PCGS submissions, Grading Opinions

[robbiegal]

jeepers - did you get that from a roll?
I have never seen one so nice!

[stevo1962]

It certainly looks the goods

[serial]

no I noodled about a month ago from circulation

[robbiegal]

lucky noodle
must of been in nanna's milk tin as it is in far too excellent condition to have been floating around for a decade or so

[serial]

Yeh that's what I figured

[echidna]

http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/31383521.html

Previously in an NGC MS64 holder.

Previous experience with NGC has been very negative.
And generally I'd rate their grading at least one point lower than PCGS.
Happily this one makes up for all the NGC rubbish I have bought in the past.

[stevo1962]

http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/31383521.html

Previously in an NGC MS64 holder.

Previous experience with NGC has been very negative.
And generally I'd rate their grading at least one point lower than PCGS.
Happily this one makes up for all the NGC rubbish I have bought in the past.

That was a very brave move Dave .I have plenty of NGC slabbed coins but don't think I could muster up the courage to risk crossing ant of them over

[Nightparrot]

http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/31383521.html

Previously in an NGC MS64 holder.

Previous experience with NGC has been very negative.
And generally I'd rate their grading at least one point lower than PCGS.
Happily this one makes up for all the NGC rubbish I have bought in the past.

Wondering if u submitted it in the holder or did you take it out?

[serial]

http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/31383521.html

Previously in an NGC MS64 holder.

Previous experience with NGC has been very negative.
And generally I'd rate their grading at least one point lower than PCGS.
Happily this one makes up for all the NGC rubbish I have bought in the past.

Wondering if u submitted it in the holder or did you take it out?

nice one and I am wondering the same

[echidna]

http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/31383521.html

Previously in an NGC MS64 holder.

Previous experience with NGC has been very negative.
And generally I'd rate their grading at least one point lower than PCGS.
Happily this one makes up for all the NGC rubbish I have bought in the past.

Wondering if u submitted it in the holder or did you take it out?

nice one and I am wondering the same

It was removed from the holder.

Must be a reason why NGC graded it 64.
I suspect they dont like toning.

[stevo1962]

I have had results back for this coin.Does anyone want to have a guess

 
 

[serial]

ms63?

[stevo1962]

ms63?

Bought this one off ebay for $90 described as VF-EF but no it's not MS63
 unfortunately

[markn]

AU58?

[Nightparrot]

I agree AU58