1961 bar in wool shilling

Started by serial, July 11, 2016, 09:38:30 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

robbiegal

done
BTW, care to kill the duplicate image, RG?

i don't buy the accidental or deliberate damage by a mint worker

ausjack

The only thing that is making me wonder about this is where I put the arrow as the other coins don't seem to have this mark so high but then if it is the die wearing out then that explains it a bit
A wise person knows there is something to learn from everyone.

trout

Quotealthough the sheeps' wool around it looks notably flatter

This is what is making me lean towards this being PMD.
It looks like the coin has taken a hit with something with a gap in it, This would explain the flat depressions either side of the "Bar" and the other mark just above it on the upper fold of wool.
If this was a cud or a growing cud then either side of it would be the normal coin design and not flattened like this one is.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

robbiegal

great photos Serial
It makes it sooo much easier to identify errors when the photos are crisp and clear like yours

nealeffendi

Quote from: 'trout' pid='92445' dateline='1468323888'
Quotealthough the sheeps' wool around it looks notably flatter

This is what is making me lean towards this being PMD.
It looks like the coin has taken a hit with something with a gap in it, This would explain the flat depressions either side of the "Bar" and the other mark just above it on the upper fold of wool.
If this was a cud or a growing cud then either side of it would be the normal coin design and not flattened like this one is.

Can't agree. A blow strong enough to move that much metal would surely leave other damage such as bending the coin or knackering the queen.
The real proof as a true variety will be when a second example is found.

serial

this is not pmd, original surfaces are present.
the appearance of damage either side is an optical illusion and I assure you I can tell the difference.
what I find most funny about this coin is my inability to find sales of any other coin. plus I cannot find a single example of the coin quite as sharp as the one in renniks

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='92447' dateline='1468325823'
Quote from: 'trout' pid='92445' dateline='1468323888'
Quotealthough the sheeps' wool around it looks notably flatter

This is what is making me lean towards this being PMD.
It looks like the coin has taken a hit with something with a gap in it, This would explain the flat depressions either side of the "Bar" and the other mark just above it on the upper fold of wool.
If this was a cud or a growing cud then either side of it would be the normal coin design and not flattened like this one is.

Can't agree. A blow strong enough to move that much metal would surely leave other damage such as bending the coin or knackering the queen.
The real proof as a true variety will be when a second example is found.
this is why I am trying to find another one, trying to establish if it is a variety or an error coin with a large cud. I am leaning towards a cud

trout

OK then, So Not PMD and very similar to Emu's coin.
There Must be more of these out there and hopefully will be found at varying stages from what Emu's coin looks like to what Serials coin looks like.
I have a bucket full of 50% silver coins and will have a squiz tomorrow, Now that I know what to look for maybe just maybe there might be one of these chucked in there.
I would imagine that there are many of us that were blissfully unaware of this error/variety existed that have a stash of silver coins that they can explore.
Happy Hunting Guys :good:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

serial

I handle at least 3kg of scrap predecimal a week
I pick through it entirely looking for variants eg 46 florins big o 6, error coins etc. Been noodling lots for a long time now. This is the 1st one I have ever seen ever!
I really hope that someone can find another one as I feel this is like a fantail 6d. Extremely rare and undervalued in the renniks

trout

I would think that there are many errors and verities that are grossly undervalued because they are not widely known.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

robbiegal

my theory that I have been pondering is:
(see what Neil thinks)

The original bar error is a smaller version of a die bubble that has begun to break off

Serials coin is 'possibly from when the die was finally quite damaged and the die bubble has completely broken away, hence the fail in the sheeps' wool in that area

that area (the flattened part) looks rough which is what can happen in a spot that isn't fully struck up. The metal had flowed into the recess of the die bubble and in doing so has taken the metal away from the design and into the 'lump'that we see but is in fact a recessed dip in the die itself.

it might also be a chip but I reckon this one fits the bubble theory better

die bubbles do occur in dies and the metal can fatigue and break away (an example is the 'dot'on the queens neck 1964 Y penny)

my feeling is that it is an interesting curiosity but perhaps not of great value in terms of errors

nealeffendi

Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='92466' dateline='1468376649'my theory that I have been pondering is:
(see what Neil thinks)

The original bar error is a smaller version of a die bubble that has begun to break off

Serials coin is 'possibly from when the die was finally quite damaged and the die bubble has completely broken away, hence the fail in the sheeps' wool in that area

that area (the flattened part) looks rough which is what can happen in a spot that isn't fully struck up. The metal had flowed into the recess of the die bubble and in doing so has taken the metal away from the design and into the 'lump'that we see but is in fact a recessed dip in the die itself.

it might also be a chip but I reckon this one fits the bubble theory better

die bubbles do occur in dies and the metal can fatigue and break away (an example is the 'dot'on the queens neck 1964 Y penny)

my feeling is that it is an interesting curiosity but perhaps not of great value in terms of errors

Doesn't work out. If it was a bubble in the die that began to break off then the defect would show up as incuse on the coin. If it was a fully burst bubble (leaving a crater in the die) then yes it would produce a raised feature (such as the bar) but then would it be so neat with nicely tapered sides?
The Frankenstein queen..... is it from metal fatigue on the die? (don't know either way).
Now if the die had been accidentally damaged (such as getting whacked into by another die when a batch was being annealed) then the defect might be a neat bar.

robbiegal


ausjack

Either way it went wouldn't one think that there should be more examples around :scratch_one-s_head:
A wise person knows there is something to learn from everyone.

serial

Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='92488' dateline='1468398672'Either way it went wouldn't one think that there should be more examples around :scratch_one-s_head:

I would say so, how many is anyone's guess. I would say that it wouldn't have been long after mine that they would have retired the die. Given that this year numbers in the 10's millions I imagine they will be hard to find

ausjack

Yes you don't hear of many people talking about them, I can't remember where I seen some one mention them as it was a few years ago but it might have been CCF.
A wise person knows there is something to learn from everyone.