] but never on bulk submissions.

trout

QuoteI suggest you email them with your issues

Yes, done that .
Here is a copy of the email sent.

Hi there,
I have recently viewed the images for my latest submission and some of the work done by your imaging department is quite frankly appalling.
Here are a couple of examples

http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/29866303.html
http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/29866304.html

My previous submission was not much better either.
As I am charged an extra $5 per coin for "Quality Images" I feel that for my last 43 coins I have been charged for a service that has NOT been adequately provided .

Can you give me the reason as to why the quality of the images has become so low lately ?

Kind regards
James Hudson
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

markn

Quote from: 'trout' pid='54111' dateline='1404601872'
QuoteNo company is perfect, and you're all posting up isolated cases and not posting up the hundreds of times they've done it right

Why would I post every time they get it right?

Because then we'd have a real idea of how well they are doing.  Right now we've got you here making a lot of noise about some coins that aren't being handled the way you'd like.  Compare this with others who are submitting 100 times the coins you are and are not posting here at all.  As I said, PCGS are not perfect, they make mistakes.  Perhaps the others are working with PCGS to sort out the errors to improve the level of service they offer AND get the result they are paying for.  Trout, if you're not happy get on the phone (or skype) to them and get it sorted out.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

markn

Quote from: 'emu666' pid='54115' dateline='1404602689'I'm a bit confused here.

Aren't the images taken just so the coin can be identified if anyone does a certificate verification? I believe images are normally only taken when the coin is submitted under their Secure Plus. On occasion we have had images appear on our modern (non- secure plus) submissions [which I consider a bonus as we have not paid for them] but never on bulk submissions.

Well I'd have thought that but it does say on the PCGS secure plus page that the service includes "High-quality images available at no charge at Cert Verification".  Clearly the images are not high quality.  But conversely it does say specifically that the images are included in the service at no charge.  So you're going to have trouble arguing that even with the crap images that you're not getting your money's worth.

Oh and trout appears to be sending his moderns under the secure plus level (which seems a waste of money to me).
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

trout

QuoteOh and trout appears to be sending his moderns under the secure plus level (which seems a waste of money to me).

I had a couple of "Mules" in that last submission that were NOT mine and I considered that the images were appropriate at the time.
I have NO problem paying the extra $5 as long as I get what I pay for :ok:
Like I said the first 100 or so coins I submitted had "Adequate" images, This is a recent problem and I hope they sort it out.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

markn

Quote from: 'trout' pid='54122' dateline='1404603714'I have NO problem paying the extra $5 as long as I get what I pay for :ok:

Well you've paid for secure plus and you got that.  The images are (apparently) provided free of charge, and it looks like you've got "free" quality too.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

nealeffendi

Quote from: 'markn' pid='54102' dateline='1404597967'
Quote from: 'trout' pid='54097' dateline='1404564092'These pic's are NOT free Walter, they cost $5 each.
IF you choose NOT to go the "Secure" option you get No pic's, But the submission is $5 less per coin.

You do realise the "Secure" option isn't all about the pics don't you Trout?  Read this page (and I know is says "high quality images") but there's a lot more value there for your $5 than the crappy images.  

http://www.pcgs.com/secureplus.html

That raises lots of red flags to me, how do they laser scan a coin if 90% is outside the image area (as in those images Trout put up).  
The blurb also contained some weasel words like "can" (can be used to perform a metallic composition analysis of your coin). In the sage words of Yoda you do or you don't and can implies that it is only done on an ad hoc basis. They also don't tell the potential customer exactly what standard of analysis is done, for all we know they lump .900 and .925 silver together so they won't know for example if wartime D and S coins were struck on the wrong silver or bronze pennies were struck on old or new stock.
If they record laser surfacing and metallic composition then does the customer have access to this information that they paid for.
The crappy images are important and they are not "free" as the blurb claims as they incorporate the cost somewhere (no such thing as a free lunch).
Maybe Trout should email the contact at the bottom of the form to ask them WTF went wrong and how will they rectify THEIR mistake,not just the cost of slabbing but the $150-200 for insured return post.

markn

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='54125' dateline='1404605068'Maybe Trout should email the contact at the bottom of the form to ask them WTF went wrong and how will they rectify THEIR mistake,not just the cost of slabbing but the $150-200 for insured return post.

I am sure the service isn't perfect.  But, I don't get your attitude here, you're pushing all of the blame onto PCGS while a portion, at least, lies with the buyer who should understand WHAT they are paying for.  Which, clearly in this case, they did not.  Yes, he's sent over a couple of emails but if it really is the "end of the world" which it seems to be judging by the amount of noise he's making, why hasn't he got on the phone to them?
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

trout

Quotewhy hasn't he got on the phone to them?

a/
It's the weekend ( Saturday in the States) and there will be nobody at PCGS to answer my call.

b/
I don't intend to spend more money on an international phone call when an email is quite sufficient.

I don't know why you are getting "Grumpy" at me Mate , PCGS is NOT a "Sacred Cow" They have stuffed up on this occasion and  I cannot see why I can't make a bit of "Noise" about it.
They are My coins and I spent My money to have them graded and I am NOT happy with the service provided on this occasion.
If NGC did the same thing to me I would be equally as unhappy with them as well :ok:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

markn

Quote from: 'trout' pid='54130' dateline='1404606573'I don't know why you are getting "Grumpy" at me Mate , PCGS is NOT a "Sacred Cow" They have stuffed up on this occasion and  I cannot see why I can't make a bit of "Noise" about it.
They are My coins and I spent My money to have them graded and I am NOT happy with the service provided on this occasion.
If NGC did the same thing to me I would be equally as unhappy with them as well :ok:

I am not grumpy with you.  I am providing a contrary opinion to yours.  Why should you be able to bitch about PCGS without someone disagreeing with you?

Here's my vastly contrary experience to PCGS.  I have sent over coins to PCGS that number into the thousands and I can think of five times that they've screwed up completely.  And on every single occasion they've made good with their mistake.  Even to the point of re-slabbing some coins for free to denote a variety that they did not recognise when the coins were first graded.  

And regarding your excuses for not ringing them?  Well it can't be that important to you if you can't make time for it.  And you can use something like Skype to ring them for free.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog