Chrome Plated Die Strikes

Started by echidna, April 26, 2022, 08:13:11 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

echidna


Basilstate

Not sure/don't know Echi,your original Post with the 1952 6d rings a bell thou.,there was a post on one of the Stamp Forums in the early days of Ebay,2000/2001,commenting on early 1950's Oz Cr. Dies.

nealeffendi

Very nice florin. Fantastic obverse, wonder why it only made 64?
Dr Briggs is the expert on chrome dies. I'd contact him.

autocoupler

echidna, your coin appears to display a semi mirror surface. That's what I look for anyway.
I'm no expert on chrome dies, but I always thought this to be one. Sent it to the plastic factory and it came back attributed as cleaned. 

I still believe it is the result of a chrome die striking.

As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

nealeffendi

hi auto. Your florin could be both struck from chrome dies AND cleaned as well. Really can only tell by having some genuine uncleaned chromes to compare your coin against as you tilt and rotate the coin to see how it reflects. Even then it is hard to be sure and '54s are the worst for this. It is also possible that the "experts" in California screwed up once again and erred on the side of caution (or their corporate bottom line... if they misgrade a cleaned coin as MS then they are liable to pay out, but if they misgrade the other way you might be tempted to fork over more money for a resubmission).

echidna

Hi Auto

I'd agree with Neal - looks like a chrome strike that has had a light clean.
Might just be the pic that makes it look cleaned though.
These chrome plated strikes are very hard to photo up properly due to mirror surfaces.
Do you have the PCGS pic ?

autocoupler

Hi Neal and Echi. Thanks for your comments. Yes, the coin could be cleaned but from my limited knowledge, I honestly don't think so. The surfaces are free of hair lines, and in the hand don't look tampered with to my eye.

Below is a link to the PCGS pic, infuriatingly, even though I paid for a true view pic, it didn't happen.

Cheers

PCGS Certificate Verification Coin Details for Cert #39506920
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

nealeffendi

Did they refund the full grading fee for failure to fulfill the contract? Or a free future submission by way of apology? That image is useless in assessing the coin. That is the through slab photo that HK PCGS uses, are you sure the coin went to California and not HK? Did you submit the coin yourself or through a dealer as some use HK and offer cheaper submission fees.
A clean with a microfibre cloth doesn't leave hairlines.

autocoupler

I submitted through a second party, and did receive a credit upon my request, and have no issues with them. 

I simply assumed the coin went to the US for processing, but it was only one of many that didn't get the true view pic I asked for. There were also four high grade variety rarities which had to be returned due to being wrongly attributed. 

The submission was during the height of Covid, and all was put in order in the end, but it's no fun waiting double time.

Just to get back on topic, also no fun receiving a verdict of cleaned when you suspect it's because they don't understand chrome die strikings.
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

echidna

" />
Pretty sure this one is chrome.

autocoupler

Looks to exhibit mirror surfaces. Quite some brushing on the Obverse, nice grade though. 

Showing my ignorance here but, do they consider brush marks when grading a coin?
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

echidna

Hi Auto

It looks like its been brushed but that's die polishing.

autocoupler

Sorry echi, I didn't express myself very well. I did mean polishing marks, just wondered if they take it into account when grading.

I always thought these were the result of chrome plated die striking. Any thoughts?

 




As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

echidna

Hi Auto

Its hard to tell without the coin in the hand.
But they all look like Chrome die strikes to me.

Re the die polishing, my guess is that PCGS view it in a similar way to a weak strike.
So up to and including MS65 or 66 it wont affect the grade.

autocoupler

As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!