Please grade my 1927 Florins. (another pic added)

Started by Triggersmob, December 26, 2012, 10:29:50 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Triggersmob

Just wondering what you think this might grade at and what the current CV is? Thanks.

[attachment=710]
[attachment=711]
Steve

OFEC count = 258

enworb

I would say it is around the Fine mark and only worth the silver in it. The catalogue value in the 2013 Maccas book for Fine is $18 although that is very optimistic.

Bigfellani5

Hi steve
I would go a bit better than fine but in saying that I scrap coins better than this one.

Triggersmob

I was just wondering, because the 2x2 that it came in, had VF+ and value at $38.
Didn't seem right to me. Back into the silver scrap pile it goes.
Steve

OFEC count = 258

robbiegal

Hi Trigger
Looks to be close to VF having what may appear to be the four sides of the CD in the band on the crown. The 1927's usually come up in better grades but when it comes to values - i often see a florin that grade go for near $30 or more on ebay then i'll put up a nice EF or better and I'm lucky to get the $15 start price that I have. If it has an interesting error like a smashing die crack or a die clash then it may have more error value. I find that the 1927 Parl. House Florin has major variations in sale price versus intrinsic silver value. Still think it is one of ozzies' best coin designs to date!

trout

VF cleaned.
Don't let that phase you NONE of these Canberra florins deserve the ignomy of the scrap bucket.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Triggersmob

Sorry, it's not a scrap bucket as such, just my small pile of extra silver coins.

Thanks for the info guys. :)


Actually, I forgot to check the one I already had in my collection.
Maybe I should add this one to the scrap (swap) pile instead.

[attachment=716]
[attachment=717]

Steve :)
Steve

OFEC count = 258

trout

Quote from: 'Triggersmob' pid='5117' dateline='1356576119'Sorry, it's not a scrap bucket as such, just my small pile of extra silver coins.

Thanks for the info guys. :)


Actually, I forgot to check the one I already had in my collection.
Maybe I should add this one to the scrap (swap) pile instead.




Steve :)

nice EF coin mate.
Even the ones of mine that don't make the grade for the album gets a 2x2 and lives in my "spares" album.
The lowest grade I have seen these at is Fine.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Triggersmob

Quote from: 'trout' pid='5122' dateline='1356580971'
Quote from: 'Triggersmob' pid='5117' dateline='1356576119'Sorry, it's not a scrap bucket as such, just my small pile of extra silver coins.

Thanks for the info guys. :)


Actually, I forgot to check the one I already had in my collection.
Maybe I should add this one to the scrap (swap) pile instead.




Steve :)

nice EF coin mate.
Even the ones of mine that don't make the grade for the album gets a 2x2 and lives in my "spares" album.
The lowest grade I have seen these at is Fine.

EF? That's surprising. I thought the other one looked better.
Shows how much I know LOL.
Steve

OFEC count = 258

trout

EF? That's surprising. I thought the other one looked better.
 Shows how much I know LOL.


The first place to look for wear on these is on the orbs of the mace's.
these are the first areas to get worn.
Your first coin had a lot of wear on the orbs and the second coin had a lot less wear.
This is the first place I look on these coins, the second place I look is at the steps to acertain the strike 3 steps is great and goes down from there as far as strike goes.
Another place to check for wear  is on the shell at the top of the design on the reverse.
the Kings ear and beard on the obverse .
Also the top orb on the crown on the obverse is another teltale :good:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Triggersmob

I see what you mean, the orbs of the maces are much better on the second coin.
Thanks.
Steve

OFEC count = 258

trout

Quote from: 'Triggersmob' pid='5130' dateline='1356583991'I see what you mean, the orbs of the maces are much better on the second coin.
Thanks.

With such an intricate design on these coins I would have to say they are the easiest of Aussie pre decimals to grade :good:
Or I may just be a bit biased because I like and own so many of these.:blackeye:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Triggersmob

Steve

OFEC count = 258

trout

Quote from: 'Triggersmob' pid='5153' dateline='1356600084'I had a strange feeling you light like them.

It's all good mate, If you don't ask , You will never know.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Bigfellani5

The thing is I get more ef's than I can handle and auction pricing only gives scrap value to I often scrap those as well