1919 Double Dot imposter?

Started by autocoupler, April 03, 2023, 09:53:44 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

serenitystan

There could also be another one from the same die. Sold by Noble auctions..Sale no 84 lot no 1549. Either that or it could be the Benchmark coin..

fred lever

Neal has a point.
We need to consider what obverses are paired with the DD reverses.
If I can figure out how to paste images on this site, i'll post a picture of a third DD reverse.
Well, I called it a fake, was because it doesn't look like the accepted reverse die!
When the Mint was baking up a batch of cloned dies its quite possible, they did 6 at a time in the oven as was the custom, and marked them with DD.
The recipe may have been poor and only one or two survived final heat treat and  polish.
They may have been utter disasters and fractured on first use = "nil thousand" and try again?
Who knows?
I'll have a wrestle with this photo paste thing.

autocoupler

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='128019' dateline='1680665065'There was only ONE 1919 .//. die. Any others are false.
The 1919 .//. is distinct as it has the same obverse die as a 1919 FBL. So it was possibly (probably?) the first of the cloned reverses which might account for it having 2 dots.

PCGS has removed the coin from their population report.
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

fred lever

Well here we go I think I have successfully imported a file into my gallery.
The coin I mentioned in post #17 is........................

First it was too big in size to fit file box so cut it down to 500KB.

Filename: https://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/11203/491/234583931765_edit_resize_1500_1290.JPG

Oh, not quite right, the image did not migrate. Bugger!
Some beginners mistake somewhere.
I'll try again.

Oh I see that works as a link so at least you can see the coin by clicking, well that a step forward.
At least you can view the coin.
You can see straight away why i called it a fake, the top "dot" looks like it has been hammered into the COIN with a hex nail punch!

Will keep trying to migrate pix.
ok, the IMG and /IMG  bookends are missing......

   
ok there they are i copy/pasted from gallery.

Ahh, it worked so being 78YO and autistic is not going to stop me, you can all applaud now............(cheeering etc etc)

So, check out the die clash as the biggest die markers of all time, I wonder if there is another one like this, or, a DUBs (with no top dot) with the same die clash marks.
Have to trawl through my file photos of DUBS and see if i get lucky.

What do you think of this coin FAKE???

Fred.

fred lever

And just to prove absent mindless, I just remembered I did a lot of research on the DD in 2020!
After being asked to give an opinion on a couple of suspect 1919 DD auction coins (both were fakes) I assembled my research into a paper.
That was printed in the September 2020 issue of CAB page 18.

In this I gathered up all the known factors associated with DD's, assembled these in print and then set about photographing those die markers from coins in my collection.
There is a couple of tables and 28 photos in the paper.
I then put those coins into an album of their own, so I could find them again (if i remember!).

The tables listed what features  a genuine DD should, and should not, have.
I'll copy/paste the tables here.

Table 1.
Item.                         DD Reverse, Should have. (Image numbers in brackets.)               

1   Top dot, oval shape tilted right, inset and  placed  slightly to right of center.(3)   
2   Bottom dot, round shape, slightly to left of center. (4)
3   "A" flaw, rectangular section above A, sometimes hard to see.(5)
4   "O" flaw, small round dot chip on right of O. Sometimes 2 dots are seen.(6)
5   "O" fill. Developing fill on top of O. Goes from non-existent to extreme.(7)
6   "A" cracks. Developing radial or circumferential surface stress cracking.(8)
7   Rim Letters, slight CBL.(9)
8   Date numerals have flat feet on 1's, NOT curved. (10)
9   NO die clash marks.
10   Upset: all coins have the dot under the King in line with the left side "9" in the date.


Table 2.
 Item                                   DD Coin should not have.
11   Any reverse or obverse, die clash marks.(11, 12, 13)
12   An obverse die crack above REX. (14)
13   Curved base 1's in the date.
14        A Reverse die crack "T" of AUSTRALIA.(15)

You can see there are 14 points of recognition

The paper is very detailed, I had to take great care in my findings as some money and repute were involved.
Best to read the paper and enjoy. Any one querying or disputing the 14 recognition points, the photos will clarify.

That does not mean that it is impossible, that a second DD die got as far as  the presses and some successful strikes could have made it to the bag.
But so far, by the reasoning shown in the paper, from close inspection,  it is most likely that any "non-standard" DD's are constructs in some way and fakes.

