(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/GVxiAtS.jpg)" />
(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/J4KB5nW.gif)" />
(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/Uzle4Xz.gif)" />
(//%3Ca%20href=)
(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/TLM7wJt.gif)" />
Two examples of the overdate sixpence.
They all are the "4 close to ornament type" or wide date.
First one has taken a hit on the 4.
Excellent!!
How did you find out about this variety (and how come Dean, Briggs, Saxton etc never even knew this variety existed).
Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='124777' dateline='1621045991'Excellent!!
How did you find out about this variety (and how come Dean, Briggs, Saxton etc never even knew this variety existed).
In general there was more overdating going on than we know.
But in most cases the number underneath was fully obliterated.
So its only some that we know about today, because they are obvious.
Working on this assumption there will be some that are borderline in terms of what is left of the overdate bit.
So do you think it was a case of incomplete removal of the old date from the hub or of partially dated dies? For the threepence and sixpence I'd be guessing the die hubbing process was just 2 blows and not the 3 (as was with the 33/32 penny) so most likely failure to properly de-date the hub.
So with the threepence, sixpence and shilling all likely overdates is there any chance of a full set with a florin overdate?
Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='124779' dateline='1621052600'So do you think it was a case of incomplete removal of the old date from the hub or of partially dated dies? For the threepence and sixpence I'd be guessing the die hubbing process was just 2 blows and not the 3 (as was with the 33/32 penny) so most likely failure to properly de-date the hub.
So with the threepence, sixpence and shilling all likely overdates is there any chance of a full set with a florin overdate?
Fred did make some good comments a while ago about this coin & hubs.
There is an old thread somewhere...
Re the florin, I've been looking for an overdate but haven't seen one.
But if its out there the overdate bit will be very whispy I guess.
(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/Eog60Ad.gif)" />
(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/pNr4zkD.gif)" />
Possible 6d O/D,Pics. sent to me by a collector up here in Northern NSW,i'll try & get some better images when the Coin turns up.
(https://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/11956/503/1934_6d_resize.jpg)
(https://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/11956/503/s-l1600_28129346d.jpg)
(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/1dNAbdV.gif)" />
(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/mrhA8tW.gif)" />
Thanks Basil.
Got it now !
Fantastic die marker.
Hullo All!
When you stand back and widen the view, all these coins are a symptom of the problems at the mint over the years 29 to 34 regarding the lack of exact tooling for each year date change.
The lack of critical expertise in punching and hubbing really shows up in the little coin, the 3d, where there was not the same room as the larger coins to do delicate work.
Hence the mangled trefoils on the 3d and various unfinished grinding off, of end numerals.
I looked at the earlier 3d 22/21 in the June 2016 CAB where there was hanky panky with the 1 and 2 and the 33/34 3d December 2017 and lastly the 1/- August 2016.
David Briggs has covered all the "overdates" in some detail in his books, as shown, and while we may disagree a bit on the exact how and why the coins just reflect the difficultys of the time.
Nice work Ecchi, Basil et al, makes one think a bit.
Like i'm getting a bit uncomfortable about calling coins "overdates".
I know its pedantry, but the "overdates" are on the dies and the hubbing, not the coins.
The coins are the end product of the dies and hubs not the other way around. I:E the coins just produce the evidence of the work, are not the actual thing.
Hmmmmmmm, now I'm starting to write an "opinion piece" and an "argument"!
(gives oneself a slap across the face)
Would be interesting to look at a collection on this theme as already mentioned: a collection of overdate hubs as evidenced by coins of all denomination in the Oz series.
Cheers, Fred.
Hi Fred,good to see you posting,i thought you must have been hibernating for the Winter..LOL.
Don't disagree with anything in your Post but,just as i have stated before,all we have to base an opinion/observation on is the Coin and from markers on it the probable Die types that struck it.
Trying to form facts from what the Mint did,or did not do, 100 years ago is going down one Rabbit Hole too many no matter how accurate the records may appear to be.
Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='124779' dateline='1621052600'So do you think it was a case of incomplete removal of the old date from the hub or of partially dated dies? For the threepence and sixpence I'd be guessing the die hubbing process was just 2 blows and not the 3 (as was with the 33/32 penny) so most likely failure to properly de-date the hub.
So with the threepence, sixpence and shilling all likely overdates is there any chance of a full set with a florin overdate?
(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/cFz9phK.jpg)" />
(//%3Ca%20href=)
The 1934/3 overdate florin will be very whispy if it exists.
Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='124779' dateline='1621052600'So do you think it was a case of incomplete removal of the old date from the hub or of partially dated dies? For the threepence and sixpence I'd be guessing the die hubbing process was just 2 blows and not the 3 (as was with the 33/32 penny) so most likely failure to properly de-date the hub.
