PCGS submissions, Grading Opinions

[markn]

63 or 64bn.

[ausproofs]

I would say MS65BN

[Fr45h3R]

Trick question? Unc details (cleaned)?

[Nightparrot]

64BN for me. These better coins can be very hard to pick.

[wwwww]

Trick question? Unc details (cleaned)?

Yeah it was a trick question, there's something right of the bust (lacquer/glue?) that's had an attempted removal with wiping. Otherwise this coin's got it all, great surfaces, smooth lustre, attractive colour, problem-free strike, quality planchet - I estimated it at MS65RB otherwise.

[stevo1962]

Trick question? Unc details (cleaned)?

Yeah it was a trick question, there's something right of the bust (lacquer/glue?) that's had an attempted removal with wiping. Otherwise this coin's got it all, great surfaces, smooth lustre, attractive colour, problem-free strike, quality planchet - I estimated it at MS65RB otherwise.

Do you think they'd still give it a grade as it doesn't look too bad

[wwwww]

Trick question? Unc details (cleaned)?

Yeah it was a trick question, there's something right of the bust (lacquer/glue?) that's had an attempted removal with wiping. Otherwise this coin's got it all, great surfaces, smooth lustre, attractive colour, problem-free strike, quality planchet - I estimated it at MS65RB otherwise.

Do you think they'd still give it a grade as it doesn't look too bad

They won't grade it, if the damage from cleaning is beyond what would reasonably be expected from normal handling/circulation for the grade then it will no grade. Any sort of odd cleaning (removal of particular residue) can't reasonably expected to occur naturally at an MS level.

[stevo1962]

Latest results and pretty happy with most of them.The
64 pennies were out of the same roll

1964m penny   MS65RB
1964m penny   MS64RD
1964m penny   MS64BN
1964m penny   MS65RD
1964m penny   MS65RD
1964m penny   MS64RD
1964m penny   MS64RD
1964m penny   MS64RD
1964m penny   MS64RD
1964m penny   MS65RD
1964m penny   MS64RD
1922   penny   MS63BN
1936   halfpenny  MS64RB
1922   sixpence  AU55
1934/3 threepence VF35
1928 threepence MS64
1932 florin    VF35

[serial]

Damn could quite get that 66 Rd could u! Nice effort still

[stevo1962]

Damn could quite get that 66 Rd could u! Nice effort still

Yeah I was hopeful but not confident as they all had a few
marks on them

[trout]

Did you get images with these Steve?
Just asking as I have a roll of these as well and would like to see how mine would match up to yours :ok:

[stevo1962]

Did you get images with these Steve?
Just asking as I have a roll of these as well and would like to see how mine would match up to yours :ok:

 The cert numbers haven't been downloaded on the PCGS site yet but although not the best photos but the top 2 outer coins would have graded MS65RD and the bottom right would be the MS65BN
 I'd say the top middle coin would be one of the coins that graded MS65RB


 

[trout]

Here are a few of mine.
I took the images "full frontal" that really don't show the lustre but do show every little defect on the coins.
All these coins have great lustre but I recon MS64RB would be the best to expect ( I am Crap with grading coppers) :dash1:

[stevo1962]

Yeah MS64BN or 63BN would pull them up

[trout]

Yeah MS64BN or 63BN would pull them up

:agreed:
Much easier to get super high grade coppers with the Indian coins :whistle2: