Which 1952 penny serif is this ?

Started by echidna, February 17, 2014, 01:54:44 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

echidna



Similiar to the wedge but different...
Does anyone have one of these ?
Or can anyone identify it.

eccentric

This illustration has had me puzzled for a while too.  Personally I think it must be the 'square end' coin.  I have never seen any others like it and the 'wedge end' is quite distinctive, with an even slope from the tail to the bottom of the '2'.

robbiegal

pretty sure that it's not a square end
here's a pic of  what I call a square end

r9453

:i_agree: robbie's coin is not the same, it appears to match Renniks "B63C FIG. 2 IN DATE HAS WEDGE TAIL - LEANS TO LEFT (V. SCARCE)". The gap in the "crook" of the 2 is different:



The OP coin appears to match Renniks "B63D FIG. 2 IN DATE NARROWER - TAIL HAS SQUARE END (RARE)".

I'm talking about comparing the photos in Renniks not the descriptions which don't quite gel. Apart from that I can't actually help to identify the OP coin.

My Renniks book is the 2nd Edition 2010.
Two Bob coin collector.

autocoupler

Quote from: 'echidna' pid='41937' dateline='1392564284'

Similiar to the wedge but different...
Does anyone have one of these ?
Or can anyone identify it.

I remember seeing this photo in one of the late Jon Saxton's articles with reference to the wedge serif 2. Have never seen one in the flesh, but if the wedge serif is derived from a die fault, it may be the early stages?
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

gnome

Did I miss something in reference to the late Jon Saxton.

autocoupler

Quote from: 'gnome' pid='86422' dateline='1459395130'Did I miss something in reference to the late Jon Saxton.

He passed away maybe the second half of last year. I didn't know him personally but did read a lot of his research, and appreciated his ability to  deliver clear images accompanied by relevant descriptions in much of his work which made things nice and simple for a novice like myself.
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

gnome

Thanks for that AC, I didn't know. Will be missed.

echidna




Here is another one.
Do doubt another die chipped version of the square serif.

autocoupler

Giving this thread a bump, seemed the best place.

Saw this very interesting 1952A. penny with London reverse on ebay, item 394445668516. The price turned me off though. 

The coin is not described as such, but the 2 appears to have a square die chip serif similar to what is seen on some 1952A. Melbourne reverses. Only one I've seen.

As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

echidna

Caught my interest as well.
Pic is not quite good enough to see whats going on though.
Sort of coin you would take a chance on if the price was right.
But @ $149 no way....