Regarding some rare pre-decimal pennies

Started by Doubledot1919, October 28, 2026, 02:13:37 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Doubledot1919

Hello everyone!
My name is Momchil, and I am from a small European country that some of you may not have heard of.
Here is why I am reaching out on this forum. A few months ago, I sent a small collection of PCGS-certified coins to a major European auction house for sale; among them are some interesting Rare pre-decimal Australian pennies. The consignment agreement specifies "sale without a reserve price," and I assumed this was standard practice. The online auction began a week ago, and I received a notification from the auction house and then I realized revealing that some of the coins have been listed with a very low starting price. For instance, one of the rarest pieces—a 1919 "double dot" penny (graded AU55 by PCGS)—has a starting price of just 100 Euros. Another of the coins - 1 penny 1920 English obverse, Dot below scroll (AU55) has a starting price of just 75 Euros.
I am aware that these coins are not widely known in Europe, and outside of Australia and the US, they are unlikely to fetch a good price. However, if such a coin were to sell for only 100–200 Euros, it would be a loss not only for me but for Australian collectors as well. So, my question is: is it possible—without violating forum rules—to somehow alert a few Australian collectors, who would have an interest in these auctions, about the presence of these rare coins in the auction? I would appreciate any advice you could offer on how to proceed.
I believe the online auction concludes on November 12th–13th, after which the coins will pass quickly through a live auction.
Best regards,
Momchil

Basilstate

Welcome DD1919,..,that'd a good grade for 1919 DD,throw a link up for the Auction so anyone interested can have a look.Good Luck with it.

Doubledot1919

Hello, Basilstate, thank you!
Since you believe that this does not violate the forum rules, I am sharing a link to the six coins that were part of my small collection for several years. All 6 coins are certified by PCGS. The seventh item shown below—a token—is not mine.

Have a great day,
Momchil

https://ha-europe.com/en/search?q=penny+australia&aid=

autocoupler

Hi Momchil,

As a collector of pre decimal varieties myself, I share your concern that the opening bids on five of the six coins are way too low. In my opinion, I believe the opening bid for the 1920 dot below Indian obverse is about right for a winning bid. Good luck with getting your information out into the main stream.
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

Doubledot1919

Autocoupler, thanks!
Yes, the prices are low, but I noticed in past Heritage Europe auctions that a significant number of coins end up selling for 5–6 times their starting price; so, the low starting price is likely a tactic they use to attract watchers.

autocoupler

I followed this auction. If I was the vendor, I would be very disappointed, but some interesting points emerged.

Lot 7626. PCGS AU55 - 1919 Penny, double dot. Opening bid of 100 Euro. The system shows just one bidder, but the price realised was 280 Euro. How can this be?

Lot 7627. PCGS AU58 - 1920 Penny, no dots, Indian obverse. Opening bid of 120 Euro. The system showed two bidders and a price realised as 260 Euro.

Lot 7628. PCGS AU55 - 1920 Penny English obverse, dot below bottom scroll. Opening bid of 75 Euro. The system shows just one bidder, but the price realised was 270 Euro. How can this be?

Lot 7629. PCGS XF45 - 1920 Penny English obverse, dot below bottom scroll. Opening bid of 50 Euro. The system shows just one bidder, but the price realised was 160 Euro. How can this be?

Lot 7630. PCGS MS64BN - 1920 Penny Indian obverse, dot below bottom scroll. Opening bid of 750 Euro. The system shows just one bidder, but the price realised was 800 Euro. How can this be?

Lot 7631. PCGS 55BN - 1927 Penny Indian obverse. Opening bid of 50 Euro. The system shows one bidder and a price realised of 50 Euro.

All prices except for one were extremely low in my opinion. I know there was some sort of internet outage at the time, so were these coins culled? If not, someone got a bargain on five of them in my opinion.   

 

 
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

Basilstate

Auto..,the opening bid may be an estimate with a reserve price by the Auction House.

I don't know all the details/facts on the above but i'm always wary of Auctions and their processes.

autocoupler

Hi Basil, I get what you're saying about being wary of how some auction houses operate. A typical example is how bidders are encouraged by some auction houses to pre bid a maximum amount only to see it thrust into the live arena without any incremental consideration. I've been bitten in that way and have seen many strange goings on with the bids of others. What has happened in this case is quite different as I see it.

One of these coins was a grade of equal best known, another two were second equal best known and in my opinion should have attracted bids in thousands, not hundreds. Why would anyone kick them off so low?   
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!