1942 Penny with "JH" initials

Started by echidna, December 20, 2022, 06:33:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

echidna

" />
" />
" />

" />



Both appear to be struck through errors.
Would be interested in opinions.

Mister T

Both Melbourne Mint?
Not sure what to make of the H - too regular.

fred lever

Hi Echidna, looks like idle time in the workshop again!
I have coins that have been beaten up by tools ranging from number and letter stamps down to chisels, tin snips, wire cutters, you name it.
Mr JHK obviously decided to give a couple of pennies a hiding, maybe practising his "engraving" skills?
I go for the idle time in the workshop theory, not the struck through theory.
Fred.

JeffH

Hey, that must be my penny. That's my initials!
Thinking is dangerous, it makes you think. That\'s why many people avoid it.

autocoupler

This post will no doubt show my ignorance of things of this nature. But, just referring to the first two pics only, would a white-hot branding iron result in something like that?
As we age we lose three things, one is our memory and arrrrr I've forgotten the other two!

gweidion

I reckon someone at the mint was playing about with the blank planchets to see what would happen when they passed through the presses, probably to see if it would wipe out any alterations. I know I would have been keen to try that if I worked there.

echidna


gweidion

It doesn't look like PMD because the detail is all there in the added letters. If it was PMD the detail would be destroyed.
I reckon it had to be done to the planchet before it went into the press.

fred lever

Gweidion nice train of thought, but I'm not sure.
look at the obverse of the 22.
The centre area shows flattening as it would supporting something hammered into the reverse.
The obverse centre flattens and spreads a bit.
Also note the pock mark damage as if the coin was not sitting on a clean dead flat surface.
The other thing that catches the eye on the reverse are the straight lines running from the top of the K to the y in penny.
Thats like the edge of the body of an "initials" letter stamp just catching the metal.
The coin also has the marks of a coin that has been in a fire and corroded.

As for the 42, i'm not even sure that is a stamping now, more like an electrode tip melting the metal to draw the initials.
Like a very small tip on a modellers torch.
Nah I'm crazy.

Torch? blows from a small punch? pre strike ?post strike?, ......the questions keep coming.
My head hurts!!!!

Fred.

gweidion

Quote from: 'fred lever' pid='127580' dateline='1671827570'Gweidion nice train of thought, but I'm not sure.
look at the obverse of the 22.
The centre area shows flattening as it would supporting something hammered into the reverse.
The obverse centre flattens and spreads a bit.
Also note the pock mark damage as if the coin was not sitting on a clean dead flat surface.
The other thing that catches the eye on the reverse are the straight lines running from the top of the K to the y in penny.
Thats like the edge of the body of an "initials" letter stamp just catching the metal.
The coin also has the marks of a coin that has been in a fire and corroded.

As for the 42, i'm not even sure that is a stamping now, more like an electrode tip melting the metal to draw the initials.
Like a very small tip on a modellers torch.
Nah I'm crazy.

Torch? blows from a small punch? pre strike ?post strike?, ......the questions keep coming.
My head hurts!!!!

Fred.

Thanks Fred, didn't mean to do your head in. Yes the 22 obverse looks heavily worn compared to the reverse so you are probably right about it being a metal letter stamp.

ttkoo

While there are theories being formed, I would put forward this about the '22. Similar thoughts to Fred for the '42,  that a TIG welder was used, but on the older coin it was used to lay a rough pattern of the outlines of the initials onto the flat end of a piece of hex bar, to form a punch, and it was mashed into the coin post mint. The thickness of the weld bead was very fine on the H and much more heavy for the K which looks like a post mint DDR!
The '42 it certainly looks like a tungsten tip was used to melt the H straight into the obverse, the J reverse looks weird though....but I'm losing no sleep about that.
Both look to have been aged, the 42 in a fire. IMO
The Ox moves slowly, but the Earth is patient.