NBN Petition

Started by Fulvio, September 11, 2013, 01:44:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

r9453

I haven't signed it. I baulked when I was asked for my phone number. I'd happily sign a written petition.

I heard the guy on abc newsradio this arvo.

Is this even capable of being tabled in parliament, fulvio?
Two Bob coin collector.

trout

QuoteIs this even capable of being tabled in parliament, fulvio?
I consider it should be tabled in Parliament, Written on dunny rolls and used in the parliamentary Privies :ok::dance2:
Sorry Fulvio I admire you as a collector and you have a great sense of humour, But on this issue I Totally disagree with you Mate :ok:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

runway

I am happy with my Telstra Broadband it is quick and does everything I require
NBN so what I won't get this where I live
I'd prefer this forum be about coins not politics
Buy what gives you enjoyment

Goldseeker

I wonder how people got on before computers, the internet and broadband.

Me thinks people of today are becoming lazy due to the lack of activity of reading, counting and finding things out for them selves rather than siting at a keyboard and having a machine do it all for you.

Sorry, I do use the keyboard and a computer for record keeping etc as the device can do many monotaneous things whereas ones brain needs a rest.

$43BILLION for high speed talk fest link is a load of bunkham.   I saw a roll of fibre optics cable being laid today and on the drum, it read Product Of japan.   So much for creating jobs in Australia.  

If they ever knock on my door to see if I want to be connected, they will be told in no uncertain terms where they can shoeve it.
Message rec\'d from Jens Coins 18 Jul 23: 
Bruce Mansfield passed away today 18 Jul 2023 – Acute Myeloid Leukemia


Fulvio

Quote from: 'runway' pid='27982' dateline='1378986581'I'd prefer this forum be about coins not politics

This issue should not BE about politics. It was a no-brainer from the start, and should have had bipartisan support.

However, since our beloved Dubya-clone now thinks he has a mandate, he's going to dismantle it for political gain, and the price will be paid by everyone in the country for decades to come, even if he gets the bums rush in a few years time.

IF the opposition is strong enough however, maybe, just maybe, they won't gut it to pay for some of the porkbarrelling this mob are grandmasters at.

Oh, and Runway? See up there where it says "Chin Wag"? Nothing in here is about coins.
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

drakesterling

Even under the Coalition fibre to the node plan, homes that want super fast internet (fibre to the home) can still pay $5,000 to get it installed. My view is that if you want 1000mbps fast internet, then you should pay for it. I don't need 1000mbps, so why should an extra $14 billion be spent installing infrastructure I don't need.

My view is simple: If you want speeds as fast as the Labor NBN, you can pay the extra $5,000 to get it connected to your home, but don't expect other tax payers to subsidise your fast internet when 1000 mbps is simply not necessary for me (and most households I suspect).

Let's save the $14 billion and put it to better use, and let the heavy internet users who need 1000 mbps pay for it themselves.

markn

Quote from: 'drakesterling' pid='28009' dateline='1378996434'Even under the Coalition fibre to the node plan, homes that want super fast internet (fibre to the home) can still pay $5,000 to get it installed. My view is that if you want 1000mbps fast internet, then you should pay for it. I don't need 1000mbps, so why should an extra $14 billion be spent installing infrastructure I don't need.

My view is simple: If you want speeds as fast as the Labor NBN, you can pay the extra $5,000 to get it connected to your home, but don't expect other tax payers to subsidise your fast internet when 1000 mbps is simply not necessary for me (and most households I suspect).

Let's save the $14 billion and put it to better use, and let the heavy internet users who need 1000 mbps pay for it themselves.

I'd love faster internet but I agree 100% with everything you've said here.  If there's a commercial need for the sorts of speeds the Labor plan was offering then a COMMERCIAL company would have installed it.  I am sick of my tax dollars being spend on infrastructure of the types that governments and public servants shouldn't be sticking their noses into.  

