How would you grade this coin?
Scans
[attachment=1797][attachment=1798]
USB Pics
[attachment=1799][attachment=1800]
More USB pics
[attachment=1801][attachment=1802]
[attachment=1803][attachment=1804]
Hard to tell except for the closeup of the emu but looks unc with maybe a weak
obverse strike
Pretty hard to tell from those images but looks to me to have a bit of run on queens neck and shoulders. Looks UNC though.
Quote from: 'enworb' pid='13413' dateline='1367276873'Pretty hard to tell from those images but looks to me to have a bit of run on queens neck and shoulders. Looks UNC though.
Unlike most of you guys I take crappy pics :dash1:
A brand new 14 megawahtsie camera and this is the best I can do.
[attachment=1805][attachment=1806]
I forgot to add that the fields on this coin have a mirror finish (not cleaned) and the obverse has wide spaced parallel lines across the coin.
I can only guess that these are from a touch up on the die ?
I see a fair bit of chatter on HM's shoulder. MS63 I guess. It doesn't look much better than that.
Better pictures Jim still UNC but wouldnt narrow it down any more than that
Quote from: 'markn' pid='13415' dateline='1367278900'I see a fair bit of chatter on HM's shoulder. MS63 I guess. It doesn't look much better than that.
It is in fact a PCGS MS63 grade.
That little bit if chatter is enough to keep the grade down to a 63 :ok:
[attachment=1810]
This is also a PCGS MS63 graded coin, this not only has "chatter" on the coin but the lettering is pretty banged up and it has dings in the fields.
If they applied the same grading technique to both coins the why are they graded the same when they are NOT ?
Perhaps there's hairlines on the 6d you haven't seen. Perhaps there's issues with the lustre your images don't make obvious. Perhaps the size of the bagmarks on the 6d relative to the size of the coin are much more distracting to those on the Frankie. Perhaps the Frankie is extremely lustrous and they've given it a bonus point for that. Remember that they take into account a number of different factors. To be honest though your images are so poor it's hard to say anything about either of those coins without any real certainty.
You should get the idea out of your head that PCGS victimise Australian coins or that there's some sort of black magic that only people in Australia understand when grading Aussie coins. PCGS largely use the same standards to grade all coins regardless of origin. I'd venture a guess that right now they've probably graded more high grade Australian coins than any Australian dealer could ever hope to.
The obverse of the 6d has a scrape like effect on the right of the queen,or thats how it looks to me.
There's nothing in your photos to indicate those two coins are a vastly different grade (in fact if I were buying either from those photos I'd conclude MS63 on both). I see the point you're trying to make but perhaps you can post clearer photos.
In regards to your previous point about many US coins grading higher, there's a reason for this and the same reason applies to certain Aussie coins too. Take a look at the population charts, find the pre-decimal coins with a relative abundance of coins in high MS grades, notice the pattern? They're all years that rolls (or other original hoards) were found of. Almost every uncirculated pre-decimal coin that has gone through the Australian market has been mishandled (dipped, cleaned, touched, rubbed, PVC, cabinet friction, etc). When you pull coins straight out of rolls their superior condition shoots out at you and you'll start to realise how incredibly difficult it is to get a coin in a matching grade from the open market.
It is SOOOO frustrating being totally useless with a Camera :dash1:
Quote from: 'trout' pid='13434' dateline='1367288969'It is SOOOO frustrating being totally useless with a Camera :dash1:
I'm pretty useless with them too but my photos turn out fine.
Here's how I do it
- I mount my camera on a tripod facing directly down, 90 degrees
- I use a remote shutter to prevent my pressing of the button vibrating the camera
- I set everything on Auto (using the flash for lighting)
- I have a macro lens, if you don't, or use a normal camera, turn on the macro function
Quote from: 'wwwww' pid='13435' dateline='1367289281'Quote from: 'trout' pid='13434' dateline='1367288969'It is SOOOO frustrating being totally useless with a Camera :dash1:
I'm pretty useless with them too but my photos turn out fine.
Here's how I do it
- I mount my camera on a tripod facing directly down, 90 degrees
- I use a remote shutter to prevent my pressing of the button vibrating the camera
- I set everything on Auto (using the flash for lighting)
- I have a macro lens, if you don't, or use a normal camera, turn on the macro function
I will have to get a decent tripod:angel::angel:
This pic shows the strange lines on this coin, they are not scratches and seem to be part of the metal ?
[attachment=1811]