Australian-Coins Forum

Numismatic Discussion => Coin and Banknote Grading => Topic started by: stevo1962 on January 21, 2013, 10:07:21 AM

Title: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: stevo1962 on January 21, 2013, 10:07:21 AM
Looks to me like this 2000 $1 mule is way overgraded and shoud only be at AU50 - anyone agree?

    http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/2000-ONE-DOLLAR-TEN-CENT-MULE-ERROR-PSGS-AU58-A-SUPERB-COIN-/111002418509?
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: Fr45h3R on January 21, 2013, 10:52:41 AM
Quote from: 'stevo1962' pid='6861' dateline='1358725041'Looks to me like this 2000 $1 mule is way overgraded and shoud only be at AU50 - anyone agree?

    http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/2000-ONE-DOLLAR-TEN-CENT-MULE-ERROR-PSGS-AU58-A-SUPERB-COIN-/111002418509?

Looks ok to me. Photos don't show lustre but wear is minimal. Lustre is mentioned in the description.
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: stevo1962 on January 21, 2013, 10:58:02 AM
QuoteLooks ok to me

 Maybe I'm being too tough because it looks like the Queen's curls have a bit of wear but if the grade is correct I'll give all of mine an upgrade
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: emu666 on January 21, 2013, 02:26:27 PM
Quote from: 'stevo1962' pid='6864' dateline='1358728082'
QuoteLooks ok to me

 Maybe I'm being too tough because it looks like the Queen's curls have a bit of wear but if the grade is correct I'll give all of mine an upgrade

Yes you are being way too tough. There is just a trace of wear on the queen's curls. AU58 is perfectly correct for that coin.
Maybe you have undergraded your coins.

Do you have pictures of yours. Photographs are better as it is very hard to grade from a scan. Actually it is always much easier to grade from a coin that is in the hand.
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: markn on January 21, 2013, 02:50:01 PM
Only thing you can say for certain is the images are rotten and impossible to grade from.  Remember two individuals at PCGS graded that coin individually using bright light and a loupe and both arrived at AU58.  Right now I'd say they are much more likely to have graded that coin accurately than anyone trying to grade from the sellers images.
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: stevo1962 on January 21, 2013, 03:07:40 PM
QuoteDo you have pictures of yours

This is my best 2000 mule but I have a few others that are very close,
I've tagged this one as AU58

    [attachment=1056]

    [attachment=1055]
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: accumulator on January 21, 2013, 03:34:46 PM
Well looking at how many knocks/bag marks the slabbed coin has,stevo's coin would be around the MS 61/2, yeah ?

There is no wear on that coin Stevo,only bagging,heaps of lustre,very nice coin.
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: keldaw on January 21, 2013, 03:38:35 PM
i dont know about the hair but i have 2 or 3 with a better circle then both the ones here , so i will get them out and ask you all to grade mine too please ..   ,, kel ,,
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: stevo1962 on January 21, 2013, 03:39:08 PM
QuoteMS 61/2/3, yeah ?

That would be great if it is UNC  and no doubt slabbing this
coin would be the way to go I reckon
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: emu666 on January 21, 2013, 03:41:31 PM
Quote from: 'stevo1962' pid='6874' dateline='1358743060'
QuoteDo you have pictures of yours

This is my best 2000 mule but I have a few others that are very close,
I've tagged this one as AU58

   

   

Nice piccy.
That is a very nice coin Steve. I certainly cannot see any metal missing due to wear. MS62 for sure, perhaps MS63.
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: stevo1962 on January 21, 2013, 03:59:25 PM
QuoteNice piccy.
That is a very nice coin Steve. I certainly cannot see any metal missing due to wear. MS62 for sure, perhaps MS63.

Thanks Emu ,I would very much appreciate your opinion on this one which I also graded as AU58 and was graded as EF by the person I bought it from

[attachment=1058]

[attachment=1057]
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: emu666 on January 21, 2013, 04:06:28 PM
Quote from: 'stevo1962' pid='6882' dateline='1358746165'
QuoteNice piccy.
That is a very nice coin Steve. I certainly cannot see any metal missing due to wear. MS62 for sure, perhaps MS63.

Thanks Emu ,I would very much appreciate your opinion on this one which I also graded as AU58 and was graded as EF by the person I bought it from





Unfortunately this one would not be graded by any of the third party grading services due to the scrape around the base of the obverse letters (caused by the coin rolling machine).
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: stevo1962 on January 21, 2013, 04:18:06 PM
QuoteUnfortunately this one would not be graded by any of the third party grading services

