1915H Shilling Ebay

Started by r9453, August 22, 2013, 12:06:32 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

r9453

This listing is from a dealer I.S.Wright Adelaide grade is 'EF REALLY NICE' price is $1495. I can't see a full set of pearls for a start, so I don't think its EF. And I have to wonder, is it cleaned?

Two Bob coin collector.

stevo1962

Yeah it's definately cleaned and would would fall short of EF  IMO and at $1500 it's full
retail for an EF coin so definately overpriced in my book.I think half that price would be
fair but I doubt he would come down by that much- maybe I'm a bit harsh but just my
opinion
It\'s not about who you know it\'s about what you know

wwwww

That's only a cleaned, low end gVF (XF45 equivalent), worth $400 on a good day.

It looks like they're grading by band detail with no adjustment for strike or other aspects of the coin.

This coin on the other hand:
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/AUSTRALIA-1916-M-SILVER-FLORIN-LUSTROUS-EF-REALLY-NICE-/390640035977?pt=AU_Coins2&hash=item5af3f5e889

Also called EF is really gEF-aUNC (AU55-AU58 equivalent). They have the same band detail so they must be the same grade right??

That's what happens when you only look at the band to grade.

stevo1962

Here's one from ebay in about the same condition but priced at $850

[attachment=2270]
It\'s not about who you know it\'s about what you know

r9453

Quote from: 'wwwww' pid='25816' dateline='1377140386'That's only a cleaned, low end gVF (XF45 equivalent), worth $400 on a good day.

OK, that's that then.

QuoteAlso called EF is really gEF-aUNC (AU55-AU58 equivalent). They have the same band detail so they must be the same grade right??

You would look at the reverse as well, surely. And more, strike etc.

QuoteThat's what happens when you only look at the band to grade.

I will look at the moustache and beard, the regalia. On the reverse I look for the point of the star and the grass.

Quote from: 'stevo1962' pid='25817' dateline='1377140451'Here's one from ebay in about the same condition but priced at $850

I had a look and couldn't find it, from the photo it looks OK but never mind. I already have a 1915H just like the one in the OP.
Two Bob coin collector.

enworb

Its a typical IS Wright Adelaide coin.