Investment Coins

Started by sirfry, November 14, 2012, 09:10:11 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

AaronG

MobOfRoos, how much does a coin cost to get graded? Which company is best for Aussie coins?

markn

Quote from: 'MobOfRoos' pid='3720' dateline='1353544464'The way I see it there are also different types of investments you can do, and just like any other investment, higher returns mean higher risk.

1) You could buy a nice solid 1930 Penny (or 1923 Half Penny or 1932 Florin) at auction and you would be pretty much guaranteed to make a reasonable investment return.

I disagree.  1930 pennies and 1923 half pennies are selling (a lot) less than what they were 5 years ago in common grades.  There's absolutely no guarantee you'll make money out of these.  They are always available and regardless of the mintages not scarce on the market.  To stand a much better chance of making money from them you need to buy as high a grade as possible.  If that grade is run-of-the-mill and commonly available then you're much more likely to lose money.

Quote from: 'MobOfRoos' pid='3720' dateline='1353544464'3) Buy a high grade raw coin, get it slabbed, and sell it at a huge mark up. In the current market this is a sure fire way to make a profit and it carries very little risk.

Again disagree.  There's no risk if you know how TPG's grade and what they are looking for to get high numbers. And you can pick a coin that they won't call cleaned, rim-damaged, planchet-flawed, tooled or any other number of things that a lot of Australian dealers do not disclose.  And you can actually find a coin that's worth getting graded and do so without spending an inordinately large amount of time to make it worth the effort.  All of those sound like risks to me.  If you think it's so easy why are there so many rubbish coins in PCGS slabs on eBay right now?  That's because it's not easy and it's not a sure-fire method to do anything.

Quote from: 'MobOfRoos' pid='3720' dateline='1353544464'It is also important to remember that a coin's value is not just a function of its scarcity. It is also a function of its desirability. So the perfect investment coin would be one that is scarce and would become more desirable as time goes on.

Agree completely.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

MobOfRoos

Quote from: 'markn' pid='3737' dateline='1353550708'I disagree.  1930 pennies and 1923 half pennies are selling (a lot) less than what they were 5 years ago in common grades.

Agreed. I was thinking more long term. Getting an investment return over 5 years on any coin would be speculative at best. Especially with the selling and buying costs factored in.

markn

Quote from: 'MobOfRoos' pid='3739' dateline='1353550955'Agreed. I was thinking more long term. Getting an investment return over 5 years on any coin would be speculative at best. Especially with the selling and buying costs factored in.

I think some people who bought 1930 pennies in the early to mid 2000's when the market was near it's peak won't see a positive ROI for 30+ years when you take inflation into account.  If ever.  They'd certainly have done a lot better leaving their money in a fixed-term account and rolling it over annually.  You are perfectly correct in your long-term outlook.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

gnome

Getting away from just the coins as an investment I purchased an  unc 1967 $10 note some years ago. It seems to be doing ok.

markn

Quote from: 'gnome' pid='3742' dateline='1353552524'Getting away from just the coins as an investment I purchased an  unc 1967 $10 note some years ago. It seems to be doing ok.

Nice :yahoo:
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

Cruzi

The single biggest mistake I see and it is not just coins, is that people do not understand buy low, sell high.

The common interpretation is buy high, hoping to sell higher.

A couple of common examples in recent times, Telstra 2 float, most buyers thought they were on a sure bet like the first float & gold, time to buy was over a decade ago when it had been sitting at a plateau for over a decade.

Hindsight is a wonderful thing but do not ignore it, see how markets have behaved in the past and apply those tools to now.  

Market forces always overshoot, they will jump from undervalued to overvalued back down to undervalued ad infinitum

markn

Quote from: 'Cruzi' pid='3745' dateline='1353556927'The single biggest mistake I see and it is not just coins, is that people do not understand buy low, sell high.

Cruzi has hit the nail on my coin investing head here.  I am by no means an investor but the best returns BY FAR on any coins I've got were in the buying.  I saw something that was mis-identified, conservatively graded, or was just a plain bargain and I knew it was a bargain.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

Fr45h3R

What is of concern though is some of the numbers thrown around on 'investment' coins.
For those only concerned about 'returns' (eg: self managed super funds) it frightens me to think what position some people may be in when it is time to realise the value of these investments.
Type 'self managed super investment coins' into Google, and see what comes up.
Even better, search for 'investment' in Australian coins on eBay.

I was poking around in this space about 10 months ago, but my pocket is glad I've found forums like this and fellow enthusiasts like you guys.

markn

Quote from: 'Fr45h3R' pid='3752' dateline='1353570830'What is of concern though is some of the numbers thrown around on 'investment' coins.
For those only concerned about 'returns' (eg: self managed super funds) it frightens me to think what position some people may be in when it is time to realise the value of these investments.
Type 'self managed super investment coins' into Google, and see what comes up.
Even better, search for 'investment' in Australian coins on eBay.

I was poking around in this space about 10 months ago, but my pocket is glad I've found forums like this and fellow enthusiasts like you guys.

I've done well on some coins but I am not ashamed to say that the vast majority of my coins (90% or more) I probably haven't made a cent on.  And in most cases I've lost money on them.  I own those coins because they are cool and I love having them.  Investment be darned, collecting coins is too much tooting fun :)
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

Mister T

Quote from: 'Fr45h3R' pid='3752' dateline='1353570830'What is of concern though is some of the numbers thrown around on 'investment' coins.

Do you mean the claims of 1000% increases that don't account for inflation?

Cruzi

Quote from: 'markn' pid='3753' dateline='1353572246'I've done well on some coins but I am not ashamed to say that the vast majority of my coins (90% or more) I probably haven't made a cent on.  And in most cases I've lost money on them.  I own those coins because they are cool and I love having them.  Investment be darned, collecting coins is too much tooting fun :)

I've been lucky and managed to make a bit as well, thing is, had to be brutal about it, sentiment had no place, that is why I have a coin collection and, as part of a larger investment strategy, some investment coins.

Coins like the Australians At War kookas are never going to give me a profit but the pleasure they give is priceless.

wwwww

Quote from: 'Mister T' pid='3757' dateline='1353578789'
Quote from: 'Fr45h3R' pid='3752' dateline='1353570830'What is of concern though is some of the numbers thrown around on 'investment' coins.

Do you mean the claims of 1000% increases that don't account for inflation?

They should not factor in inflation because they're intended to be compared with figures that don't factor in inflation.

Quote3) Buy a high grade raw coin, get it slabbed, and sell it at a huge mark up. In the current market this is a sure fire way to make a profit and it carries very little risk.

Where can I buy these high grade, risk free coins?

Mister T

Quote from: 'wwwww' pid='3797' dateline='1353641908'They should not factor in inflation because they're intended to be compared with figures that don't factor in inflation.

I don't understand.

wwwww

Quote from: 'Mister T' pid='3798' dateline='1353644198'
Quote from: 'wwwww' pid='3797' dateline='1353641908'They should not factor in inflation because they're intended to be compared with figures that don't factor in inflation.

I don't understand.

Percentage return figures don't ever factor in inflation. Why then should you factor it in for coins?

Take for example, a number of ways of investing money:

A particular apartment appreciated by 3% pa in value and had a net rental return of 3% pa, so a total of 6% profit.

A bank term deposit paid 6% pa.

A particular coin appreciated by 8% pa, but there was 4% inflation, and you have to factor it in as you say, so it really only appreciated by 4% pa.

So the coin made a 4% return pa, the other two options paid 6%, yet the coin had the most return, how is that possible?