Have you been an ebay winner today?

Started by trout, November 04, 2012, 05:54:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

trout

I was thinking of sending this to PCGS along with a couple of other Gold coins when it arrives.
IF it turns out to be a fake/counterfeit coin I imagine a seller with the Rep this bloke has would still honour a refund .
I am however quite optimistic about this coin and will persevere with it until I get a definitive answer from PCGS.
This coin is WAY out of my field of expertise and I am reliant on expert opinion on it before I can say if it is the real McCoy or not :ok:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

nealeffendi

I know even less than you do Trout about Pagoda coins, I just speak/read arabic (imperfectly). I have no reason to doubt the authenticity of it, but I do doubt the translation of the symbol. The letter 'ayn may be written differently in India or perhaps somebody tried to guess the symbol was the first letter of the rulers name.
Do other rulers pagodas have their initial on it? if so that would support the reasoning.
I hadn't even thought of arbaa (4), again it looks to be the wrong shape for arbaa as the 2 loops are usually not so rounded (like a western 3) but are normally like 2 peaks. Again there may be regional differences from the way I'm used to seeing/writing.
So will Trout get a Proclamation coin after every June 30th?

trout

QuoteSo will Trout get a Proclamation coin after every June 30th?
this will be my second one for this years "Splurge" :angel: :yahoo:
In everything else I am controlled and conservative But when it comes to coins I Covet I tend to throw caution to the Wind and just go for it when I have the spare "reddies".
my Budget turns to crap every Tax return :angel:
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

robbiegal

The pagoda was the principal gold coin of Southern India in the late 16th century. Struck by the East India Company, it was a small gold coin which Governor King proclaimed to have a value of 8 shillings. The most famous design was the Star Pagoda, so named for the design appearing on the reverse of the 10 to 11 millimeter diameter coin. Undated, they were struck from 1740 until 1807.  
Another Pagoda, also struck throughout the same period, was the Three Swami Pagoda. Slightly larger than the Star Pagoda, it had a diameter of 12 to 14 millimeters and weighed approximately 3.43 grams.

 

Valuation :
 1740 to 1807 - Star Pagoda - Proclaimed at 8 Shillings.

 2002
Fine 175
Very Fine 200
Extra Fine 300
Almost Uncirc.
Uncirc 350 -- 475
Website Design by AG Photography & Design
 Material by Coinweb, Copyright © 2001-07 Australian Stamp & Coin Co Pty. Ltd.     Last modified: 05 December, 2007

more googling
that mark on your coin trout may depict the maker

the reason I am suggesting that is after reading this from the British Museum
 
Gold pagoda


 

Diameter: 12.000 mm
Weight: 3.380 g
Marsden Collection
CM Marsden MLXXXIV.(a)C
Coins and Medals

Gold pagoda
Pondichery, south India, AD 1705-80

The French mint coins for India

The French Company of the East Indies was set up in 1664 with a fifty-year monopoly of trade in the Indian Ocean. The French established their first (and principal) settlement at Pondichery on the Coromandel coast of southern India in 1674.

Southern India in this period was fragmented into a number of small states. Minting coinage was not a state privilege and any merchant could obtain the right to coin money of the regulated standard. From about 1705 the French began minting their own version of the local gold coinage, the pagoda. This imitated the local tradition of depicting the schematized image of an Indian goddess standing between two flowers on the reverse. The coins carry no legend or date, but are identifiable as French by the obverse design of a small crescent and dot monogram encircled by a grained field.
C. R. Bruce, J. S. Deyall, N. Rhodes and W. F. Spengler, The Standard guide to South As (Iolo Wisconsin, Krause Publications, 1991)

trout

AWSOME sleuthing RG :good:
There must be dozens if not hundreds of different types of these Gold Pagodas out there.
They are too expensive for me to get a set of them so I will call it quits with the 2 types I have so far and concentrate on getting the other Gold in the Proc set.
I still have the guinea, the Johanna's  and the Gold Mohur  to get over the next couple of years.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

nealeffendi

Just purchased (B.I.N.) a 1937 crown (eBay item 331273623239). Its in a ICCS holder as MS64. Never seen a ICCS coin before but the Canuks rate them highly so I hope it will cross over to PCGS.

trout

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='55770' dateline='1406593288'Just purchased (B.I.N.) a 1937 crown (eBay item 331273623239). Its in a ICCS holder as MS64. Never seen a ICCS coin before but the Canuks rate them highly so I hope it will cross over to PCGS.

From what I have seen ICCS is a tougher grader than PCGS as far as the Canadians are concerned.
Aim well to enjoy life. You only get One shot at it.
Illegitimi non carborundum

markn

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='55770' dateline='1406593288'Just purchased (B.I.N.) a 1937 crown (eBay item 331273623239). Its in a ICCS holder as MS64. Never seen a ICCS coin before but the Canuks rate them highly so I hope it will cross over to PCGS.

Sounds interesting, would love to hear how it goes.  The only coin I've cross from an ICCS holder was  1964Y halfpenny that crossed from an MS65RB ICCS into the same grade at PCGS.  I have a few other ICCS coins too, all Canadian, and they seem well graded.
Founder: Australian Coin Forum
The Australian Coin Collecting Blog

robbiegal

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='55770' dateline='1406593288'Just purchased (B.I.N.) a 1937 crown (eBay item 331273623239). Its in a ICCS holder as MS64. Never seen a ICCS coin before but the Canuks rate them highly so I hope it will cross over to PCGS.

are my eyes deceiving and it's a Dot variety?

accumulator

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='55770' dateline='1406593288'Just purchased (B.I.N.) a 1937 crown (eBay item 331273623239). Its in a ICCS holder as MS64. Never seen a ICCS coin before but the Canuks rate them highly so I hope it will cross over to PCGS.

The doubling on all the reverse legends & date is the most obvious i've seen.

Goldseeker

I have the following two items on EBay:   Item Numbers 111421477160 and 111421471896 if anyone is interested.

Items end on Tuesday, 5 Aug 2014.
Message rec\'d from Jens Coins 18 Jul 23: 
Bruce Mansfield passed away today 18 Jul 2023 – Acute Myeloid Leukemia


Nightparrot

Quote from: 'Goldseeker' pid='55869' dateline='1406682107'I have the following two items on EBay:   Item Numbers 111421477160 and 111421471896 if anyone is interested.

Items end on Tuesday, 5 Aug 2014.

Goldseeker, i notice you say your preferred payment method is direct deposit. I always say that too when selling but I find everyone just uses Paypal. What's your experience with that?

robbiegal

I am happy to do bank transfer if I get to know the seller but I don't like to use it with unknown sellers

Goldseeker

I just go with the flow.   If buyers use paypal then as soon as the money is available I take it.   If I am the buyer, I send an email asking for their bank details so I can direct deposit.

I have been doing it this way since my first trade on ebay and have had ZERO problems.

For Robbiegal:   Why worry, they can't withdraw from your account at all.  

It is either an EFT or direct bank deposit.   That way the payment is almost immediately available to yourself to do as you want with it and best part is, NO FEES.
Message rec\'d from Jens Coins 18 Jul 23: 
Bruce Mansfield passed away today 18 Jul 2023 – Acute Myeloid Leukemia


kchan1111

Quote from: 'Goldseeker' pid='55890' dateline='1406719555'For Robbiegal:   Why worry, they can't withdraw from your account at all.  

Doesn't Paypal have dispute resolution? They can reverse the charges if something goes wrong.

Also I link my Paypal with credit card which earns frequent flyer points. Plus there is a second party (card's issuing bank) I can turn to to get my money back if seller is dodgy.

But if I know the seller I would try to save him or her the fees, cause I don't need the protection.