Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - Geordie

#1
Quote from: 'gweidion' pid='126499' dateline='1656250655'Have you tested to see if it is actually silver and not a counterfeit one? Easiest test is to use a rare earth magnet to check.

Hi gweidion,

Thanks for the suggestion, just tried that now, definitely not magnetic.

--G
#2
Quote from: 'Mister T' pid='126497' dateline='1656229936'I'm not sure what to make of it, though I'm tending towards deliberate damage - I think the coin shouldn't spread out like that during striking because it's in a collar. If it were struck out of a collar the spread should be reasonably even. The only other way for it to spread is if it was a brockage, but I'd expect an even spread for that too (but I could be wrong).

Hi T,

Thanks for the reply !

Note that the damaged one is exactly the size of a normal sixpence, so it has not spread out at all beyond the size of a standard sixpence (pic 1).

The last 3 pics I lined up the edge of the whole one with the various grooves on the damaged one to see if they were the same radius as a sixpence, which they seem to be.

Edit: I thought that that might help given that if the radius was different it would definitely indicate post production damage.

--Geordie
#3
OK,

So a few comparisons with another sixpence.

First pic confirms that the damaged one is exactly the same size as another sixpence, you can just see a bit of the whole one beneath peeking through in the gap on the right.



The rest of the following shots I am attempting to show a comparison of the edge of the whole sixpence with each of the grooves in the damaged one.








They *seem* to match which suggests that it was probably caused by a multiple strike during minting.

The only other theory I have is, that someone put another sixpence on top of this one and bashed it with a hammer, several times, on both sides.

I hope these pics help, let me know if there is any other "test" I can do that may help work it out.


thanks

--Geordie
#4
Quote from: 'Mister T' pid='126493' dateline='1656197000'Does it match the dimensions of a real sixpence?

Interesting idea, I will post another few pics with a comparison

--Geordie
#5
Hello internet coin people !

I do a bit of metal detecting in my spare time and last year I dug this up this sixpence in a Brisbane park.

I was telling my dad about it, and it turns out he use to be a coin collector himself who was interested in fractions/errors/varieties and said that it could be one.

Unfortunately he is legally blind these days so not really able to tell me any more than that.

So I have finally gotten around to seeking a place where someone might be able to shed some light on it,  and that led me here :-)

Due to the somewhat non-subtle nature of the defect, I will not bother to describe it, but I am interested in whether it might be a minting error (maybe catastrophe might be a better word) or just some random damage that occurred during its lifetime.





Any thoughts are welcome

thanks

--Geordie