Possible 2014 $1 Mule

Started by Bigfellani5, August 26, 2016, 10:46:06 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Nevol

There are 4 Coin obverses in this image which should be self explanatory. The 2000 Mule obv is mine.

The reason I put these images together was that I noticed the variance of distance between HM hair and II in the legend, when comparing
CoinFreak666's image to one on The ACF.  

So I decided to get together 4 images which might help sort things out. Then I saw that the front curl of HM's hair was also
differently placed on the 2014 coin, so it's obvious that the 10c obv on the 2014 coin, is larger than the Obv on the 10c 2000 coin.

There are 4 things I would like to know/see about the 2014 ANZAC $1;

Exact diameter of the coin (bigfella says 25.05mm) .05 larger than standard $1
Exact weight of the coin (bigfella says 9g) same as standard $1
Some really close-up in-focus shots of the rim
Some really close-up in-focus shots of the edge

If no more examples of this coin come to light, it is possible that it's;

a)   Mint Sport, one off
b)   Meticulously manufactured Magician's coin – probably one off, very close examination with a good loupe should reveal this
c)   small possibility of a really well centred Collar error (this might explain the coin being slightly wider), but not the difference in HM's head size.


A Platypus is a duck designed by a committee ( anon)

Bigfellani5

Hi Guys.....Have emailed the guy again in an effort to get some more imagery. What I really want is a close up scan of the coin with a 10c next to it. Then I can post it here and get someone with the image manipulation skills to transpose the 10c image on top of the $1 coin and see if there is a fit. I would also attempt to get images as Nevol suggested.

I believe the new owner lives somewhere near Moree so I doubt I will ever see the coin again IRL.

Hercules

Quote from: 'Bigfellani5' pid='109994' dateline='1499823048'I believe the new owner lives somewhere near Moree...

Great!!! That means it's over halfway to Brisbane. ;)

Bigfellani5

more pics of the mule are here. Would be nice if someone could super impose the 10c over the $1 (my skill level here is crap). I am trying to get the guy to do a decent scan of the 2 coins together and have emailed him several times and even posted that in the other forum but it is like pulling teeth. I think the guy is making it hard for himself.

autocoupler

Just my two bobs worth, the guy appears ready to toss in the towel, but I personally don't know why. The coin is either genuine and from a very short mint run, or mint sport, that's the only difference as I see it. There are plenty of mint sport coins going for big bucks at auction, so if it were me I would be tucking it away, and then letting  collectors fight for it at auction (not ebay) in a couple of years. It's a no brainer IMO.
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

trout

From the images the coin appears to be genuine, But images can be manipulated.
IF genuine it is either as auto stated "Mint Sport" or a small run of coins.
To be certain the coin needs to be assessed by an Expert numismatist or be graded by either PCGS or NGC.
Lots of "Iff's and "But's" about this one.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

JeffH

There is an old saying..."If it sounds too good to be true it probably is."
That is one too good looking coin. I'm with trout, in the absence of any definitive evidence -too many ifs and buts.
Thinking is dangerous, it makes you think. That\'s why many people avoid it.

trout

Quote from: 'JeffH' pid='110004' dateline='1499920999'There is an old saying..."If it sounds too good to be true it probably is."
That is one too good looking coin. I'm with trout, in the absence of any definitive evidence -too many ifs and buts.

Maybe it IS "Mint Sport" and this one is just the "Tester" and there are others being held by the perpetrators for a later date cash in  :angel:

With all these double headed and other "Mint Sport" now being graded by PCGS and thus being regarded as legitimate, It would Not surprise me in the least to find all sorts of this sort of garbage being produced by unscrupulous employees at RAM :dodgy:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

gnome

Could it be machined to look like that?

Could just be my imagination, but there looks like lathe marks under magnification.

trout

QuoteCould it be machined to look like that?

I didn't think of that.
You could be onto something as it does look to be perfectly central which isn't the "Norm" with the 2000 mules :angel:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

Bigfellani5

I have sold 2 well centred high grade mules. Think you really have to look at wether the head is 10c size which it is. In real life I did not pick up any tool marks under a 10x glass. "Marks" you are seeing are possibly light reflection

gnome

Wheww, thought I was making a tool of myself,by asking :) just a thought, but maybe if anyone knows a machinist etc, ask them, from the pics ,if it could be done, seeing emails etc aren't forthcoming with more pics. There's that overseas company that's knocking out double headed magician coins, so it may be possible, just another line of inquiry maybe.

Very possible as well, bigfella, :)

rollycoins

I've been reading this thread with interest, and also going across onto CCF to read what's going on there. While I was browsing on CCF, I chanced upon the '2007 double headed 5 cent' thread.

https://www.coincommunity.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=48044&whichpage=10

Some of you may remember this person noodle74 who posted about them having gotten one of it from regional NSW, somewhere close to the border with QLD. Have a look at his/her profile - note the profile picture and no location was given. The above was from the thread.

Now compare it with CoinFreak666, the one with this '2014 mule'. Check out their profile! Location = Terry Hie Hie, NSW - pretty close to the border with QLD isn't it? And how about the profile picture?

I don't know, just too much of a coincidence for me and I think it's the same person. Style of photography is also similar. I'm not sure how I even came up with this but it just all clicked lol. This is all just my personal opinion. I might be terribly wrong.

Here are the profiles:
Noodle74 - https://www.coincommunity.com/forum/pop_profile.asp?mode=display&id=48565
CoinFreak666 - https://www.coincommunity.com/forum/pop_profile.asp?mode=display&id=49616

Hercules

Thanks, Rolly. When someone says "near the QLD/NSW" border, I usually think of Tweed Heads, so this connection didn't occur to me, but I'm glad you've brought it up. Interestingly, noodle74 claims to be a female, but CoinFreak666 doesn't specify their gender at all. Has CoinFreak666 told anyone explicitly what their gender is? Although this looks like a beautiful coin, there's something about it that just doesn't feel quite right.

gnome

On the fb page the original owner and the new owner were both males, I believe.