INCUSED 50

Started by stevo1962, August 13, 2016, 10:08:26 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

robbiegal

Quote from: 'stevo1962' pid='94466' dateline='1471078214'
Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='94453' dateline='1471067595'why on earth do you clean off the lovely cupro-nickel toning?

The only reason is to bring out the hidden lustre to increase the eye appeal.There's every chance it could be lifted to a higher grade

an expert numismatist will identify the luster through tone
i admire the cupro-nickel tone
I think it is very beautiful

r9453

Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='94504' dateline='1471088578'
QuoteThe only reason is to bring out the hidden lustre to increase the eye appeal.

an expert numismatist will identify the luster through tone

Originally Steve referred to "discolouration" which might not be tone. Will acetone remove tone?

I always imagined the experts identifying the lustre through gaps in tone as opposed to somehow being able to discern it beneath.
Two Bob coin collector.

trout

QuoteI always imagined the experts identifying the lustre through gaps in tone as opposed to somehow being able to discern it beneath.

Good lustre will show through even on a heavily toned coin :ok:
Acetone will only remove grime, toning and old fingerprints will remain on the coin.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

tania

Hi

Just wondering do you rinse the coins under the tap when they come out of the acetone?

Thanks Tania

stevo1962

Quote from: 'tania' pid='94555' dateline='1471142848'Hi

Just wondering do you rinse the coins under the tap when they come out of the acetone?

Thanks Tania

I usually rinse them in warm soapy water and the gently dab dry with a clean teatowel with no ill effects and then they are off to PCGS
It\'s not about who you know it\'s about what you know

tania

Thank you for the reply.

Do you just soak them in the acetone and then rinse them in the warm soapy water?

And how long do they usually stay in the acetone?

Thanks Tania

Basil

Acetone,always make sure you do the lid up tight after each use,i lost 4 Litres a few years back when i forgot to tighten the lid,amazingly how fast it evaporates.I put small amounts into a screw top jar now.
Also only use as a last resort,natural Toning is always the best,warts & all.
Definition of Wisdom in a Man.\"...the moment in a persons journey through life life when he realises 99.9% of the people he meets & greets don\'t care about himself or his opinions\".

nealeffendi

Quote from: 'Basil' pid='94562' dateline='1471148615'Acetone,always make sure you do the lid up tight after each use,i lost 4 Litres a few years back when i forgot to tighten the lid,amazingly how fast it evaporates.I put small amounts into a screw top jar now.
Also only use as a last resort,natural Toning is always the best,warts & all.

Does acetone remove toning (warts and all)?
Is there any need to rinse acetone off coins instead of just letting it evaporate?

stevo1962

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='94563' dateline='1471151007'
Quote from: 'Basil' pid='94562' dateline='1471148615'Acetone,always make sure you do the lid up tight after each use,i lost 4 Litres a few years back when i forgot to tighten the lid,amazingly how fast it evaporates.I put small amounts into a screw top jar now.
Also only use as a last resort,natural Toning is always the best,warts & all.

Does acetone remove toning (warts and all)?
Is there any need to rinse acetone off coins instead of just letting it evaporate?

Acetone doesnt remove toning but only any dirt that is sitting on the surface.It doesnt remove toning but can leave a visible aftermark so the soap and water just cleans it off
It\'s not about who you know it\'s about what you know

Basil

Yeah,and each to his own but its best to the leave the Coin as is unless its to remove varnish/glue etc.A bit of dirt adds character. Sydney Dealers,pre Internet,regarded Acetone and the like as 'dipping'.
Definition of Wisdom in a Man.\"...the moment in a persons journey through life life when he realises 99.9% of the people he meets & greets don\'t care about himself or his opinions\".

robbiegal

obviously pcgs doesn't

Basil

Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='94579' dateline='1471177017'obviously pcgs doesn't

Geez,lets all start cleaning our Coins,sorry RG but i can't believe we are going down this track on a Coin Forum.
Definition of Wisdom in a Man.\"...the moment in a persons journey through life life when he realises 99.9% of the people he meets & greets don\'t care about himself or his opinions\".

trout

Quote from: 'Basil' pid='94595' dateline='1471178152'
Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='94579' dateline='1471177017'obviously pcgs doesn't

Geez,lets all start cleaning our Coins,sorry RG but i can't believe we are going down this track on a Coin Forum.

I don't think we are going down that track Mate.
The vast majority of us here wouldn't dream of "tarting up" a coin in an attempt to garner a better grade from a TPG :ok:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

robbiegal

well i guess it opens up that whole debate around 'çleaning'

the old wire brush or brasso is definitely bad for the coin and damages surfaces

but a light but ikky solvent is perhaps not invasive enough to be considered 'çleaning' or damaging?

dunno really

trout

Getting rid of PVC slime or glue etc. is one thing, Going further than that starts to get into the "Grey" area.
I have used acetone with a limited amount of success on PVC coins for my collections But I wouldn't bother sending them to be graded, I would much rather just find a problem free coin in the first place if I wanted to have it slabbed.
Cleaning coins is not a new thing and using acetone is market acceptable and much better than the old mix up a brew and lets dip this sucker routine that used to be done.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum