1960 Copper Grades

Started by enworb, May 10, 2013, 02:38:52 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

enworb

I would be interested to hear how PCGS may grade these three coins. I want to slab one 1960 1/2d and one 1d that have colour. The two I have now are both MS64 RB but are a bit lifeless.







ausjack

Well I don't think they're gonna grade them very well so maybe you should just chuck'em my way..I'm pretty sure I could find them a really nice home :ok:

Beautiful coins Matty :drooling:
A wise person knows there is something to learn from everyone.

Robster

Great Coins, Great Colour, Great Pics.! Hope you get Great Grades. !!
\"Everything in moderation, including moderation\".

markn

I'll go from top to bottom MS64BN, MS63RB and MS64RB.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

wwwww

Nice colour, I'll go with MS63RB, MS63RB and MS64RB.

enworb

Thanks AJ but you'll have to kill me to get them. I cant turn down colourful 1960 copper. I wont be sending them all to PCGS just that have the best shot at 64.

Thanks mark and walter. Would you mind also offering your opinions on the next three candidates:

I especially like the first 1/2d because the metal flow lines on the cheek make the Queen look like she has a bit official hair.







ausjack

:scratch_one-s_head: OK, for them mate it's not a problem..your wish is my command, but ya know I'm gonna miss ya mate :cray:.. ALL JOKES :laugh2: You've got a nice little stash there :good: And thanks Mark and Walter I really appreciate your input as it helps many of us :good:
A wise person knows there is something to learn from everyone.

markn

The first half penny is the best of the lot, should be a 64, outside shot at a 65.  The second half penny looks like a 63 and I'd grade the penny a 63 too.  QE2 copper is tough in 65.  60's half pennies are a little easier than the pennies (apart from 64M's which are common in 65).  Enworb if you get a chance to come back to where you saw us today let us know the day before and we'll dig out some MS65 copper for you to look at.

Edit: If you look at the PCGS Population Report there's a total of 6 MS65 1960/1961/1962/1963 pennies.  That's how tough they are.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

Fr45h3R

Great coins.
Out of the lot posted, the one with a best chance of surprising you with a better grade would be the last 1/2d in the first set.
Would be hanging by a thread to get MS65RB, but hard to be certain from the photos.

enworb

I'll come see ya on Monday again mark. I'll bring them down for you to have a look at. Id love to see some 65s!

ausjack

this sounds like a bit of insider trading going on here so ya better not be getting all my nice shinny coins Matty :mocking:
A wise person knows there is something to learn from everyone.

echidna

PCGS grading has been harsh of late.
Possibly they have new inexperienced graders.
I have a bunch of red and brown pennies and halfpennies to send but I will be holding off for a bit.
Just my personal view...

enworb

My 1960 set is looking alright but as you can see the copper is lacking a bit of eye appeal. The threepence could do with an upgrade as well I think.














Fr45h3R

Quote from: 'echidna' pid='14280' dateline='1368180080'PCGS grading has been harsh of late.
Possibly they have new inexperienced graders.
I have a bunch of red and brown pennies and halfpennies to send but I will be holding off for a bit.
Just my personal view...

Do you think this is for both Copper and Silver, or more so the copper ?

robbiegal

enworb, that 1960 penny and halfpenny in the slabs look very well matched - the penny is particularly nice - I reckon that it is very hard to get this year in top quality