Indo Chine Francaise coins

Started by AussieSilver, April 06, 2016, 02:59:15 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

AussieSilver

[attachment=3434][attachment=3435][attachment=3436][attachment=3437]Friend went to Vietnam years ago and emailed me saying he was going to buy some coins and would i like some and this is what he got me . Always wondered if they were legit as there are a few fakes out there but they were cheap he got them for melt from memory about $16.00 each so no great loss i guess

[attachment=3440][attachment=3439]
BazK

gnome

Yeah look like the same dodgy's I have. Got given a whole pile of them awhile back myself :)

AussieSilver

Thks for confirming that gnome i have a silver testing kit on its way just to check but am wondering is there any other way to check if coins are made of silver that you can do at home ?
BazK

Triggersmob

Steve

OFEC count = 258

gnome

Only said they looked similar, wouldn't take that as a firm confirmation,  mine definitely aren't silver.

JeffH

Measure size reasonably exactly -vernier calipers suggested to get thickness accurately and weigh them.
Do the same with a silver coin of known provenance.
Then reasonably simple maths to compare densities. May give a clue.
Thinking is dangerous, it makes you think. That\'s why many people avoid it.

gnome

I'll get some pics done of mine tomorrow

AussieSilver

thks for the reply's everyone , will give the ice test a go this arvo . No calipers but will try and find what they should weigh .Tried the ring test and was spot on compared with a two and a half guilden . Would like to see your fakes to compare tho .
BazK

gnome

There's a full page of them, just took a couple of quick ones. Most dates are covered even the rarer ones. Wont be a minute.



These ones are definitely not genuine, :)

AussieSilver

thks for that GN the date sure is a give away on that 1917 , think i am seeing difference with the BARRE as well as overall missing detail yours looks kind of flat plus top of crown on yours touches rim and not with mine , not saying that mine are the real deal tho but i did do the ice cube test and both mine and test subject a koala bullion coin both melted at same rate ? Getting scales on W/E so will check that out then
BazK

AussieSilver

got to weigh my coins on weekend 27gm which from what i could find on internet is what they should be , wondering Gnome if you might know what your fakes weigh please
BazK

gnome


gnome

Just checked mine. Given you some wrong info, mine is for the 20cent coins and weigh between 4.39gm to 4.92.  Checking your weight in the book and  it is for the piastre it should have a weight of 27 gms. Appologies should have checked the denomination in the first place. :) Only looked at the top pics.

AussieSilver

[attachment=3446][attachment=3447]:laugh2: all's good thks anyhow , friend who loaned me scales also had this fake thinks made of steel
BazK

Sapyx

I would not hold out much hope of them being genuine. The vast majority of FIC piastres you find for sale in the market stalls of Vietnam are base-metal fakes.

Had a fellow come along to one of our coin club meetings a few years ago, had a handful of these he wanted verification of. I had a magnet with me and offered to test them.

CLUNK.

Had trouble getting the magnet off again, they were solid steel with some kind of silvery plating.
Waste no more time arguing what a good man should be. Be one.
    Roman emperor Marcus Aurelius, \"Meditations\"