Grading "Toned" coins

Started by trout, February 28, 2013, 02:12:33 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

trout

I have always considered "Toning" as a form of environmental damage although sometimes it can be quite stunning and beautiful, It is still a form of environmental damage in my opinion.

I find it hard personally to gauge the quality and amount of remaining lustre on these types of coins and make it hard for me to put an accurate grade on them compared to a coin that isn't toned.
For example an AU58 coin that has toned over the years could be given an MS grade because the toning may hide the minor defects in the toning and design that made the coin an AU58 coin in the first place.
I would imagine that the tiny almost imperceptible bag marks in the lustre (I call it Lustre bruising) would be impossible to detect on a heavily toned coin.
I am not talking about the “rainbow “ type toning on Copper coins but the oxidation toning that affects silver coins.
This oxidation MUST be destroying the original mint lustre on the coin and therefore should affect the grade.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

stevo1962

The toning on a coin could send the grade in either direction depending on eye appeal and depending on who is grading it  ,so many variables to consider when grading a coin
It\'s not about who you know it\'s about what you know

Bigfellani5

Toning has absolutely no bearing on the grade on the coin. Grade measures wear not toning. Toning affects eye appeal and therefore affect value. Eg an unc penny with full luster will have greater value than a toned unc

drakesterling

Quote from: 'Bigfellani5' pid='8671' dateline='1362034006'Toning has absolutely no bearing on the grade on the coin. Grade measures wear not toning. Toning affects eye appeal and therefore affect value. Eg an unc penny with full luster will have greater value than a toned unc

Correct. Toning doesn't affect the grade of the coin. In addition to wear, the numerical grade (at least by PCGS' standards) measures 1) wear, 2) strike, and 3) bagmarks.

(I will note, as an aside, though, that I believe in certain circumstances particularly ugly toning does, in fact, reduce the numerical grade of a coin. Although this doesn't appear to be PCGS' official stance (ie, it's not in their grading standard), they still appear to look at toning in a commercial context and take extreme cases into account).

Particularly attractive toning may earn a coin the "+" designation.

wwwww

It should be noted that toning acquired slowly over a long period of time will have a negligible effect on lustre. Unless this form of toning is unattractive, PCGS generally awards such coins a slightly higher grading as strong lustre beneath an attractive tone almost always enhances the coin's eye appeal.

Intense toning acquired over a short amount of time will dull the lustre of the coin, such coins would be penalised if the lustre is worse than what would normally be expected for the grading it would otherwise have been awarded.

trout

I received this coin a couple of days ago.
It still cartwheels under all that toning, The toning is that dark grey type with a few hints of gold in it (not overly attractive in my opinion)

Technically it is a nice coin but aesthetically not so good.

[attachment=1406][attachment=1407]
[attachment=1408][attachment=1410]
[attachment=1409]
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

robbiegal

funny
i'll buy a parliament house florin with tone' and pass over a fully brilliant one - not just about price but I adore the colours that these coins show up in
i collect the 'lower' grade ones for colour not grade

your florin sounds nice - gun metal grey (?) with gold hues

trout

i'll buy a parliament house florin with tone' and pass over a fully brilliant one

I must be a bit of a Magpie cos I just love em fully lusturus and shiney.:yahoo::dance2:
I do however have many diferant hues and grades, When I open the pages of these coins the fully lusturus coins realy grab your attention over the toned coins.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

robbiegal

too true
the BU are stunning coins

old parliament house is my favourite building in canberra
when we first moved here i was forever over there
and if no security were around
i'd do the old Gough on the front steps, 'God may save the Queen but nothing will save the Governer General' - just to entertain the family, they (the family and the odd  tourists) eventually got bored with my acting ha ha

keldaw

can this coin be graded please ??

[attachment=1559][attachment=1558]
take care because we care ..

stevo1962

Here's an example of one of my coins with toning where I dont
think it detracts from it too much

[attachment=1560]
It\'s not about who you know it\'s about what you know

Australian coin


trout

Quote from: 'stevo1962' pid='10928' dateline='1364427653'Here's an example of one of my coins with toning where I dont
think it detracts from it too much



Nice coin Stevo :good:
I call this the start of the end if the coin isn't protected from anymore toning.
I would say that this coin has been in a Dansco type album for a while and been affected by the chemicals in the cardboard, That is why only the outer parts of the coin are affected.
If the toning wasn't there then this coin would (In My eyes) be a stunning piece instead of a Great piece :ok:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Possie Ron

Silly question But. Why do coins tone differently ?. I have maybe 100,  1964 pennies. All copper/gold to average brown. One stands out as Rich Red. Any ideas why ??
Life is what happens while you are busy making other plans.

ausjack

Just the mixing of the metals I'd say Ron..metal doesn't mix evenly from my understanding :good: like melting down a car, it's not all one metal and once it's molten it seperates with alloys floating and heavier metals sink..ya know saphires are like that..you shake the sieve side to side then back and forth then till it's in a mound then flip it up side down and the saphires will(touch wood) be sitting on top and that's just wilh little rocks :) true ay Kel :good:
A wise person knows there is something to learn from everyone.