As a disclaimer here I worked for several years in a government department that was responsible for various forms of industrial assistance.  I saw so much wastage in there because public servants and politicians have NO IDEA about commercial reality.  The idea that these sorts of people handle our tax dollars makes me sick to my stomach.  Stick to healthcare, roads, schools, disability support and the sorts of things governments SHOULD be responsible for.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

trout

Quote from: 'markn' pid='28016' dateline='1379022458'
Quote from: 'drakesterling' pid='28009' dateline='1378996434'Even under the Coalition fibre to the node plan, homes that want super fast internet (fibre to the home) can still pay $5,000 to get it installed. My view is that if you want 1000mbps fast internet, then you should pay for it. I don't need 1000mbps, so why should an extra $14 billion be spent installing infrastructure I don't need.

My view is simple: If you want speeds as fast as the Labor NBN, you can pay the extra $5,000 to get it connected to your home, but don't expect other tax payers to subsidise your fast internet when 1000 mbps is simply not necessary for me (and most households I suspect).

Let's save the $14 billion and put it to better use, and let the heavy internet users who need 1000 mbps pay for it themselves.

I'd love faster internet but I agree 100% with everything you've said here.  If there's a commercial need for the sorts of speeds the Labor plan was offering then a COMMERCIAL company would have installed it.  I am sick of my tax dollars being spend on infrastructure of the types that governments and public servants shouldn't be sticking their noses into.  

As a disclaimer here I worked for several years in a government department that was responsible for various forms of industrial assistance.  I saw so much wastage in there because public servants and politicians have NO IDEA about commercial reality.  The idea that these sorts of people handle our tax dollars makes me sick to my stomach.  Stick to healthcare, roads, schools, disability support and the sorts of things governments SHOULD be responsible for.

:agreed:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Robster

Common sense seems to be the correct answer.!!!
\"Everything in moderation, including moderation\".

Fulvio

Quote from: 'markn' pid='28016' dateline='1379022458'Stick to healthcare, roads, schools, disability support and the sorts of things governments SHOULD be responsible for.

Disclaimer: I worked for the commonwealth, both collecting and disbursing taxes. I also saw immense waste. Towards the end I was assigned a project to track usage of our fleet of commonwealth cars. Once I'd built the system and collected data from the first 250 vehicles, I got reassigned, the project was killed and buried, and a decree came down that everything would now be done in Canberra, and no further projects would be handled at state level. Why? I'm not at liberty to say, but if what I found were in the commercial world, heads would have rolled.

The problem with governments, all governments, is systemic and it makes no difference what they're doing. Whether its building a bridge or running a school or collecting trash, the rot is well and truly entrenched. If it could be excised, the savings would easily pay for a dozen NBN's. But that's never going to happen. And hasn't privatisation been a glowing success? We now pay more for less in every area, including those Mark mentioned as governmental responsibilities.

Regardless, this matter is not going to sink or swim on the basis of our deliberations here. A majority of the population are against FTTN. The Libs will ignore that sentiment, because they are inherently arrogant, and have repeatedly proven it.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/breaking-news/turnbull-brushes-aside-record-nbn-petition/story-fni0xqi4-1226717898111

"Mr Turnbull replied: "Wasn't there an election recently at which nbn policy was a key issue?"". Arrogance, see? No conception of why they actually won, and why it does not give them a mandate to kill this.

Still, nothing will change for at least a year, so at the very least those areas already started, and probably those scheduled to start in the next year WILL at least get built properly. And of course greenfields sites will too from now on, because everyone realises its the right thing to do. So that once again means we'll have a two tier ballsup, with your address determining how well you do, just like with all Mark's examples. Which is par for the course for everything here, isn't it? :(
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

drakesterling

If you ask the question whether people prefer Labor's fast NBN or the Coalition's slower NBN, people will of course say Labor's NBN is better and preferred. But ask them to front up with the cash to pay for it ($5,000 to extend FTTN to the home for each household who wants FTTH), I think you'll find most people would be satisfied with the cheaper FTTN.

Fulvio, I am not sure where you live, but if it is in a suburban area, did you know that you can have the FTTN extended to your home so that you can get 1000 mbps downloads, but this will cost you personally $5,000 out of your own pocket. Are you still keen on the FTTH now, or would you prefer taxpayers to subsidise it for you?

