Ok, so what coins do we slab and when do you slab them? Are new coins worth slabbing or leaving for a few years?
it is all about condition, variety or rarity
so if you had a proof coin from a proof set, or a mint coin from a mint set.
then there are error coins and variety, so if you found a coin that had some spectacular mistrike or die crack or cud.
if you were thinking about doing a new release coin, I would be thinking about the mintage, if a small mintage then maybe.
most new releases are NCLT and come in mint condition with packaging and they are probably not going to be rare with large mintages.
other coin are the circulation coins, and they usually release a good amount anyway, so you would be looking at quality - the earlier you can grab one with few circulation marks the better the coin. even then you would have to ask was this design only for circulation or can I grab it from a set or something in mint condition then its probably not going to be worth much as a circulation coin when better examples can be easily obtained elsewhere, then the last would be was there a variance from what the normal design was.
I guess a example would be the commemorative $2
2012 Remembrance Day $2 commemorative circulating coin
(http://www.ramint.gov.au/media/press-releases/2012/images/20121026-CIRC-Remembrance-Poppy_REV.jpg)
2012 Remembrance Day $2 commemorative coloured circulating coin
(http://www.ramint.gov.au/media/press-releases/2012/images/20121026-Remembrance-Poppy_REV.jpg)
2012 Remembrance Day $2 'C' mintmark commemorative colour printed coin
(http://t1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcT2cfgclgA1SSdORs7aJCku6SzqyYgtxx5diMewTqQbeiAEDh2FuA:www.coincity.com.au/catalog/images/2012%2520%242%2520Remebrance%2520day%2520coin%2520in%2520card%2520large.gif)
so you know that the c mintmark coin can be obtained in mint condition anywhere from several forms of packaging.
so this wouldn't be that interesting to slab.
then there is the coloured one from the RSL that was struck in a circulation strike, and didn't end up in circulation, was stupidly hard to obtain in good condition with few marks, because of the handling and preparation from mint to RSL, this would be interesting to slab :exclamation:
and last would be the circulation issue, they were release into circulation as one hit, people surely horded them, I know I did, so the question becomes, mintage - 5 million is it a big mintage - probably not, but your not going to think so until 10years later when you just cant find them in circulation anymore, then quality - and this is the biggie they could be obtained in pretty good nick at first from security bags, so there are going to be quite a few good obtainable examples around, not something to jump into for instant payback for your investment, sit on this for 10years.
few I think I got it feel free to tell me how you see it :winkextra:
I dunno.. I'm not convinced. I've always viewed slabbing as a typical yank moneymaking scheme that relies on people being too lazy/stupid to grade a coin. Much like NCLT, it becomes all about the wrapping, not the contents.
But hey, what would I know? ;)
Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='11362' dateline='1365068164'Ok, so what coins do we slab and when do you slab them? Are new coins worth slabbing or leaving for a few years?
Do the numbers. If you can better realise a coin's value by getting it certified, then do so. Even if you don't intend to sell it, having it graded still needs to make financial sense, as the $40+ grading fee is not cheap.
Equally, there are instances where a coin is better left "in the wild" ie uncertified. An example is when a coin grades AU58 with PCGS. If the coin is unsalable in this grade, often it's better to simply crack out the coin and sell it as UNC through an auction house. More often than not, it sells for more than an AU58 might sell for.
Of course, if the coin is worth less than the slabbing fee, no amount of PCGS grading is going to enhance its value.
Thanks team, very helpful and all food for thought :good: