PCGS submissions, Grading Opinions

[echidna]

Hey Guys,

I got 3 more of my NGC coins regraded by PCGS today. To say the least I am very disappointed to see the grading differences between the two TPG companies. (except 1)

1920 M 3D (was AU58) Now AU55
1934 Florin (was MS62) Now AU58:dodgy:
1959 Proof 3D (was PR66) Now PR65
1938 Shilling (Was MS65) Now MS65 :yahoo:

Do you have the PCGS links to the above ?

[ausproofs]

Hey Guys,

I got 3 more of my NGC coins regraded by PCGS today. To say the least I am very disappointed to see the grading differences between the two TPG companies. (except 1)

1920 M 3D (was AU58) Now AU55
1934 Florin (was MS62) Now AU58:dodgy:
1959 Proof 3D (was PR66) Now PR65
1938 Shilling (Was MS65) Now MS65 :yahoo:

Do you have the PCGS links to the above ?

here you go..


http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/30967513.html
http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/30967514.html
http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/30967515.html
http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/30967516.html

[oh my florin]

Nice Coins and the 1938 Shilling looks like it has the beginnings of radial die cracks on the reverse.

[echidna]

Hey Guys,

I got 3 more of my NGC coins regraded by PCGS today. To say the least I am very disappointed to see the grading differences between the two TPG companies. (except 1)

1920 M 3D (was AU58) Now AU55
1934 Florin (was MS62) Now AU58:dodgy:
1959 Proof 3D (was PR66) Now PR65
1938 Shilling (Was MS65) Now MS65 :yahoo:

Do you have the PCGS links to the above ?

here you go..


http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/30967513.html
http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/30967514.html
http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/30967515.html
http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/30967516.html

I'd be happy with those PCGS grades if it were me.
NGC generally overgrades.
And they sell for much less on ebay and Numisbid.

[ausproofs]

Thanks guys,  I have paid bit too much for the Florin and the 1920 3D... thats why I was bit upset... I am happy with the Shill... its a nice coin...

[echidna]

http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/27455086.html

This one was resubmitted and came back 64+BN.
Previously graded 64BN.
Still unhappy as it looks RB to me.
What do you think ?

[ausproofs]

http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/27455086.html

This one was resubmitted and came back 64+BN.
Previously graded 64BN.
Still unhappy as it looks RB to me.
What do you think ?

That coin is a RB ! What makes it BN ? :idea:

[nealeffendi]

http://www.pcgs.com/Cert/27455086.html

This one was resubmitted and came back 64+BN.
Previously graded 64BN.
Still unhappy as it looks RB to me.
What do you think ?

That coin is a RB ! What makes it BN ? :idea:

Probably yank graders used to their deep red copper "pennies" and not to our bronze "large cents"

[serial]

wow! if that is bn it is right on the edge!

[stevo1962]

Going to give these a try at PCGS to see how they go

[keldaw]

very nice steve ,i hope you do well with them rounds .    ,, kel ,,

[stevo1962]

very nice steve ,i hope you do well with them rounds .    ,, kel ,,

Thank you Kel

[echidna]

Currently at PCGS.
My guess MS63.
What do you reckon ?

[Nightparrot]

Currently at PCGS.
My guess MS63.
What do you reckon ?

Agree....

[stevo1962]

I think 64 would be a possibility