Fulvio

Quote from: 'drakesterling' pid='28061' dateline='1379041956'would you prefer taxpayers to subsidise it for you?

I'm MORE than happy with my cable, thank you very much. And our area will be one of the last to get whichever scheme ends up being built. So I don't care personally.

However, the fact is that the second-rate scheme will cost us double and saddle us with crap for decades.

The copper network is stuffed. Has been for years. 20 years ago when I wanted two extra phone lines, Telstra spent $40,000 putting in a second 80-pair because half of the existing cable was out of commission. That has only gotten worse, because of lack of maintenance.

FTTN needs POWERED boxes on every street corner. Which have to be built, maintained, and powered. Estimates are it will take an extra power station, burning coal of course, to power them.

The claimed speeds for FTTN are a pipe dream. ADSL speeds and throughput are the best they can hope for, on a good day. And that goes down with distance and condition of the copper.

In every single way, FTTN is crap. It is at best a stop-gap, and everyone who has rolled it out has since had to redo it properly. At double the cost.

This idiotic plan is like building a one-way freeway, then having to redo it years later at a far higher cost than doing it right in the first place.

Oh wait.. they already did that, didn't they? :P
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

Steveqld

Certainly a lot of good points being raised and the weight of opinion seems to be against the petition.

I'm quite happy with my current broadband plan but one point being raised is that the general population should not be funding the $5000 needed to connect NBN to a residence.  If I decided to go down the NBN path then I wouldn't have the expectation of others funding it for me.  If I receive a better product I expect to pay for it.  

Like all telecommunication plans the broadband/NBN plans overlap and are hard to compare but my current plan is $79/month reduced to $59/month as a bundle for 50 Gb of which I use 10Gb.  If I want NBN I'm looking at something like $100/month and an additional $20 if I want to "superboost" it to 100 mbps.  So potentially I'm up for an extra $60/month or $720/year but will be using no extra downloads.

If NBN is going to be around for even 10 years then I've paid an additional $7,200 which would largely repay the $5000 the government puts up front for the installation.  The alternative is that I stay with my current broadband in which case I contribute nothing extra rolling the NBN out to the "nodes" and that then becomes a burden on the taxpayer.

Probably a bit of a simplistic analysis but I'm of the view the government is only putting the money up front and will recoup most through higher fees.  I have no doubt the NBN fees will go up once it becomes the norm or, alternatively, the other broadband plans will increase in costs to encourage more onto the NBN plans.

Could be wrong, but I thought Telstra had the NBN contract but since the election the Telstra share price has actually gone up about 6 cents so the financial community doesn't seem too worried about the new government winding it back.

Fulvio

Quote from: 'Steveqld' pid='28083' dateline='1379061395'The alternative is that I stay with my current broadband

That was never meant to be an option. Telstra was being paid $11 billion of that money to decommission their copper and HFC.

The reason of course is that they are outdated and a nightmare to maintain, so everything was to be replaced with fibre.

As for pricing, the wholesale price was fixed, so that every provider had the exact same price everywhere across the country. And the reason for that was the games Telstra was playing. Charging competitors extra or locking them out entirely.

Retail prices have a lot of factors built into them of course. But once the fibre network is in place, it is no longer one of those factors. Plus, as technology advances over time, it can very easily be plugged into the network, future-proofing it in a way copper can never be.

Oh, and as for Telstra's share price, of course its gone up. Telstra and Foxtel are the big winners in the second-rate network. Why do you think Murdoch threw his weight behind Abbott? He stands to gain billions out of this, as does Telstra, which is already renegotiating their deal.

As always, if you want the truth, follow the money and see who's snouts are in the trough.
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

trout

QuoteAs always, if you want the truth, follow the money and see who's snouts are in the trough.
This has ALWAYS been the case and as long as the Bastards keep their snouts out of yours and  MY pocket  I will be reasonably happy :ok:
you have to realise that most "Political" decisions are NOT financially viable because they are playing with OUR money and NOT their own :dodgy:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum