Third party rolled coins

Started by JeffH, September 25, 2016, 04:57:34 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Fulvio

Quote from: 'trout' pid='98763' dateline='1474795196'If there was indeed NO attempt at deception here then the coins would be rolled in plain brown paper or something else and not it some security companies wrappers.

You've never made your own rolls, I take it?

Its a fairly major PITA. MUCH easier to use an empty tube. Or are you under the misapprehension everyone has a rolling machine under the bed?
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

trout

Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='98769' dateline='1474801756'
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98763' dateline='1474795196'If there was indeed NO attempt at deception here then the coins would be rolled in plain brown paper or something else and not it some security companies wrappers.

You've never made your own rolls, I take it?

Its a fairly major PITA. MUCH easier to use an empty tube. Or are you under the misapprehension everyone has a rolling machine under the bed?

No, I have never made my own rolls and nor do I intend to.
They may be a pain in the bum to roll from scratch and other than for the ease of depositing coins back at the Bank I can see NO other valid reason to re roll them at all.

The methods used to produce these "home Brand" rolls is irrelevant, What we are discussing here is the ethicality of the production of these rolls purely for the secondary market.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Fulvio

Quote from: 'trout' pid='98770' dateline='1474802473'NO other valid reason to re roll them at all.

Storage. That's why I did mine. I went from 18 sacks of loose coins to $4 and $10 rolls with descriptions printed on them.

But, a huge pain to do, because we only have two hands. :P

If I was doing it over, and if I had the empty tubes, I would definitely reroll them that way.
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

trout

Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='98772' dateline='1474803986'
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98770' dateline='1474802473'NO other valid reason to re roll them at all.

Storage. That's why I did mine. I went from 18 sacks of loose coins to $4 and $10 rolls with descriptions printed on them.

But, a huge pain to do, because we only have two hands. :P

If I was doing it over, and if I had the empty tubes, I would definitely reroll them that way.

What you are doing is for a totally different reason to what the sellers of these rolls are doing it for on eBay.
You are doing it because it is the way that you prefer to store your coins, The eBay sellers are doing it to artificially enhance the value of their coins. :ok:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Fulvio

Quote from: 'trout' pid='98776' dateline='1474804527'The eBay sellers are doing it to artificially enhance the value of their coins. :ok:

Which is what I remain unconvinced about.

I mean, sure, the black rolls were a commercial attempt at exactly that. And anyone stuffing rolls with crap would be a crook and all that. But someone who tells you exactly what it is, well, is he really responsible for your naivety?

I put it in the same category as tins of bulldust, fresh air or roo poo.

Caveat Emptor.

The funny thing is, as the original anti-packaging zealot, I would expect you of all people to be all about the coin, and not the paper its in. :angel:
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

ausproofs

Guys, I think there is lot of discussion here around someone's business venture. I don't approve what they have done if they source the coins in a deceptive way and rolling them and selling them on ebay. However if they have ethically sourcing the coins and selling them with a full disclosure, then thats business. Mr Cotton is a very smart business man... he has the connections and the know how, so he is making money. Some of us who bought the coin packs were selling them for a profit(higher than the purchase price) soon after it was bought.. So whats the difference ? Sorry, but thats what I call business.
Collecting coins is not about having the best, but loving what you have ...

trout

QuoteThe funny thing is, as the original anti-packaging zealot, I would expect you of all people to be all about the coin, and not the paper its in

It IS all about the coin.
Re packaged and pre searched rolls is something that I am definitely NOT interested in.
If I am searching for that pristine coin the odds of finding one in these types of rolls is extremely slim compared to a genuine Mint roll.
So the "packaging" IS important to me because the odds of finding that special coin are far better if someone hasn't already looked the contents over in a roll and they haven't been handled excessively and this can be pretty much guaranteed in a genuine untouched mint roll :ok:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Fulvio

Quote from: 'ausproofs' pid='98781' dateline='1474809669'Sorry, but thats what I call business.

:agreed:

Quote from: 'trout' pid='98782' dateline='1474809913'genuine untouched mint roll :ok:

Which don't exist anymore. Well, except they will again, but at a hefty premium.

For many many years the only rolls we've had have been security rolls. With no guarantees as to contents or condition.

So what's the difference?

You assume that an individual is going to be up to no good. And by inference, that an organisation, be it Armaguard or the RAM, is going to be squeaky clean and above board.

And yet, we know of countless incidents when things were in fact dodgy. Most recently sacks of olympic coins on ebay a week before release. And boxes of carded coins.

Me, I wouldn't trust ANY roll. But then I opened a couple rolls of 20ยข from the 80's only to discover the edges ruined, with the cancer encroaching onto the faces of the coins. The ends looked perfect, and there was no hint of the damage hidden inside.

A roll is just a (not very good) storage and transport solution. Nothing more, and arguably much less. I wouldn't pay any premium for one over the value of the loose coins.
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

JeffH

I hadn't really thought about the use of security firm wrappers here. On reflection that is definitely a dodgy practice and likely to deceive. In this case the pictures do, as many sellers say, form part of the description.

And the statement "Buy from a Honest seller, all my items have had positive feedback." also sows confusion. It implies that all positive feedback makes him honest but that doesn't necessarily follow. He may well be very honest but that statement proves nothing. And he doesn't have 100% positive feedback -two negatives and one neutral in last six months.

So, not a seller I would recommend.
Thinking is dangerous, it makes you think. That\'s why many people avoid it.

trout

Quote from: 'ausproofs' pid='98781' dateline='1474809669'Guys, I think there is lot of discussion here around someone's business venture. I don't approve what they have done if they source the coins in a deceptive way and rolling them and selling them on ebay. However if they have ethically sourcing the coins and selling them with a full disclosure, then thats business. Mr Cotton is a very smart business man... he has the connections and the know how, so he is making money. Some of us who bought the coin packs were selling them for a profit(higher than the purchase price) soon after it was bought.. So whats the difference ? Sorry, but thats what I call business.

It may be business and it may be legal But ask yourself is it really ethical and would you feel comfortable doing this yourself??
I don't know about anyone else but I still have my coin packs minus a few that I have gifted But re selling these packs is a completely different thing to taking the coins out of the packs to manufacture  rolls that appear to be security rolls or use whatever other official looking wrapper.
One is a case of selling an official Mint product and the other is selling something that appears to be an official product, two very different scenario's.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Fulvio

Quote from: 'trout' pid='98793' dateline='1474839143'the other is selling something that appears to be an official product, two very different scenario's.

And where do security rolls fit in then?

They're not official products. The contents aren't guaranteed. Just because there's a shiny desirable coin at each end doesn't mean the rest are the same. And there's no guarantee of condition either. In fact, they COULD be completely dodgy, whether rolled that way deliberately by an employee or repacked by someone afterwards.

Either ALL non-RAM rolls are sus, or they're all fair game and its up to the buyer to be aware and alert. You can't pick and choose.
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

trout

QuoteAnd where do security rolls fit in then?

I know exactly where you could "Fit" the security rolls :diablo::angel:

Selling dodgy rolls in whatever wrapper you like to choose is NOT the same as selling a genuine carded Mint product, Quite simple really :ok:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Fulvio

Quote from: 'trout' pid='98814' dateline='1474864532'Selling dodgy rolls in whatever wrapper

You totally missed my point, fishboy. :P

If I flog off my slabs of green Prosegur Coronation rolls, what guarantee is there that they contain UNC Coronations? Or that I haven't noodled them and removed the MS68's? :dodgy:

I'm saying that all rolls are equally suspect. Bags too if it comes to that, since they can be repacked also.
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

trout

QuoteYou totally missed my point, fishboy

On the contrary You are missing the point of what I am trying to say :ok:
The people that are selling the Olympic $2 coins in rolls and I am referring to any coloured, marked or barcoded , Whatever roll that you would prefer or takes your fancy have been created by the sellers and none else as these coins were NOT rolled at all for dispatch/delivery, They came either carded or in $50 bags OK.

These are the rolls I am talking about here :ok:
Now that we have got that bit clear, What  I have been trying to say is that selling these Olympic rolls (please read above) is NOT the same as selling a carded genuine Mint product :):yahoo:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Fulvio

Quote from: 'trout' pid='98820' dateline='1474866878'NOT the same as selling a carded genuine Mint product

Nobody said it was.

The way I see it is this:

If I swap a $50 note for 25 $2 coins, I'm not actually 'buying' anything. And I don't care if they're loose, bagged, rolled or even roadkill. Its $50. End of story.

But the moment there's any kind of premium attached, that's when things get complicated, and all sorts of pests crawl out of the woodwork. Because now we're not talking about money anymore, but a 'product'.

And here my opinion probably varies from yours. I regard ALL this stuff, including RAM rolls and olympic packs, as dodgy. Because whether its the RAM, Joe Bloggs or the Trout Mint, the objective remains the same: To extract extra profit by passing something off as something different, purely by the way its wrapped. Even slabs fall into this category, but that's a different discussion.

Its a bit like buying a bulk bag of Mars bars, where each one is in a wrapper marked 'Not for Retail Sale'. Who cares? I want a Mars bar, and I shouldn't be charged two wildly different prices for the exact same thing based solely on what's printed on the wrapper. As long as they both came off the same production line, they're interchangeable, I reckon.

Now, IF the coins are different, say with Specimens or even the high-grade coins that used to go into RAM rolls back in the day, then no problem. But putting the exact same stuffed coins that are in bags into a card and charging 50% more? That's as crooked as a dog's hind leg IMO. And so is the plan to charge a hefty premium for 'genuine' rolls, BTW.

'Genuine' in this case carries no weight whatsoever. :P
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW