Australian-Coins Forum

Numismatic Discussion => Coin and Banknote Grading => Topic started by: Fr45h3R on January 19, 2013, 05:09:02 PM

Title: 1954 Halfpenny
Post by: Fr45h3R on January 19, 2013, 05:09:02 PM
Hi All,
What do you think this one grades at ?

(http://i1277.photobucket.com/albums/y484/Fr45h3R/Half%20Pennies/1954rev_zps806caaef.jpg)
(http://i1277.photobucket.com/albums/y484/Fr45h3R/Half%20Pennies/1954obv_zpsb8c26b58.jpg)

-rob
Title: RE: 1954 Halfpenny
Post by: markn on January 19, 2013, 05:17:13 PM
UNC.  MS63RB?
Title: RE: 1954 Halfpenny
Post by: Mister T on January 19, 2013, 05:23:56 PM
I would agree on UNC but weakly struck.
Title: RE: 1954 Halfpenny
Post by: Fr45h3R on January 19, 2013, 06:07:53 PM
Thanks guys.
It has quite nice surfaces, let down a little bit by the bag marks on the roo.
Title: RE: 1954 Halfpenny
Post by: robbiegal on January 20, 2013, 10:14:13 AM
hello - late but finally back on line after computer problems
huge pics there

i looked at some pics that i have of a MS63 halfpenny of mine  (MS = "mint State' - 'as struck' at the Mint)
and i'd suspect that coin of yours would have been a 64 but there is either bag marking damage or something across the ELIZA lettering - & high point marks on the ribbon and hair - they would have to notice that and knock it down a notch or 2
those marks on skippy look almost original planchet roughness to me & shouldn't preclude the reverse being an MS grade at all (me thinks)

no pcgs expert  
in ozzie grades i'd say it's a gorgus unc with recent bagmarking as it bright and coppery

not sure what the pcgs mob would do in this case
i'd guess it would be at entry point from the penalties so i'd go for a 61 (if thay have that)
cheers rob

after reading through some of the chat about grading and the MS system
i'd reckon this coin is pretty well a beautiful unc 'as struck' in it's grade but with the bagmarking probably knocks the commercial value down to a/unc?
the grade remains the same unc+ bagmarks but the sale value can be affected - that is how I understand it?

others may have comments on that?

it all gets a bit argy bargy but when it comes to the rarer coins and putting the $$ value on a coin, then it is all highly relevant for the buyer/collector
Title: RE: 1954 Halfpenny
Post by: Fr45h3R on January 20, 2013, 01:44:42 PM
Hi Rob,
Excellent reply

Quotei'd reckon this coin is pretty well a beautiful unc 'as struck' in it's grade but with the bagmarking probably knocks the commercial value down to a/unc?
the grade remains the same unc+ bagmarks but the sale value can be affected - that is how I understand it?

others may have comments on that?

I think you are spot on.
The severity of these bag marks on most coins seems to range from non existent, to quite heavy.
However bag marks shouldn't alter whether the coin in mint state or not, my understanding is only 'wear' will drop the grade below 'unc'.
But as you say, the value of an UNC coin with bagmarks, could be around the same as an aUNC coin just touched off.
The value may even be less if they impact eye appeal in a negative way.
I just had a look at these photos again, and on my screen, the photo is 300mm wide, vs 25mm wide for the actual coin.
Whilst the photos show a true representation of the coin, they are rather unflattering compared to viewing the coin unmagnified under the same light.

Quoteit all gets a bit argy bargy but when it comes to the rarer coins and putting the $$ value on a coin, then it is all highly relevant for the buyer/collector
Normally we'll see the market decide the value of these coins. A single highest graded coin will go to the highest bidder, and in most cases Renniks, McDonald's and even bluesheet values are irrelevent.
Come down a few grades, and the prices return to normal.
I even saw an example of a 1931 1/2 on eBay a few weeks back. The coin was a technical MS63BN but it strugged with eye appeal, and it sold for 1/3 of what the same coin with decent eye appeal would have sold for.