So with the threepence, sixpence and shilling all likely overdates is there any chance of a full set with a florin overdate?
Sorry to keep going back to the 1960's but all this,Depression era Die/Hub work,was discussed in depth back then, i spent last w/end trying to find references amongst my Books/Mags/Papers with no success,so far.
I did find a article where the Author stated post WW1 Aust. Mint Records were more to keep their London masters happy than a accurate representation of Mint activities in the period between the wars. He gave egs from the cover up of the 22/21 overdate thru to the 1930 penny and as far as Sydney goes the trial runs of which there was no record other than receiving Dies/Planchets from Melb.
Not sure about the 6d but the the 34 Shilling O/D was a legitmate variety for a period in the 1960's but never made it to mainstream amongst researchers of the time for whatever reason,must have have been 'spalling'... LOL.
My Brother has given me all his 34 Coins so will get them under the Microscope this w/end.
(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/h2oM4XK.jpg)" />
1934 sixpence - not an overdate.
But possibly the remnants of a 4 under the 4 ?
Never seen worse die polishing though.
What on earth did they use to polish the dies ?
Wire brush?
The other day I had a look at my '34 sixpences. Outside of my MS65 example (narrow date) they are a sorry bunch and I found I had only 3 in my album (all the common narrow date and none better than F+) :dash1:
Then today had a look at my stack (low grades) and found 3 more '34s of which 2 were the wide date and one of them is the overdate :yahoo: It has the hyphenated Advance Australia die marker. A pretty sorry example (0 pearls) but still chuffed to have one. Has anyone identified any other die marker from other die pairs? Critics might say the fault that looks like the top loop is just some random defect but if more than one die with this fault is identified then it supports the overdate theory.
Then a squiz at my '34 florins and they all have that blip sticking out from the left side of the foot of the 4. So a fault in the hub?
Based on what I've seen the 1933/4 sixpence appears to be the product of one die only.
Mintage of 1 mil would mean about 25 reverse dies altogether I guess.
I have seen four examples of the overdate altogether and they are all the same, with only a whispy bit of the 3 visible to the left of the 4 plus they all have the same die flaw as mentioned.
I was hoping that there might be another die with a big overdate similar to the threepence but unfortunately this does not seem to be the case.
Having said that, the amount of the 3 that is visible seems to vary with one example showing a bit more to the right of the 4.
So I'm still hopeful that there is a more convincing example out there.
If you have seen only 4 examples then it is too early to say it is the product of a single die.
Look at another scarce sixpence variety, the '26 Serif, looking at the PCGS images the 3 examples are all from the same die, plus the Benchmark catalogue suggests only a single die was used. Yet I have examples from 4 other dies.
Or the scarce'38 Crown, where well over 80% of them are the product of a single die pair, yet I have examples from 3 other die pairs. So those 3 die pairs likely each had a mintage below 5,000.
So until dozens of the variety have been found don't rule out more dies.
Dr Briggs wrote that the mintage was 1,024,000 from 36 dies and about 88% are the narrow date die. Now Dr Briggs also wrote that 3 dies can be identified for the wide date. So clearly he would have seen this variety yet he emphatically rejects that any sixpence of any date was overdated. As he looked at 1000X'34 sixpences if there is a 4th die (and 2nd showing the fault) it would be scarce (mintage of maybe 1000 or so with ?? remaining for us to find).
(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/BQBYWyn.jpg)" />
(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/cZLk3B5.jpg)" />
Two more examples.
Just the tip of the overdate visible to the top left of the 4.
No big overdate yet...
Interesting,first Pic. is a good eg. and they both have the line between the E-A.
Nice pictures.
Folks, I am not and expert when it comes to varsities. Would you say this coin is a wide date ?
Quote from: 'ausproofs' pid='126063' dateline='1645269615'Folks, I am not and expert when it comes to varsities. Would you say this coin is a wide date ?
Yes.
Quote from: 'echidna' pid='126065' dateline='1645274769'Quote from: 'ausproofs' pid='126063' dateline='1645269615'Folks, I am not and expert when it comes to varsities. Would you say this coin is a wide date ?
Yes.
Thanks Echi.
(//%3Ca%20href=)(https://i.imgur.com/8Wp0Ckr.jpg)" />
I tried to verify that number 46581760 but get an error message???
What is the message Neal ?
Today it worked (from my computer). Last night on my phone there was in red text Error, contact PCGS.
Certainly a nice coin. Whose is it and why didn't they get rid of that green spot on the P and another at the base of the king before encapsulating it?