Manders Florins & varieties

Started by echidna, April 09, 2016, 02:00:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

echidna

" />

" />

" />

" />


Out of the four dates in the series, 1927 & 28 are the most common followed by 31 with 26 very hard to come by.
In terms of high grade, I have seen only three or four better grade examples (EF/aUNC)  - these were all 27s.

How to ID them:
Quickest way is to check the bottom of the R in REX.
On a forgery it is above the E.
Genuine slightly below.

Varieties:
Some die variations exist mainly in the shape of the star and roo's ears.
This can be seen on the pics above.
Another variety appears to be a beaded obverse vs denticles.
The difference cannot be seen except on high grade examples:

" />


What are they worth ?
I've seen average examples sell for $150 each.
The Saxton example at Nobles went for about $380 - it was aEF but horribly cleaned.
Downies had a set of four estimated at $250 in their 25/10/2011 auction.

With patience they can be bought cheap on Ebay where they appear occasionally as bullion.

gnome

I had a crack at Triton's example, went a bit high even for me. I also believe the chinese may have brought in other denominations beside the 1928 shillings. Still working on that one. :)


echidna

Its a nice example at a good price.
1931 is really quite scarce.
These were popular up till a few years ago but interest has dropped off.

autocoupler

Thanks for the info echi and Basil
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

Basilstate

No worries Auto,i have a 1928 MT Florin somewhere and will post a Pic. when i find it.

Further to all the Info. out there on the Net apparently the investigating Police knew how they created them but did not make it Public.
New investment casting techniques is the probable method but some Coin Gurus back in the 1960's are certain they had a Press & Die of some kind.

Varieties/Errors  in general have taken a dive on Ebay the last few years compared to the early 2000's,little interest unless the Coin is at a giveaway price.

Basilstate

MT(i think?) Florin given to me pre Ebay by a local Dealer.Appears to have all the markers but don't know alot about them.



echidna

Nice one.
This is the version with "big ears" on the roo and wonky star.

Basilstate

Thanks for the clarification Echi.,yes the Roos neck and head are almost detached.
In amongst a pile of Florins its still hard to pick,they did a great job.

The 'R' in Rex is a good marker,Thanks,and the low Dot after 'P in IMP is well documented.

The MT Florins went for good money in the early days of Ebay Oz, shame the Ebay market is now flat along with most Variety/Error Coins but may bounce back if the younger collectors get interested.

echidna

Yeah, I remember average circulated examples selling for circa $150 back in about 2010.

ttkoo

Thanks for the info Echidna, very interesting. Checked all of mine, all real. I will have to do some study, as not surprisingly I have never heard of them. I'd like to know just how prolific they were back in the day.
The Ox moves slowly, but the Earth is patient.

Mister T

I think David Briggs' florin book talks about how many might have been made. I don't recall but I think they were pretty scarce even back in the day.

echidna

IIRC "The Shadow" states 11000 pounds which would mean a mintage of 220000 if my math is right.

ttkoo

That is still a fair few. I want one.
The Ox moves slowly, but the Earth is patient.

Mister T

I've seen a few on sale on ebay over the years but not too often.