If anyone interested does not have a copy of the mag, just send an email to  my published email address and I'm happy to email back a PDF of the original paper.

Cheers, Fred.

fred lever

To round it off I looked at ebay, 11 1919 DD are listed.
Six look ok with dots in position and the flaw on the O.
Two are high top dot duds.
Three are blurry pix and indeterminate.
Fred.

Basilstate

Thanks Fred,here's an eg of the oblong top dot,really got out of shape as the Die wore,i have a better eg somewhere,will throw it up when i find it.







fred lever

Hi Basil also keep an eye on the "O" of OF.
There is a small flaw on the right hand side and the top of the O gets filled as the die progresses.
I have a late state coin where the O is nearly filled at the top that is the loop is missing on the coin.
See my 2020 CAB article.
Fred.

autocoupler

Looks like another has surfaced. Hmmmm....no, I think it's the Benchmark coin echidna posted earlier, this time in a PCGS slab graded top of the pops AU58. Cert 47353760

As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

Basilstate

Here we go again,gee, i thought the 1919DD story was sorted 50 years ago,only 1 Die,Test run from the Sydney Mint.

Interesting to see the PCGS reasoning behind ID this coin as a genuine DD.

autocoupler

Yes Basil, IMHO the same dot below die chip coin as in post #1, which PCGS eventually cancelled. Be interesting to see what they do with this one.
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

nealeffendi

Doubt it that Sydney minted the 1919 .//.
The rim is nothing like the 1920 /./
The 1919 .//. shares an obverse die with a 1919 no dot so was possibly the first of the strikes from cloned dies.

Basilstate

Hi Neal,Sydney Mint was the general consensus in the 1960's when they were the 'flavour of the Month' for a year or so.
Hard to see Melb minting them,why add a dot?,but in reality who knows for certain.

Interesing aside,more than 1 Sydney Dealer,who were in their teens in 1919,never saw one until the 1960's for whatever reason.
Same with a Stamp/Coin Dealer we had for a period a week at School,started his Business in the mid 1930's when he lost his job in the depression hit Wool industry,i showed him the one i found on my paper Run,first he had seen.

There must be a story to where the 1919 DD was hiding,the 1940/50's feeding frenzy by Dealers looking for the 1930 should have turned them up in reasonable numbers but it wasn't until the 1960's that they were 'discovered'.

nealeffendi

Yes Basil. They were not shown back in 1920 at a society meeting where all the other dot and no dot reverses were shown. But then again they didn't mention the English and Indian obverses either for many decades.
Even the 1921/22 Threepence was known about and published in the early 1920s, but then not mentioned again until the 1960s. So  possibly the double dot was spotted but never published and then when the societies went into decline during the Great Depression the knowledge was effectively lost. The rebirth of societies after ww2 was a new generation that had no knowledge of what the old timers knew.
So who first spotted and who first published back in the 1950s or 60s? Dean had them in 64 but didn't mention anything about them as a recent discovery so I'm presuming that they were rediscovered at least a few years prior. Do you recall how you were first told about them?

Basilstate

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='128513' dateline='1694583189' Do you recall how you were first told about them?

Hi Neal,as i've posted before i found one on my paper run in 1962 or 63.My Mother gave me a 10 shilling note as a float to keep all coins with a Kings Head,i collected them off the other paper boys as well but even back then 99% of coins were QE11.
I didn't know what it was until i looked at it with a magnifying glass at home,i showed it to local dealers(only 2 in those days) who didn't know what it was,i took it into Sydney and the 2 or 3 Dealers in walking distance of Central station didn't know either.That got my interest and it took pride of place in my collection.

My first recollection after that was an add in Coin World magazine for a Downies Auction in 1964/65,1919 'dot over top scroll' penny,i'll try and find the scan and throw it in this post. 

The Menzies/Holt Govt. in 1958(59?)announced the setting up of a committee to advise on the conversion to Decimal Currency,wasn't widely known by the general poulation but Dealers(Heyde & Friends springs to mind)siezed on it and started sorting Coins by the the tens of thousands,this added to the search for the 1930 which had been going on since 1944/45.Anyway point being it may have been the late 1950's that it was ID as a genuine variety.
This was all Sydney centric,i don't know what was going on in Melbourne.