NBN Petition

Started by Fulvio, September 11, 2013, 01:44:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

r9453

I must admit I wasn't too fussed with the change of plans. But the copper network is surely cactus, there are still some pit covers with PMG on them!

In regard to FTTN does it sit alongside the existing copper network? Or does it replace the copper between the exchange and the fridge on my street corner?
Two Bob coin collector.

runway

I am a taxpayer living in a rural area and have ADSL it does the job for me I have no cable options nor ADSL2
Rollout of NBN will be done by whatever government is in power just think ourselves lucky we have internet at all I still know folks who can only get dial up access and they pay the same taxes as you and me :(
Buy what gives you enjoyment

Fulvio

Quote from: 'r9453' pid='28089' dateline='1379068123'In regard to FTTN does it sit alongside the existing copper network? Or does it replace the copper between the exchange and the fridge on my street corner?

OK, lets try and do a quickie Dummy's Guide...

First up, ALL the trunks are already fibre. Have been for a long time. So from the point of origin all the way across the oceans to the exchange down the road, its already blazingly fast. Has to be to handle the bandwidth, which is growing astronomically each year.

FTTP extends that fibre to your place. Its all glass, no electronics. Which means even in a major disaster, say a flood for example, it keeps working. FTTP also makes any existing copper or HFC redundant, and it gets decommissioned and presumably sold for scrap.

FTTN chops that off at the knees. They build new boxes at the corner, and terminate the fibre there. The last bit from the box to your place is the existing copper, which is limited to ADSL speeds. The box has to be big enough to terminate the fibre, convert the signal from light to a 50V current and feed it down the wires. Which takes a heap of gear and a bigger heap of power. And makes it susceptible to damage and degradation. Since the existing copper runs from telstra pillars, it will need to be relocated into the new boxes. No way the pillars can do the job.

The savings are almost all in wages. What you save on glass you spend on hardware, imported hardware at that. Oh, and you introduce a new ongoing and not insignificant maintenance and operating cost. Plus, copper is asymmetric. That is, there isn't the room in it for equal-size bandwidth in both directions. So the uplink is a tiny fraction of the downlink. Fine for cruising webpages, but pretty much useless for doing real work which requires data to move in both directions.

Then some years down the track, after its all finished and you discover its crap, it will need to be redone. By then of course, wages will have gone up, so it will cost more to do the job over. Plus all the interim hardware becomes so much scrap metal. The total cost will have more than doubled, and the country will have been uncompetitive for a generation.

But who cares? Abbott will be just another bad memory by then, and political gain is the only game that matters, right? Screw the future as long as you can make yourself look good short term.




Quote from: 'runway' pid='28099' dateline='1379075008'I still know folks who can only get dial up access and they pay the same taxes as you and me

Precisely what the NBN was designed to fix. You shouldn't be a second-class citizen just because of your address. And we've repeatedly seen business can't be trusted to treat people fairly. They will cherry pick the most profitable every single time and screw the rest. That's why it needed to be built by the government. Once upon a time it would simply have been Telstra's job, but previous short-sighted decisions killed that off, didn't they?
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

markn

Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='28108' dateline='1379083503'
Quote from: 'runway' pid='28099' dateline='1379075008'I still know folks who can only get dial up access and they pay the same taxes as you and me

Precisely what the NBN was designed to fix. You shouldn't be a second-class citizen just because of your address. And we've repeatedly seen business can't be trusted to treat people fairly. They will cherry pick the most profitable every single time and screw the rest. That's why it needed to be built by the government. Once upon a time it would simply have been Telstra's job, but previous short-sighted decisions killed that off, didn't they?

I don't want to subsidise the internet of someone who chooses to live where they do.  I am sure they don't want to pay all my additional expenses incurred from living in a city.  So why should I pay for their additional expenses for choosing to live in the country?
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

r9453

Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='28108' dateline='1379083503'OK, lets try and do a quickie Dummy's Guide...

Thanks Fulvio I appreciate your effort. :angel:
Two Bob coin collector.

trout

Quote from: 'markn' pid='28111' dateline='1379106428'
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='28108' dateline='1379083503'
Quote from: 'runway' pid='28099' dateline='1379075008'I still know folks who can only get dial up access and they pay the same taxes as you and me

Precisely what the NBN was designed to fix. You shouldn't be a second-class citizen just because of your address. And we've repeatedly seen business can't be trusted to treat people fairly. They will cherry pick the most profitable every single time and screw the rest. That's why it needed to be built by the government. Once upon a time it would simply have been Telstra's job, but previous short-sighted decisions killed that off, didn't they?

I don't want to subsidise the internet of someone who chooses to live where they do.  I am sure they don't want to pay all my additional expenses incurred from living in a city.  So why should I pay for their additional expenses for choosing to live in the country?

country WA has already "Subsidised" Via Drivers licence levies the stuff ups and infrastructure in Perth on occasion.
WA inc and the Northbridge tunnel come to mind :dash1:
If anyone wants/needs this service then they should dig into their own pockets and keep their thieving hands out of mine:close_tema:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Steveqld

Whether we're capital, rural or regional Australia I'm sure we will all be done over, just some more than others.  (My cynicism also comes from working for the Government)

From what I read the coalition policy is dependent on taking over Telstra's copper cable between the node and premises.  Telstra is unlikely to gift it to the Government so that will reduce the cost benefit from the FTTN option.  Telstra seems to be in a great position hence possibly the increase in share price.

The most significant consideration for me is the amount I will pay for access to the internet, better performance isn't the highest priority.  If I don't pay the "up to $5000" for the premises to node cable then I retain the copper cable.  In that case my performance isn't going to change because I guess the transfer of can only occur as fast as the slowest link.  

If I can remain on my current plan then "they" are getting nothing extra from me for the cost of their installing fibre optic cable to the node.  If they abolish my current plan and make me go on an NBN plan then I will have 90Gb unused at the end of the month rather than 40Gb, no increased speed and it will cost me an extra $720 (approx.)/year.

Not looking good however the coalition policy does not alter the wireless or satellite options for rural or regional Australia so is of no consequence outside the capital cities.

All too much.

Fulvio

Quote from: 'markn' pid='28111' dateline='1379106428'So why should I pay for their additional expenses for choosing to live in the country?

Oh dear. This is unfortunately the way a lot of people think, and its just so wrong, on so many levels.

Firstly, we need the bush. Believe it or not, things happen out there that we actually need every single day. You know, like its where we grow the food you eat? That which doesn't come from some germ-ridden third-world country at least.

Secondly, not everyone can afford million-dollar homes in the city, or rents which exceed their incomes. Its not a choice when you only have one option.

Thirdly, even people who do live in the big smoke occasionally like to travel beyond the traffic jams.

Sorry, but either we're one nation, or a bunch of self-centred city states at war with each other. People in the bush already do it hard, and its not only fair to level the playing field, its also in our own best interest. The fewer reasons we give people to all move to the capital cities, the better.

Quote from: 'Steveqld' pid='28121' dateline='1379121724'Telstra is unlikely to gift it to the Government so that will reduce the cost benefit from the FTTN option.  Telstra seems to be in a great position hence possibly the increase in share price.

Quite. Between them, Telstra and Murdoch will ensure we not only get to pay more than what the libs have said, but we'll continue to pay on an ongoing basis. Then eventually when we reach the point of having to rebuild it in a few years, we'll pay all over again.

This is all a con job, to stuff as much money as possible into their supporters pockets. Always was, always will be with this mob. Kinda sad the other lot are so bent on self-destruction that we find ourselves in this situation regularly.
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

markn

Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='28181' dateline='1379146457'
Quote from: 'markn' pid='28111' dateline='1379106428'So why should I pay for their additional expenses for choosing to live in the country?

Oh dear. This is unfortunately the way a lot of people think, and its just so wrong, on so many levels.

Says you.  I pay more than my fair share of tax and I am entitled to have an opinion on where it goes.  Schools, fine.  Hospitals, fine.  Disability Care, fine.  But subsidising internet for people in remote locations?  I don't think so.

And by the way, I can assure you I do not live in a million dollar home.  Not.  Even.  Close.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

Fulvio

Quote from: 'markn' pid='28182' dateline='1379146896'Says you.

You're a smart, high-tech kinda guy. Here, read this:

http://nbnexplained.org/wordpress/technical-points/the-fttn-first-debate/

You really want to pay for one of these on every street corner?

http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

trout

Quotenot everyone can afford million-dollar homes in the city, or rents which exceed their incomes
Mate if I was offered a mansion in the City for free I would knock it back.
I much prefer to live in the bush where your neighbours actually DO care, NO traffic noise and NO Nosey Busybodies within Cooee :yahoo:

Do I loose wifi connection sometimes YES
Do I get bad TV reception sometimes YES
Do storms do damage around the property that I have to repair myself  YES
Are Australian farmers and Pastoralists considered some  of the most efficient in the world YES
Is there less crime in the bush YES
Do I breath clean fresh air in the bush YES
Can I grow and produce my own Meat in the bush YES
Do we wave to policemen/women and know them by name in the Bush YES
Do we need to spend Billions of dollars just to have a faster internet connection in the bush NO
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

markn

To be honest Fulvio I don't want to pay for any of it.  I am rabidly opposed to governments doing anything that commercial enterprises would do if it was profitable.  I'd rather they (they being both sides of politics) kept their noses out of it and just cut taxes to companies and let them get on with the business of doing business.  If someone can make a buck out of faster internet they'll install it and make money from it.  If, as I suspect, it's not commercially viable in a big sparsely populated country like Australia then so be it.  That's the price we pay for living in a great country.  I for one, would take slow internet in Australia over living in the USA with blinding fast internet any day of the week.  And that's coming from a (as you put it) a smart, high-tech kinda guy.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

Fulvio

Quote from: 'markn' pid='28192' dateline='1379147836'opposed to governments doing anything that commercial enterprises would do if it was profitable.

And there you have it. Two differing world views.

One side says its all about money, and greed is good.

The other side knows that the greedy won't lift a finger for the common good unless forced to.

Lets privatise the post office. The police. Ambulances. Fire Brigades. The armed forces. I'm certain all would be very profitable businesses. Of course they won't provide services in marginal areas, but who cares, right? Let the invaders have the scrub, we'll stop them once they get near our capitals where people can afford to pay for services.

DOH!
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

r9453

Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='28207' dateline='1379151849'Lets privatise the post office. The police. Ambulances. Fire Brigades. The armed forces. I'm certain all would be very profitable businesses.
DOH!

Could we also make every road a toll road?
Two Bob coin collector.

Fulvio

Quote from: 'r9453' pid='28213' dateline='1379152387'Could we also make every road a toll road?

Logical step. Oh, and put Wilson in charge of on-street parking too. Why should people be able to park outside their houses for free?

Now, how do we charge for the air people breathe?
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW