Australian-Coins Forum

Numismatic Discussion => Coin and Banknote Grading => Topic started by: wwwww on April 19, 2013, 03:53:13 PM

Title: 1924 Florin
Post by: wwwww on April 19, 2013, 03:53:13 PM
Here's an interesting coin,

(http://downloads.putme.net/0/rev.jpg)
(http://downloads.putme.net/0/obv.jpg)
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: trout on April 19, 2013, 04:24:45 PM
it is interesting , Especially the colour and the lack of detail/strike on the obverse and reverse.
Could it possibly be a "Test" coin to test the pressure of the press ?
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: accumulator on April 19, 2013, 04:33:06 PM
Well, i see a die crack that goes almost all the way around the reverse & what must be die clash on the obverse.
Or is there something else Walter ?
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: Australian coin on April 19, 2013, 04:46:31 PM
did a search info links >> its a short 4 and broken letters with die crack
also has a weird texture to the upper right, maybe some greening, and maybe a bit of an impression part, and a tiny cud above the m, now my eyes hurt..
http://www.australianstamp.com/Coin-web/aust/florin/1924flor.htm
http://www.triton.vg/F24-26.html
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: Robster on April 19, 2013, 05:06:49 PM
Almost looks like it has been dipped in acid.! Makes the short 4 very obvious.:idea:
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: wwwww on April 19, 2013, 05:53:57 PM
I was actually looking to see how people would grade it.
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: Fr45h3R on April 19, 2013, 06:07:45 PM
I'm thinking this is a trick question.
From the ANDA guide, its a good VG, but based on the lustre and the metal colour, I'd grade that a good EF.
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: Fordprefect on April 19, 2013, 06:19:14 PM
I'd say overall aVF with the reverse being better. :angel:
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: keldaw on April 19, 2013, 06:35:08 PM
I think it is a fake and made from steel ..   ,, kel ,,

same as mine ... ,, kel ,,

(http://i48.tinypic.com/fphzp.jpg)
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: robbiegal on April 19, 2013, 07:15:13 PM
:exclamation:
I like that one kel

is it really made from steel??

wwwww world wide web's coin
has a brilliant star

almost as nice as the dodgey star on your coin!!
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: stevo1962 on April 19, 2013, 07:22:46 PM
I reckon the 1924 is a fake
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: robbiegal on April 19, 2013, 07:32:19 PM
seriously?

you don't often see die cracks on a fake

- ok the votes are

die cracks
short '4'
obv cud (great observations AC)
dipped in acid
test strike
great looking star (almost too good looking)
fake

grades

vf

ef

one very interesting coin here
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: trout on April 19, 2013, 08:12:03 PM
Quote from: 'stevo1962' pid='12457' dateline='1366365166'I reckon the 1924 is a fake

I agree with Steve :ok:
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: echidna on April 19, 2013, 10:11:10 PM
1924 florins are generally poorly struck and very concave.
Grading should take this sort of strike into account.
I would grade it F/gVF with qualifications.
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: wwwww on April 20, 2013, 10:05:26 AM
A wide range of opinions here, everything from gVG to gEF. The coin is real of course, a good percentage of 1924 florins have this appearance. It's been lightly dipped though.

If one were to grade the coin strictly on its surfaces, you'd get the grading of aEF or AU53, there's plenty of lustre on the reverse, obverse has traces of lustre in the fields.

But, AU (or gVF) requires full details as struck, there's clearly wear on the band. The reason for this disparity is the concavity of the strike has protected the reverse and to some extent the obverse fields, but exposed the centre of the obverse to wear. This is how an AU55-AU58 would look like:

(http://www.aussiecoins.com/coins/FlorinsCrowns/1924-florin%20both.jpg)

As you can see there's quite a bit of difference so it does have wear. If you grade strictly by wear, the high points are worn away but otherwise the coin is mostly unworn (note the robes, emu, etc compared with the AU example), so you get VF (or XF40). Just imagine that if the coin had 8 pearls but a mostly flat emu, what would be the grading?

Following the ANDA guide you'd look at the band, and assign a VG grading.

PCGS graded this coin XF40 so it's based entirely on wear. This coin is a good reminder that surface grading (via lustre) is only an estimation of wear and relies on an even distribution of surface contact throughout the coin (something that's not going to happen on a concave strike), while detail gradng is also only an estimation of wear and relies on a pre-defined detail->wear profile which can never be 100% accurate as many coins wear and are struck differently, the ANDA guidelines only being accurate for about 90% of Geo V issues with other series being less well defined).

Interestingly, you get a similar wear profile on 1932 and 1933 florins (though to a lesser extent). 1923's too.
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: keldaw on April 20, 2013, 05:31:29 PM
Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='12454' dateline='1366364713':exclamation:
I like that one kel

is it really made from steel??

wwwww world wide web's coin
has a brilliant star

almost as nice as the dodgey star on your coin!!

well Robbie , I always thought it was and that is what I marked the 2x2 as being steel but on reading the letter again from the person I got it from , and after your query about it, and his exact  wording,s were ( A COUNTERFEIT/CONTEMPORARY COPY OF A 1935 FLORIN )I now have to re think my thinking ..   ,, kel ,,
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: robbiegal on April 20, 2013, 08:42:36 PM
well Kel
I reckon a steel forgery would be tops
my fakes are all light materials and maybe dipped in aluminium or lead to look like silver

in fact I have a have a gawd awful fake crown - only one side - made of lead
probably for a school project or something
it weighs a ton
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: keldaw on April 21, 2013, 07:14:14 AM
Robbie , I now think you are right , I just put it on a magnet on the back of a torch and it did not stick to it , so that's makes me think it is not a steel copy now .. so I don't know what they are made from , .

                               ,, kel ,,
Title: RE: 1924 Florin
Post by: robbiegal on April 21, 2013, 09:03:28 AM
hi kel
I think that some fakes are quite a mystery product

the 1931 or 28 (?) chinise minted shillings were almost pure silver and the twible and manders were the sterling silver

most of mine are moulded coins with quite rough surfaces
metal unknown! so I keep them in a folder separate to my other coins

although the copper fakes look & feel like copper