Cold Shuts

Started by Fulvio, June 26, 2013, 09:47:49 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

enworb

If a coin is UNC and not handled roughly then how would age cause the flaw to appear?

markn

Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='19579' dateline='1372316963'I didn't mean condition, I meant age. Not a lot of 2013 copper around that I've seen. :angel:


OK.  Give me one logical reason why an old UNC coin would show planchet flaws and a new one wouldn't.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

markn

Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='19579' dateline='1372316963'I don't think I've seen an explanation for what that orange-peel is, AJ. I'm dying to know though...

Orange peel on copper coins is almost certainly due to excessive die use / wear.   I've matched so called "metal flow" and "orange peel" on various half pennies of the same year.  Clearly struck from the same worn dies in a similar state of die wear.  Identical orange peel and metal flow.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

Fulvio

Quote from: 'markn' pid='19593' dateline='1372321151'OK.  Give me one logical reason why an old UNC coin would show planchet flaws and a new one wouldn't.

I can't, because its not logical. But until we see these flaws in recent mintings, one has to conclude its age-related. Perhaps something changed in the manufacturing process to stop them happening. Perhaps there's a chemical reaction going on. Perhaps they're actually out there, and we simply haven't seen them. I don't know, but would like to.

Meanwhile, you've given me cause to document my splits. Starting with what's in this pile in front of me...

50¢ - 2x1971, 1973
20¢ - 1966, 1967, 1974, 1980
$1 - 1984x4, 1985x4, 1997, 1998x2
10¢ - 1974x2
$2 - 2004 (Extremely worn and corroded)

So the only 21st century (or current effigy) in the lot is one that's lived a stressful life, and even its 9 years old. I'm happy to be wrong about this, so if anyone has a new one, please show and tell.

Quote from: 'markn' pid='19594' dateline='1372321493'Orange peel on copper coins is almost certainly due to excessive die use / wear.   I've matched so called "metal flow" and "orange peel" on various half pennies of the same year.  Clearly struck from the same worn dies in a similar state of die wear.  Identical orange peel and metal flow.

So if I've got this straight, the die starts to deform with use, producing a rippled surface? Interesting. But wouldn't that take an awful lot of strikes, and show lots of other signs of wear? Apart from doubling, I can't say I've really noticed much else going on. Perhaps some dies are weaker than others, and more susceptible to deformation?
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

Unicorn

Before I make a fool of myself for the 2nd time today, we're NOT talking about lamination flaws are we?

Fulvio

Quote from: 'Unicorn' pid='19609' dateline='1372325294'Before I make a fool of myself for the 2nd time today, we're NOT talking about lamination flaws are we?

Nope. Just comparing them because Mark asked a few posts back.
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

Unicorn

Thanks Fulvio, I'd dug out a 2008 $1 lamination and then thought, nah, they're not talking about that.

Fulvio

Quote from: 'Unicorn' pid='19628' dateline='1372334125'Thanks Fulvio, I'd dug out a 2008 $1 lamination and then thought, nah, they're not talking about that.

I'd like to see it though.
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

markn

Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='19607' dateline='1372324509'I can't, because its not logical. But until we see these flaws in recent mintings, one has to conclude its age-related.

I don't think it's age related at all.  It's almost certainly process related.  If someone today was using the same poor processes the mints were using in the 50's and 60's I'm sure you'd see the same sort of errors.  That's no different to any other errors.  As quality control improves errors become scarcer.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

markn

Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='19607' dateline='1372324509'So if I've got this straight, the die starts to deform with use, producing a rippled surface? Interesting. But wouldn't that take an awful lot of strikes, and show lots of other signs of wear? Apart from doubling, I can't say I've really noticed much else going on. Perhaps some dies are weaker than others, and more susceptible to deformation?

Yes, that's exactly what I am saying. There's a thread here somewhere (that I can't find) with some identical looking 1964Y half pennies with the same die wear, orange peel, and metal flow.

Given that the PM was renowned for pushing dies to their limit it's not surprising that PM coins are the ones that show the most metal flow and orange peel.  Looking at the pattern of orange peel and metal flow I wonder if it's got something to do with the grain boundaries in the working dies.  If they were poorly aged during the heat treating process after being hubbed they could have a coarse (and brittle) micro structure.  As you strike more and a more coins perhaps there's localised wear and deformation at the grain boundaries of the die.  

Sorry if this is unclear but it's been a while since I did any metallurgy.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

ausjack

shoot me down but the nickel could be the main thing here as old coins mark so much easier but these new one's can take a fair hit..not that I'd know, just what I've been told :winkextra:
A wise person knows there is something to learn from everyone.

markn

Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='19653' dateline='1372375576'shoot me down but the nickel could be the main thing here as old coins mark so much easier but these new one's can take a fair hit..not that I'd know, just what I've been told :winkextra:

Improvements in processes is the most likely explanation.  Bronze one and two cent pieces always showed a lot fewer errors than half pennies and pennies despite being the same material.  The reason?  Processes used from production of the raw metal, rolling of strip, striking of blanks, and minting of the coins improved greatly from 1964 to 1966.  

Another example is to look at 1951PL half pennies and the Perth minted coins of the same year.  I've seen lots of PM 1951 half penny errors and hardly any London minted coins.  And they are the same material.  Explanation?  The Royal Mint was just doing things a lot better than the Perth mint.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

ausjack

thanks Big M :mocking: I'm still learning so it's all good mate :good:

so it's more those roughians like trout that seem to be the problem :winkextra:
A wise person knows there is something to learn from everyone.

Unicorn

QuoteI'd like to see it though.

Here she is Fulvio ....


ausjack

A wise person knows there is something to learn from everyone.