Australian Grading sevice

Started by trout, March 22, 2013, 08:21:16 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

trout

Ok I have been away in Kal doing nightshift and have been doing some brainstorming.
Just about everyone would love to see an Australian grading service started but we all have concerns as to the bonafides of that service.

We have heaps of eminently capable collectors and dealers out there and the coins really don’t need to be slabbed , they could be simply housed in a sealed saflip (like the early ICCS coins) see pic.

This would keep the costs down (especially the postage costs) and the turn around time would be way faster.

What would make this really work in Aus would be to have the graders name on the coin packaging this would make sure that the coins were graded consistently and accurately, after all the grader's reputation would be at stake every time a coin is graded and there would be NO company name to hide behind.

I am certain that we have honest people out there that are more than capable of pulling this off and the start up costs shouldn’t be that great.
Any thoughts on this.
[attachment=1466][attachment=1467]
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Robster

Welcome home Trout, a good topic to finish the week.!
When I renewed my interest in coins 12 months ago I was quite frankly stunned by the price of slabbed pre-decimal coins.! The idea of purchasing these items evaporated very quickly for someone like me who has finished his working life.!
Thanks to forums such as this I now have an appreciation of the various grading systems but more importantly the level of coin that I own.! Would I use an affordable system such as you suggest- absolutely- would said system help to improve my meagre collection- possibly- could I afford to have the 300 odd pre-decimal coins individually assessed-highly doubtful.!
But that is me.
For a younger Australian collector who has a expendable income I can think of nothing better than well graded coins provided by an Australian company whose main aim is to improve the numismatic baseline for the future.!
Would these new collectors use this system- or would they be influenced by the allure of shiny slabs they see in every coin shop and auction they participate in.!
My personal view is you have a fantastic idea- Ten Years too late.!:idea:
\"Everything in moderation, including moderation\".

trout

I personally have NO interest in collecting bulky slabs or for that matter Mint packaging.
This sealed saflip concept that ICCS used fits in perfectly with the way I and Many more collectors store their coins (In albums), Let's face it a sealed saflip in a pvc free album is by far the best way to preserve the integrity of a coin.

Quoteyou have a fantastic idea- Ten Years too late

It is not my idea or concept, although a good one.
It may be 10 years too late but better late than never.

I am so "Over" our coins being graded by some unknown and un named Yank that probably only has a basic appreciation of Australian coins but has graded US coins for decades.

There are many Australian experts and collectors that DO have an intimate knowledge our coins and for the betterment of this hobby should "Step up" and knock these US usurpers out of the Australian market.
I would envisage a product that would have a ANDA grade as well as a Sheldon grade given this would also assist collectors with the cross-referencing of these grades.

At about $50 a coin + postage + long delays the Major TPG’s are quite frankly way out of the reach of 99% of Aussie collectors and to me is a ridicules waste of funds that could be spent on other coins.

However IF an Australian based grader could come up with a better solution at a lesser cost I would imagine it would take off like a rocket.

All we need is to have a few competent and honest graders to get their heads together and "Step UP" and give this a crack.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Fordprefect

Quote from: 'trout' pid='10217' dateline='1363906961'
Quoteyou have a fantastic idea- Ten Years too late

It is not my idea or concept, although a good one.
It may be 10 years too late but better late than never.
It was tried 17years ago.
Failed to interest Australian Collectors.
If you can find any of the coins certified by them,
Grab them. There grading was tougher than  
Aussie ANDA standard adjectival or Sheldon System.

ACGS - Australian Coin Grading Service est 1996
Link - http://www.pacificrimcoins.com.au/articles.php?id=9
Rob the Elder

keldaw

good on ya trout , great idea:idea::idea::idea:

 i am all for it , and would love to see it happen .

   ,, kel ,,
take care because we care ..

trout

Quote from: 'Fordprefect' pid='10229' dateline='1363912657'
Quote from: 'trout' pid='10217' dateline='1363906961'
Quoteyou have a fantastic idea- Ten Years too late

It is not my idea or concept, although a good one.
It may be 10 years too late but better late than never.
It was tried 17years ago.
Failed to interest Australian Collectors.
If you can find any of the coins certified by them,
Grab them. There grading was tougher than  
Aussie ANDA standard adjectival or Sheldon System.

ACGS - Australian Coin Grading Service est 1996
Link - http://www.pacificrimcoins.com.au/articles.php?id=9

Unfortunately Chris Buesnell didn't have the advantage of the internet the way it is today.
17 years ago the internet was only used by a small percentage of collectors and was nothing like it is today.
Many Many collectors now embrace the internet and most of us are members of various internet forums so the grapevine is now far larger than it ever was.
Also 17 years ago I doubt that ANYONE was in the least bit interested in TPG graded coins.
Chris was a man way ahead of the times and unfortunately didn't succeed in this.
However I tend to believe that the time is now right for this to succeed, as many collectors are looking at getting coins graded but are disenchanted with the way things are run purely by overseas graders.
The cost and time involved at the moment to get coins graded is ridicules and from my experience many of the coins I have bought “Slabbed” are overgraded.
Nothing wrong with coins graded ANDA style, the tougher they are graded the better as far as I am concerned.

We need another Chris Buesnell to have a crack at this.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Australian coin

haha now available AC grading service, everyone's a winner!

now grading in
'shiny'
'pretty'
and
'road kill'

Fr45h3R

Whilst I would be glad to use the services of an Australian based TPG, most Australian collectors / dealers who I see as experts, a number of them who view this forum, already use either PCGS or NGC themselves.
Is this an indication that they are not comfortable with their own grading ? I certainly don't think so.
They are merely providing the consumer an independent grade which can be used to set a price.
Would you pay anywhere near the MS65/Gem price for a raw coin based on photos alone, either on eBay, or one of the online dealers ?

Quotefrom my experience many of the coins I have bought “Slabbed” are overgraded.
One of the challenges with the Sheldon grading against the ANDA grading is the tendency to want an easy conversion.
Whilst the collectors and dealers have come up with a guideline, each coin has to be based on its own merit.
Are all MS65 coins, ANDA Gems ? No they are not. The reverse, are ANDA Gems all MS65 ? This is where it gets tricky ;)
Either way, what you might attribute an MS63 grade to on a raw coin, could actually come back MS65, MS63, or even AU58...(maybe even the dreaded 'details') from even an Australian based TPG if one is ever set up.

robbiegal

uuuummmmm

am I right if I say that Chirs never did third party grading himself
the coins have always been sent over to PCGS or NGC (?)
The only australian based TPG business that I know of having a go at starting up was walter eigner's slabbing services

correct me if I am wrong

accumulator

I think Chris & Walter were in it together ?,I'm sure i read that somewhere.

trout

QuoteOne of the challenges with the Sheldon grading against the ANDA grading is the tendency to want an easy conversion.
 Whilst the collectors and dealers have come up with a guideline, each coin has to be based on its own merit.
 Are all MS65 coins, ANDA Gems ? No they are not. The reverse, are ANDA Gems all MS65 ? This is where it gets tricky

I agree with that but this is where the + and - come into play with the ANDA system.
AU58 could be described as AU+ and so on with the other grades.

most of our resident experts are fully aware of this and I certainaly don't want to be the one to tell them how to suck eggs.

In my opinion the ONLY reason that the Sheldon sytem is being introduced into Aus is as a direct result of the overseas TPG's putting this system of grading on their slabs.
I have absolutly NO problem with which system is being used as long as it is being used by an Australian TPG.
Surely we can do this we arn't stupid and the costs of grading should be far less and become more acceptable to the average collector.
Lets face it the costs of slabbing a coin IS passed onto the buyer, less cost = more buyers :ok:
It may take a while before an Australian tpg becomes recognised but so did the major tpg's take a while to be recognised.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

robbiegal

interesting reading the link to Chris's bio
i wondered why I'd see him at the shows in Orange
never knew that he was a local!

drakesterling

Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='10274' dateline='1363937270'uuuummmmm

am I right if I say that Chirs never did third party grading himself
the coins have always been sent over to PCGS or NGC (?)
The only australian based TPG business that I know of having a go at starting up was walter eigner's slabbing services

correct me if I am wrong

Chris started up ACGS in 1996/97. You can read about it and look at his ads in early Coin Reviews from that decade. You can even read the letters section, where Chris and Klaus Ford sparred regarding his grading service.

trout

if you have the chance check out the unslabbed/raw coins on Numisbid.
whoever does the grading for these is pretty "spot on" in my book.
:good:

It just goes to show that an Aussie CAN grade coins consitantly and honestly :dance2:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

drakesterling

Quote from: 'accumulator' pid='10276' dateline='1363937939'I think Chris & Walter were in it together ?,I'm sure i read that somewhere.

No, Chris started ACGS ten years earlier. Walter started up only a few years ago. The ICCS flips which trout refers to are almost identical to the ACGS flips. As convenient and cheap as they are, they are pretty easy to counterfeit, look like crap, and are not durable.

If Australia's collectors or dealers started up their own grading service, they'd condemn the Australian coin market to a tiny corner on the world stage. World coin markets would not accept our home-grown TPG. Australian coins would not sell well overseas in these Australian flips. Trading coins with world collectors would be difficult. Most importantly, there will always be a faction of the coin community here in Australia who would not take the Australian TPG seriously.

Not withstanding the issue about cost (both in dollars and time), there’s simply no reason to reinvent the wheel. PCGS and NGC are established names with worldwide reputation. If collectors and dealers want to appeal to the greatest market and reach the most customers, they’ll always need PCGS or NGC to get the best value for their coins.