Dot above S Pennies

Started by autocoupler, May 10, 2024, 01:42:12 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

autocoupler

I know there is a connection between some 1930 pennies with Indian obverse and the 1931 penny with Indian obverse and dropped 1 in relation to a dot over S in the obverse legend.

So, is it just a coincidence that the 1920 penny with English obverse and dot above bottom scroll also has the dot over S in the obverse legend? 

Could there have been a long term Mint employee on the loose with a hammer and punch?  :shok:



As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

fred lever

Hi Auto, could be the same master die source.
I have forgotten all I knew about the dot S obverse, would have to look at my research again to comment further.
I'm buried in other research at the moment and can't do anything about coins.

Here is a suggestion, look closely on the 3 obverses for another common die mark.
If found that would confirm a common master source.
Fred.

Dead Coin

Hi AutoCoupler,

I'm new to this forum - all forums actually! Never joined a forum in my life until now.

I was wanting to say a general gidday to everyone but couldn't work out how to start. 

I only picked up on you as a slight link to errors. I'm not a mad coin collector but always had an eye for the unusual.

I got a 20c in my tuckshop change as a kid and noticed it didn't ring when I flipped it - it sounded 'dead'. It had a distinct line all the way through the milling. Wasn't a double side and didn't look tampered with (why would you unless you wanted to make a H/H or T/T fake), so I stuck it in a safe place, so safe that I haven't seen it again!

When I drove busses for BCC a lifetime ago I was counting the change one night and found a 'dancing man' $1 that had slipped the die and is missing a good 70% of the milling with a lovely bulge in it's place. I stupidly passed it around to show off to friends a few times and a mate dropped it which put a nick in the bulge. Dipshit me! 

I took it to a coin shop back then and the guy offered me $10 for it at the time but I think I chose wisely to step out of the shop with my $1. I've since found a few other cud errors in change, nothing special.

Anyway, I didn't mean to write a tome, but would be ever gracious if you can offer any insights into the forum we are on and how to use it. I'm happy to post a few pics of the $1 coin if you, or anyone is interested to see a photo.

Thanks,

P.S. Apologies if I don't respond regularly or go 'AWOL' for a bit, it's just that life is...

nealeffendi

The dot on the 1920 English near the S is in a slightly different position to that on the 1930 and 1931 Indians in the images.
So not a chance it was master die related going back to when the 2 masters (English and Indian) were created.
And if it was some privy mark by a guy with a punch then for what purpose?

Triggersmob

Welcome Dead Coin, I remember getting a couple of those split 20c coins. It was around the time the Centenary coins were starting to appear and got me interested in collecting. If you had a few coins in your hand and shook them, you could hear something wasn't right. I stupidly split them with a screwdriver.
Steve

OFEC count = 258

echidna

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='129215' dateline='1715370867'The dot on the 1920 English near the S is in a slightly different position to that on the 1930 and 1931 Indians in the images.
So not a chance it was master die related going back to when the 2 masters (English and Indian) were created.
And if it was some privy mark by a guy with a punch then for what purpose?

The dots above the S on the 1920 is an offset die clash I'd say.
Similar to the offset die clashes visible on Perth mint halfpennies circa 1954.
Not the same die as the 1930 and 1931.

nealeffendi

Quote from: 'echidna' pid='129218' dateline='1715390604'
Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='129215' dateline='1715370867'The dot on the 1920 English near the S is in a slightly different position to that on the 1930 and 1931 Indians in the images.
So not a chance it was master die related going back to when the 2 masters (English and Indian) were created.
And if it was some privy mark by a guy with a punch then for what purpose?

The dots above the S on the 1920 looks like an offset die clash I'd say.
Similar to the offset die clashes visible on Perth mint halfpennies circa 1954.
Would an offset die clash only leave a dot? There also seems to be a pimple on the inside of the loop of the S and also another outside and opposite that pimple. Also some sort of change of colour streak sweeping towards the rim, but is that just an optical illusion? Are there any other signs of a die clash on either side? I can't see any and usually there would be obvious signs of clashing below the kings chin or between NN.
I'll get to the bank next week and then examine mine to see if there are similar marks.

fred lever

Welcome Dead Coin!
If you mouse click on the little "search" box at the right-hand top of the home page, then type in the words     split planchet.
The search function in this site will then think about it for a while and then show a list of all posts  having to do with split coins, underweight coins, skinny coins, and so on.
Happy reading!

Once you get the hang of the site you could start a topic yourself just find the most relevant topic heading, figure out how the hell to start a post in that, and do your best!
Don't let age or inexperience put you off I'm 80 and still manage to post on various sites about my hobbies.

Cheers, Fred.

echidna

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='129219' dateline='1715418112'
Quote from: 'echidna' pid='129218' dateline='1715390604'
Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='129215' dateline='1715370867'The dot on the 1920 English near the S is in a slightly different position to that on the 1930 and 1931 Indians in the images.
So not a chance it was master die related going back to when the 2 masters (English and Indian) were created.
And if it was some privy mark by a guy with a punch then for what purpose?

The dots above the S on the 1920 looks like an offset die clash I'd say.
Similar to the offset die clashes visible on Perth mint halfpennies circa 1954.
Would an offset die clash only leave a dot? There also seems to be a pimple on the inside of the loop of the S and also another outside and opposite that pimple. Also some sort of change of colour streak sweeping towards the rim, but is that just an optical illusion? Are there any other signs of a die clash on either side? I can't see any and usually there would be obvious signs of clashing below the kings chin or between NN.
I'll get to the bank next week and then examine mine to see if there are similar marks.

" />

I'm seeing three dots above the S.
And the spacing appears to be the same as per a denticle pattern.
This suggests a light offset die clash to me.

An offset die clash will appear as a series of dots if its light.
If its heavy then you often get a denticle pattern.

Normal die clashes are different and I cant see any evidence for one of these.

nealeffendi

Yes, I can see those other 2 dots now that you have pointed them out. So the white patch in the upper loop and the streak heading to the rim; are they just optical illusions? That's the hard part when analysing images, you can't loupe and rotate a coin to see what is what.

echidna

" />

I'm pretty sure that the white patch is planchet streaking.

autocoupler

Welcome Dead Coin. Have been buried in model railway construction since my initial post and can only reiterate the advice of other posters in this thread. Sounds like you are interested in varieties and such, of which there is any amount of info within the relevant subjects etc. Have fun.

Thanks to the other posters for their replies. I would never have noticed the additional two markings on the 1920 English obverse penny if echidna and neal had not pointed them out. Now, they are oh so obvious.

My reference to an errant Mint worker was just a bit of fun, but to be remotely true, that person would have needed to be employed at multiple Mints for his/her handiwork to appear on both Indian and English obverses. Am I wrong in this thinking?

Cheers All
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

nealeffendi

Hi Auto, no the mint employee only needed to be at Melbourne where all the dies for 1920 were either finished in the case of the soft unturned dies from India or were fully struck and finished in Melbourne for all subsequent Geo V pennies with the exception of some 1922 penny dies London sent to Perth (presumably the wide date dies).
But again even if he had the opportunity to punch a dot near the S there is little reason to.