Has anyone come across this error before

Started by petpat, May 30, 2016, 07:23:09 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

petpat

I was going through my old penny collection and came across this spectacular error.  I was just wondering if anyone else had seen this error.
Only half the bottom scroll and missing the I.

[attachment=3511]

robbiegal


Fulvio

http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

humpybong

Never seen it before...what a great find.
Cheers
Barry
humpybong
Moderator

\"Experience enables you to recognise a mistake when you make it a again\"

Robster

Wonderful error plus the coin is good condition!
\"Everything in moderation, including moderation\".

r9453

What Fulvio said. When you look closely at a regular 1916 penny you can see that the scrolls are separate and the left one extends to the centre of the "E" - it looks like the tip is still visible here. Renniks list a variety with a missing mint mark.
Two Bob coin collector.

gnome

Yes nice find :), think there is a 1917 penny like that as well.

Nevol

I have an electronic version of a Coin Book on Aust Pre-Decimal Varieties written by a very keen collector, Mostyn Byrnes, (now dec'd), and he mentions the missing I, but not the missing ½ Scroll.
A Platypus is a duck designed by a committee ( anon)

nealeffendi

I have 3 of the filled I variety, but the missing half scroll is a new one to me, it is also not your usual weak scroll but a nicely struck half a scroll and then a sudden change to nothingness. A bit like shaving off  one side of a nice pair of moustaches, it really stands out.

Fulvio

Quote from: 'Nevol' pid='89674' dateline='1464649562'I have an electronic version of a Coin Book on Aust Pre-Decimal Varieties written by a very keen collector, Mostyn Byrnes, (now dec'd), and he mentions the missing I, but not the missing ½ Scroll.

I'm really leery of 'reference' works that list flaws like this.

This type of work is meant as a guide as to what you can expect to find in circulation. So of course Varieties and Errors are fair game, since they're repeatable. Anybody can acquire a cud, bubble or die clash, because there are heaps of them in existence, and apart from progressive die deterioration, they're all the same.

But when it comes to fills, strikethroughs and other flaws, they may be unique. And even if they're not, the run length before the crud moved or was removed is unknown. Its next to impossible to get two identical coins, so why list them in a reference work like that?

Now, a non-reference work, lets call it a coffee table coin art book with big glossy pictures, that's a whole different story. Pretty, yes. Useful, no.
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW

r9453

:i_agree: The one thing you don't get in any of the reference books (errors, varieties, whatever) is big glossy pictures. More is the pity because when it comes to coins a picture is worth, um, about a thousand words.

With the OP coin its hard to imagine whatever filled the left scroll simply popped out after a couple of strikes. Maybe the operator saw what was happening and put a stop to it?
Two Bob coin collector.

robbiegal

the photo isn't clear enough really to determine the error genuine or post mint

Nevol

QuoteI'm really leery of 'reference' works that list flaws like this.
Now, a non-reference work, lets call it a coffee table coin art book with big glossy pictures, that's a whole different story. Pretty, yes. Useful, no.
Sorry to disillusion you, but no glossy pictures at all in this one, just hand drawings.

I refer to it on a fairly regular basis, even if it's just to see if a certain error or variety was know at the time of publishing in 2000.
A Platypus is a duck designed by a committee ( anon)

r9453

I have a PDF copy of the book by Mr. Mostyn Byrnes referred to by Nevol. The hand drawings are actually schematic diagrams and he uses his own reference numbers. I'm not sure how it relates to the other references such as Renniks. I find the PDF format a bit clunky to use but I'm glad to have it. I should try to make better use of it.
Two Bob coin collector.

Fulvio

Quote from: 'Nevol' pid='89717' dateline='1464733542'Sorry to disillusion you, but no glossy pictures at all in this one, just hand drawings.

Yes, I know. I have the book, remember? :)

What I was saying is that such a book, were it to be produced, would be about the only sensible place for such unique flaws. They have no place in a work intended to be used as a guide for what to look for.

Consider your own work in documenting progressive die deterioration for example. Each step could be considered a different error, except we know they're not. See my point? :angel:
http://fulvio55.altervista.org/ - Decimal Mintages and Polymer Notes PDFs
Doge: DG8r9JJnWCHVvd1iG4BJeJMj5g1reYTnSc - BTC: 1FFnNxMDNCnQEjHrh9EhnHZoDMjkbf1seW