Australian-Coins Forum

Australian Coins, Banknotes and Exonumia => Australian Errors and Varieties => Topic started by: echidna on June 01, 2021, 07:09:38 PM

Title: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: echidna on June 01, 2021, 07:09:38 PM
(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/qE6jqmx.jpg)" />

1919 dot below penny DDR and DDO.
This coin was previously described in the old catalogues as the "wide date" variety.
I guess that they were looking at low grade examples where the doubling was not evident.
Hence the "wide date".

More interesting is the dot however.
Check it out.
Reverse doubling is evident except for the dot.
Why ?
Must have been added after hubbing.
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: nealeffendi on June 01, 2021, 08:17:57 PM
I have many hundreds of 1919 pennies and there are at least 2 different widths of wide date that I noticed, the width is actual and not an artifact of the doubling. The dots were added to each working die. I have a few from this die pairing but only in average condition. Yours is a beauty.
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: Goldseeker on June 01, 2021, 10:16:02 PM
Please explain in simple terms the meaning of DDR and DDO?
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: fred lever on June 02, 2021, 06:33:02 AM
Hi Goldie, what Neal said, plus I looked at the PCGS entry because I wondered what DDR and DDO  meant as well!
The entry says "doubled die obverse/rev".
Uh huh. So now its a 1919 DOTS,DUBS,DDR,DDO!
To me they are talking about the HUB striking error evident on both sides where the previous hub strikes on the dies were not obliterated and a bit of "doubling" of the letters shows.
Never looked at that before so now I have to dig out all my 1919 DD and look for that as well.
Great.
Cheers, Fred.
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: nealeffendi on June 02, 2021, 09:12:54 AM
In simple terms the fault is caused by the hubbing process (where the working die that makes the coins is made from a hub). For the penny there were 3 blows of the hub onto the die to give a full impression. The mint worker didn't align the hub and die to the exact same position so the 3rd blow was rotated slightly so instead of making the 2nd blow impression stronger he made another impression off by a hairs width.
Why they didn't scrap such imperfect dies is down to many possible reasons; they needed to cover a coin shortage, they were short of dies, they were short of die steel, cost/economy reasons, not caring, not being observant.
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: Goldseeker on June 02, 2021, 10:02:12 AM
OK, thanks.
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: fred lever on June 03, 2021, 10:50:03 AM
I had a read of my research on the 1919 to prod my memory.
That research was published in the September 2013 issue of CAB.
I covered a lot of subjects from observation of hundreds of coins and established a basic set of variety labelling mainly to do with dots and dates, upsets and so on.
The point to keep in mind with the 19 is the tooling for the dies has THREE origins.
Theses are better researched in Davids Briggs book on coppers.
These give rise to all sorts of differences in the coin appearances such as the letter foot curving distortion and the date variations.
No, there are no "wide date" or "narrow date" varieties!
What there is is dozens of dies and punches with all sorts of manufacturing distortions and goof ups.
That gives you dozens of variations in lettering and date numeral placement.
The end 1 and 9 squirm about all over the place and the letters wriggle about as the metal flowed.
Briggs summerises it as tooling A, B and C.
A, being Melbourne concocted dies with curvy letters.
B, being English source tools with flat foot letters.
c, being Melbourne dies concocted from English tooling.
In that lot there are dates that appear wide or narrow depending on how the last 9 was punched(hubbing).
A very complex coin.
It takes about an hour to read my endless dribble in the CAB mag and finish up with Brigg's description of the tooling.
Than you go back to your 1919 examples and see all sorts of things you never saw before!!
Fred.
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: echidna on June 03, 2021, 07:59:04 PM
(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/XWhQqVw.jpg)" />

Some nice separation.
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: Basilstate on June 03, 2021, 09:16:59 PM
Great Pics. Echi.
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: autocoupler on June 03, 2021, 11:07:04 PM
Quote from: 'Basilstate' pid='124947' dateline='1622720819'Great Pics. Echi.

 :i_agree: Excellent pics
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: fred lever on June 04, 2021, 06:41:38 AM
RE #8 PIX.
What a great example showing how the hubbing punch impression can go wrong in the outer section of a die.
Move in a bit and the details like the scroll are near perfect.
Look at the rim denticles and circle dots (no one looks at those!), they are a real mess.
I used to look at 1919 and 1920 coins and thought they were worn.
Then I realised that they were just from a poorly made (or badly wearing) die.
That realisation then lead to understanding that the punch and die come first and even a mint state coin can look badly worn if the die is cactus!
It would be nice if one could "invert" that image, that is turn the view from concave to incuse, then that image would be a picture of what the die looked like.
Then one could clearly see that the last punch blow did not fully cover over the preceding blow and multiple features are left behind.
We could call that die the "fat denticle and date" variety!
Fred.
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: echidna on November 17, 2022, 09:45:18 PM
Looks like PCGS are attributing these now.

1919 //. (m) 1D Dot below, DDOR
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: serenitystan on November 21, 2022, 09:08:33 AM
The date and ONE PENNY are doubled, yet the beads and Commonwealth of Australia are plain?? Die hubbed in sections??
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: echidna on November 21, 2022, 08:07:19 PM
Hi Stan

There is doubling visible in AUSTRALIA.
Separation is visible in both of the As.
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: serenitystan on November 21, 2022, 08:37:19 PM
Quote from: 'echidna' pid='127393' dateline='1669023439'Hi Stan

There is doubling visible in AUSTRALIA.
Separation is visible in both of the As.

Yes, I can see separation (doubling) on both As..Baffled why only the two As ??? If movement causes doubling why only the two As...
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: ttkoo on August 07, 2023, 06:39:37 AM
I have one similar, when I get a chance I will post it.
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: ttkoo on August 14, 2023, 02:28:24 PM
Of fairly ordinary condition
[attachment=4099]
[attachment=4100]
[attachment=4101]
[attachment=4102]
[attachment=4103]
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: ttkoo on August 14, 2023, 02:34:56 PM
Continued
[attachment=4104]
[attachment=4105]
[attachment=4106]
[attachment=4107]
[attachment=4108]
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: echidna on August 15, 2023, 11:01:09 AM
Nice example
Title: RE: 1919 Penny DDR/DDO but Dot Not Doubled
Post by: Mister T on August 16, 2023, 08:02:31 PM
Nice coin.