Australian-Coins Forum

Numismatic Discussion => Coin and Banknote Grading => Topic started by: Triggersmob on January 16, 2013, 10:55:46 PM

Title: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: Triggersmob on January 16, 2013, 10:55:46 PM
[attachment=953][attachment=954]

and another set of pics taken in different light, to try and reduce the glare.

[attachment=955][attachment=956]
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: markn on January 17, 2013, 05:34:14 AM
Looks like a nice one.  I'd say choice UNC at least.  Hard to assign a numerical grade based on your images but the obverse fields look really nice.
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: enworb on January 17, 2013, 11:25:58 AM
At least CH.UNC. Most of the 1959 florins i have seen have very baggy obverses. Yours is one of the nicest i have seen.
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: Triggersmob on January 17, 2013, 08:32:28 PM
Thanks for the kind words, Enworb, and thanks to both of you for the grading.
That's another one I can upgrade.
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: trout on January 17, 2013, 08:52:49 PM
Quote from: 'Triggersmob' pid='6603' dateline='1358416948'Thanks for the kind words, Enworb, and thanks to both of you for the grading.
That's another one I can upgrade.

Nothing wrong with that florin Steve :good:
MS62-63 easy
To upgrade to a MS65 will cost you around $450, and then that coin will make all the other coins in the florin album sulk:angel:
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: Triggersmob on January 17, 2013, 10:48:26 PM
Trout, I meant that I can upgrade the grading I had listed against this coin.
I had it as UNC, but now I can call it CH UNC. I certainly don't have $450 to
upgrade. In fact I would rather down grade and free up capital to buy more coins.
Just as a point, you say $450 for next grade, but my 2009 Maccas only list them
as $100 for Gem, has there been big increases in values over the last few years?
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: trout on January 17, 2013, 10:52:54 PM
Quote from: 'Triggersmob' pid='6634' dateline='1358425106'Trout, I meant that I can upgrade the grading I had listed against this coin.
I had it as UNC, but now I can call it CH UNC. I certainly don't have $450 to
upgrade. In fact I would rather down grade and free up capital to buy more coins.
Just as a point, you say $450 for next grade, but my 2009 Maccas only list them
as $100 for Gem, has there been big increases in values over the last few years?

Check out "Blue Sheet" it lists a MS65 at $450.
I have subscribed to it and I recon it is prety up to date  and the data comes from recent auctions:good:
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: robbiegal on January 17, 2013, 10:54:22 PM
That is a very beautiful florin
Zippo bag marking which is so rare as they were moved  in bags of hundreds
I think it is a choice easy
Ps tho i know very little about the silvers!
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: Triggersmob on January 17, 2013, 10:59:37 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='6635' dateline='1358425374'
Quote from: 'Triggersmob' pid='6634' dateline='1358425106'Trout, I meant that I can upgrade the grading I had listed against this coin.
I had it as UNC, but now I can call it CH UNC. I certainly don't have $450 to
upgrade. In fact I would rather down grade and free up capital to buy more coins.
Just as a point, you say $450 for next grade, but my 2009 Maccas only list them
as $100 for Gem, has there been big increases in values over the last few years?

Check out "Blue Sheet" it lists a MS65 at $450.
I have subscribed to it and I recon it is prety up to date  and the data comes from recent auctions:good:

I'm not familiar with the "Blue Sheet". Can you tell me what value I should put on my coin then, please.
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: trout on January 17, 2013, 11:03:13 PM
1959 florin at MS63 valued at $65 :good:
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: Triggersmob on January 17, 2013, 11:05:20 PM
Thanks Mate.
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: robbiegal on January 17, 2013, 11:06:27 PM
But that is where auctions can change things
A beautiful florin like this might fetch a much higher price if there is competiton for one with such lovely surfaces?
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: Triggersmob on January 17, 2013, 11:39:14 PM
Very true. It's amazing what can happen in an auction war.
When the SAS $1 silver coin came out in 2007, there were
many of them on E-bay. Most were selling for around $150
or so, but I watch the ending of one auction that had a few
people bidding and that coin sold for $500.
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: trout on January 17, 2013, 11:44:15 PM
Quote from: 'Triggersmob' pid='6653' dateline='1358428154'Very true. It's amazing what can happen in an auction war.
When the SAS $1 silver coin came out in 2007, there were
many of them on E-bay. Most were selling for around $150
or so, but I watch the ending of one auction that had a few
people bidding and that coin sold for $500.

I agree, look at the Victoria cross $1 coin issue price of $5, look at them now?
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: Triggersmob on January 17, 2013, 11:50:54 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='6654' dateline='1358428455'
Quote from: 'Triggersmob' pid='6653' dateline='1358428154'Very true. It's amazing what can happen in an auction war.
When the SAS $1 silver coin came out in 2007, there were
many of them on E-bay. Most were selling for around $150
or so, but I watch the ending of one auction that had a few
people bidding and that coin sold for $500.

I agree, look at the Victoria cross $1 coin issue price of $5, look at them now?

I see what you mean.
$285 in my 2009 book.
Title: RE: Please grade my 1959 Florin.
Post by: trout on January 17, 2013, 11:57:35 PM
Quote from: 'Triggersmob' pid='6658' dateline='1358428854'
Quote from: 'trout' pid='6654' dateline='1358428455'
Quote from: 'Triggersmob' pid='6653' dateline='1358428154'Very true. It's amazing what can happen in an auction war.
When the SAS $1 silver coin came out in 2007, there were
many of them on E-bay. Most were selling for around $150
or so, but I watch the ending of one auction that had a few
people bidding and that coin sold for $500.

I agree, look at the Victoria cross $1 coin issue price of $5, look at them now?

I see what you mean.
$285 in my 2009 book.

It is wierd nearly 100.000 issued (PNC and folders) and yet they sell for so much?