Ok thanks for the info,I was a bit disappointed when I received this one but I think it's still a nice coin and one more for the collection
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: keldaw on January 21, 2013, 05:59:08 PM
[attachment=1064][attachment=1065][attachment=1066][attachment=1067]
 do you think these $ 1.00  x 2000 mules are worth grading and i believe they have a better double rim then the 2 pictured before on the link and the other one pictured by stevo1962 ..
would they go a grade or are they just normal  mules .?   ,, kel ,,
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: accumulator on January 21, 2013, 06:25:25 PM
Both very nice coins Kel,well worth slabbing,especially the 2nd one.
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: drakesterling on January 21, 2013, 06:48:54 PM
yes, get it graded stevo. i can assist, if youre interested.
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: Fordprefect on January 21, 2013, 07:06:23 PM
Quote from: 'keldaw' pid='6892' dateline='1358753348'do you think these $ 1.00  x 2000 mules are worth grading and i believe they have a better double rim then the 2 pictured before on the link and the other one pictured by stevo1962 ..
would they go a grade or are they just normal  mules .?   ,, kel ,,
Hell YES Kel, think of it as insuring there future value

Neither coin is going to make MS or an AU grade.
Coin 2 looks to be an XF candidate.
Coin 1 well centred strike but high VF.
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: stevo1962 on January 21, 2013, 07:34:59 PM
Quoteyes, get it graded stevo. i can assist, if youre interested.

So what are your rates as I have quite a few slabworthy coins
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: keldaw on January 21, 2013, 08:33:03 PM
[attachment=1068][attachment=1070][attachment=1069][attachment=1071]these are  other 2 i have   . plus 1 i dont have a pic of yet ..
 for this  4 mules , i have been offered  $ 2300.00 plus

  but just now not for sale ..


 ,, kel ,,
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: enworb on January 22, 2013, 10:10:07 AM
The seller of this one 330856704831 must have been happy with the end price!
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: stevo1962 on January 22, 2013, 10:31:59 AM
QuoteThe seller of this one 330856704831 must have been happy with the end price!

I watched that one with interest ,its all down the great photography,I've seen and bought better coins than this for 1/3 of the price because of the crap photos/scans.Good to see that prices are creeping up.I should try to get my hands on a few more uncirculated examples
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: stevo1962 on January 22, 2013, 02:13:19 PM
Anyone care to offer a grade on this one

[attachment=1072]

[attachment=1073]
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: keldaw on January 22, 2013, 02:52:46 PM
matt , that 4831 you mentioned does not even have a full circle by the looks of the pic ...i would not have though it was worth that much money .. ,, kel ,,
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: stevo1962 on January 22, 2013, 02:57:37 PM
Quotethat 4831 you mentioned does not even have a full circle

Kel its not whether its fully centred or not that gets the price up its the grade.Anything EF or better seems to be what serous collectors would be keen to get their hands on
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: enworb on January 22, 2013, 03:03:01 PM
i still dont think that one in the listing was worth $1300. I thought it might go for about $700.
Yours is quite nice steve. I reckon AU58.
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: stevo1962 on January 22, 2013, 03:10:34 PM
Quotei still dont think that one in the listing was worth $1300

I didnt think it was worth that much either Matt but maybe this is the trend with this coin now (I hope) and they were good photos too so everyone had a fair idea what they were bidding on
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: Nevol on January 22, 2013, 05:00:43 PM
QuoteAnyone care to offer a grade on this one
I don't try to guess grades, but I will say it's plenty plurry nice!!! :yahoo: I wish I had one like it. :winkextra:
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: keldaw on January 22, 2013, 05:03:13 PM
Quote from: 'stevo1962' pid='6944' dateline='1358828857'
Quotethat 4831 you mentioned does not even have a full circle

Kel its not whether its fully centred or not that gets the price up its the grade.Anything EF or better seems to be what serous collectors would be keen to get their hands on
[/quote

 thanks steve , i did not know that was the case , i thought the better centred  the better price , no problems , i still like mine ,..even if they are not top grade , i am very lucky to have 5 of them .. it all good ..
   ,, kel ,,
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: robbiegal on January 22, 2013, 10:19:37 PM
Good grief

I thought these 'mules' were rare!!!

If i bought one today i'd only pay less than half what I would have of before joining this forum!!

they are like the 1930 penny - hidden treasures
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: stevo1962 on January 22, 2013, 10:42:32 PM
QuoteIf i bought one today i'd only pay less than half what I would have of before joining this forum!!

  Good thinking RG,I go by the motto   Pay 1/2 as much for a coin
that is twice as good
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: enworb on January 23, 2013, 11:39:26 AM
There is almost a constant supply of them on ebay. At any time you could buy one. Whilst im sure 1930 pennies are also for sale in some shops they arent in the same supply as the mules. There must be quite a few thousand of these mules compared to only 1000 half decent 1930 pennies
Title: RE: PCGS overgraded dollar mule
Post by: keldaw on January 23, 2013, 04:49:28 PM
if you buy them , ok must sell big , but if you find them , thats even better , but looking at the average mule for the average man on the street , that sell on ebay most of the time , for around between         $ 500.00 to  $ 7 00.00 that is a very good profit , and any seller should be happy with that profit , after all it only cost him a $ 1.00.

 as for the ones selling on ebay , they are not all extras mules , the 2 i have sold to a certain lady , 2 years ago are now selling again on ebay , 1 sold 3 weeks ago and the other one is on there now selling at a reasonable profit to what i got for it ..   ,, kel ,,