Australian-Coins Forum

Numismatic Discussion => Coin Chit Chat => Topic started by: JeffH on September 25, 2016, 04:57:34 AM

Title: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 25, 2016, 04:57:34 AM
Well it looks like someone else has a rolling machine. 2016 $2 FULL SET Olympic Coin Rolls. (http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/2016-2-FULL-SET-Olympic-Coin-Rolls-ALL-6-Colours-and-the-Para-Olympic-/152253179235?hash=item2372ff2563:g:R6oAAOSwYIxX2~2l)
Not sure why you would buy rolls when they can be obtained in the original bags for the same, or lower, price.
(http://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/R6oAAOSwYIxX2~2l/s-l500.jpg)
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: stevo1962 on September 25, 2016, 08:07:11 AM
When these coins were first released they were selling for high prices compared to
the bags but now its not worth the effort to roll the bagged coins.Maybe the seller
has rolled these from circulated coins
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: kchan1111 on September 25, 2016, 08:31:44 AM
I don't get why you would buy any roll unless it's from official RAM roll??? :scratch_one-s_head::scratch_one-s_head:

If kchan1111 rolls some up for you would you pay any premium for it? :angel:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 25, 2016, 08:32:25 AM
QuoteMaybe the seller has rolled these from circulated coins
That's what I first thought (or loose coins anyway). But his pictures show several bags and coins spilling out which strongly implies that bags have been opened and then coins rolled. Doesn't seem to make a lot of sense.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: purplepennyhunter on September 25, 2016, 08:59:38 AM
I saw an eBay listing that said in the listing that the coins had come from bags and they'd put them in a roll.

edit: Found it see here. dodgy roll listing (http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/2016-2-FULL-SET-Olympic-Coin-Rolls-ALL-6-Colours-and-the-Para-Olympic-/152232948919?_trkparms=aid%3D222007%26algo%3DSIC.MBE%26ao%3D1%26asc%3D20140106155344%26meid%3Df20b30f099c84713a9e55892feee30cc%26pid%3D100005%26rk%3D2%26rkt%3D6%26mehot%3Dlo%26sd%3D272379414729&_trksid=p2047675.l2557&nma=true&si=QHI0dyMNLMi6vlIKzT200yacrJU%253D&orig_cvip=true&rt=nc) What do you make of that?
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 25, 2016, 09:19:39 AM
A different listing from the same seller. Different wrappers but photos showing the rolls are the same ones.
Wording identical including "The Olympic Coins from Woolworth's were only issued in sealed bags from the Mint." but doesn't actually say (s)he took these coins from bags.
Also has bags and single rolls listed.
QuoteWhat do you make of that?
I don't really know what to make of it. Still doesn't make sense to me. Seems a lot of mucking around for no extra return.

Whoever it is was quick off the mark -first listings of Olympic coins 20th July.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Unicorn on September 25, 2016, 09:40:41 AM
The only reason I can think of as to why they rolled them was that they'd opened the bags, removed all the higher grade ones, then rolled the remainder into rolls.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: robbiegal on September 25, 2016, 09:45:12 AM
cough cough

$799 for a set

oh gee why would this seller roll those coins from bags?
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 25, 2016, 09:51:25 AM
That makes sense Uni.
And why the cough RG -you haven't relapsed have you?
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Nevol on September 25, 2016, 12:10:29 PM
The rolls are in 'Prosegur' paper, so I'd say there's a fair chance they rolled them.  Maybe just another security company trying to get in on the act. :dontknow:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 25, 2016, 12:26:08 PM
Don't think so Nancy. He has also sold similar rolls in Armaguard wrapping too.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 25, 2016, 12:42:22 PM
Guys, its clearly one of the 'educational' fake listings. Ebay demands that auctions be for actual items, so put something up to make the point and slap an insane price on it nobody would pay. Some of you have done this yourselves in the past.

"Nothing to see here... move along" :P
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 25, 2016, 01:32:35 PM
There is Plenty to see here Fulvio.
If the coins are NOT in a RAM roll then they are highly suspect to say the least.
Even being in a RAM roll there is not a 100% certainty that they were rolled by RAM.
Regardless of Who is offering these rolls in NON RAM wrappers they are trying to infer that all the coins are "Kosher" and are playing on the fact that RAM rolls ARE becoming a collectable and are cashing in on that market.
ALL of the Olympic coins in rolls are illegitimate and are "Home Brand" offerings because RAM didn't roll any.
If you want one of these rolls just get a bag of the Olympic coins and a roll of $2 from the supermarket or Bank and empty the roll and put the contents of the Olympic bag or even 25 loose coins into the empty roll and you have exactly the same thing :dodgy:
The idea behind collectors buying RAM rolls is to try and get the best condition coins available that have come directly from the mint.
There is Absolutely NO guarantee of that with these "Home Brand" rolls.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 25, 2016, 01:33:35 PM
I don't quite understand. Why then does he have good feedback from a large number of apparently happy purchasers of Olympic coins in the last month, or so?
And I can't actually see any sort of educational "message" in his (or her) listings.
Prices don't seem insanely high -plenty of optimistic sellers are asking more for similar coins (but not rolled).
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: stevo1962 on September 25, 2016, 01:49:25 PM
This seller has manufactured their rolls and would have good feedback because
most buyers would not be opening the rolls straight away.Even if they did they'd
be none the wiser that they are fake rolls unless you'd done your homework
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 25, 2016, 01:57:32 PM
Quote from: 'stevo1962' pid='98740' dateline='1474777165'This seller has manufactured their rolls and would have good feedback because
most buyers would not be opening the rolls straight away.Even if they did they'd
be none the wiser that they are fake rolls unless you'd done your homework

This is just another instance of unethical sellers taking advantage of the uneducated collectors out there.
Quite simple really:dodgy:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: robbiegal on September 25, 2016, 02:28:49 PM
sold for $650
$700  - 3 sets sold

errmm nothing educational to see here folks !!


2016 $2 FULL SET Olympic Coin Rolls. ALL 5 Colours and the Para- Olympic.

The Olympic Coins from Woolworth's were only issued in sealed bags from the Mint.  

These coins were placed carefully into the Security Wrapper with minimal handling using gloves.
I will guarantee you will receive 25 Uncirculated Olympic coins in every roll.

Buy from a Honest seller, all my items have had positive feedback.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 25, 2016, 04:00:54 PM
Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='98742' dateline='1474779529'The Olympic Coins from Woolworth's were only issued in sealed bags from the Mint.  

These coins were placed carefully into the Security Wrapper with minimal handling using gloves.

Are you guys blind, or was it too many shandies last night?

He TELLS you that he rolled them himself! Very clearly.

This is not the same as pretending they're real.

If I emptied one of my Coronation rolls and refilled it with dodgy coins, that would be deceptive.

If I offer one of the CoF state coin rolls that I made myself, that isn't dodgy, because I TELL you I got them out of a sack.

FFS. You're all as bad as the government, trying to find terrorists under every bed. :P
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 25, 2016, 04:06:52 PM
QuoteHe TELLS you that he rolled them himself! Very clearly.
Yes, but what we are trying to work out is why did he bother? What is his aim? I also wonder where he obtained the wrappers (two different security firms) -are they new or recycled? I could just ask him, I suppose, but don't expect I would get a sensible answer, if any.
Are you blind too? Check the title of this thread.

Uni's supposition that he opens bags, keeps the best ones, and rolls the crap (majority of them) and sells them seems the best bet so far. And the end coins only have to have one good face to make the roll look good!
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: interest on September 25, 2016, 04:41:20 PM
If these rolls find their way into Macca's in a few years.
What then happens? they could become leggit & very rare rolls of coins.
Who can predict? Stranger things have happened.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 25, 2016, 04:47:16 PM
Incidentally, Woolworths Mudgee still is giving out these coins. A bag and some loose coins today.
So, unless you know a particular store has run out, would pay to ask if buying anything at Woolworths.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 25, 2016, 04:48:46 PM
Quote from: 'JeffH' pid='98746' dateline='1474785412'Uni's supposition that he opens bags, keeps the best ones

Possibly. But then why tell anyone?

Its like when I reroll noodled coins back into Armaguard bags. At first glance they LOOK like they came from Armaguard, but since I cut them short to keep the roll tight, plus the cutoff is a standard heat-sealed seam and not waffled, its pretty obvious they're not real.

I don't hide the fact I do it, and its entirely about convenience, since banks will take them without checking, which saves time and effort.

But...

If I was going to do it to be deceptive, I could bag them so it wouldn't be visible that they'd been opened. I could then, for example, noodle a sack of say 2014 ANZACs, take out all the mules, and flog off the rest at a premium to hopeful noodlers. That would be dishonest of course, but that's another matter.

Telling you I did it defeats any deceptive intent. And given that the first of these roll auctions I saw had a lengthy explanation of why it was being done (no idea if it was the same bloke), I still maintain the intent is unlikely to be fraudulent.

Of course you can't counter stupidity. If someone is dumb enough to buy them anyway, well, caveat emptor.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: robbiegal on September 25, 2016, 05:08:45 PM
Quote from: 'JeffH' pid='98748' dateline='1474787836'Incidentally, Woolworths Mudgee still is giving out these coins. A bag and some loose coins today.
So, unless you know a particular store has run out, would pay to ask if buying anything at Woolworths.

i have been asking at our local stores
happy to buy any spares that you acquire  
even though i do believe that i declared that i was done with them!! ha ha
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Unicorn on September 25, 2016, 05:14:11 PM
:laugh2: ..... I reckon that I should take to this one with the scissors ..... and cut straight through the BS ......

(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/11067/bs.jpg)

Some music to cut by ...... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4H5I6y1Qvz0 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4H5I6y1Qvz0)
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 25, 2016, 05:21:37 PM
QuoteIf someone is dumb enough to buy them anyway, well, caveat emptor.
Well he sold a roll and a bag today (but didn't have any bids on some others). He is averaging over $2 per coin when latest sales of bags have been around $90 and most are not attracting bids at that price. So perhaps he knows what he is doing. I agree with Fulvio that his listings are not factually misleading (but they do seem to bedesigned to confuse tyros).

I thought some other sales of these coins today were much better value in comparison. e.g. a bag of blue plus five each of all colours (50 coins) went for $138.50 (average of $2.77 per coin).

Quotei do believe that i declared that i was done with them!! ha ha
That sentiment has been expressed here many times and mostly proves to be later ignored.

By the way RG, now the feeding frenzy on these coins has eased off, prices dropping -can you tell me when it is going to bottom out and what price will be then? Your crystal ball is operational again I hope?
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: robbiegal on September 25, 2016, 05:51:26 PM
crystal ball ??

i do have have a small one
it is supposed to be good for my psychic energy and i put it out on BBQ table when the full moon is out and about, gets a recharge & fully energized

it looks nice but it has not proven itself in the coin futures department ... sorry :(
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 25, 2016, 05:58:21 PM
Quoteit looks nice but it has not proven itself in the coin futures department
What a pity. You could have made a killing if it works.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 25, 2016, 06:12:22 PM
It doesn't take a crystal bay (regardless of its size) to see that these "Home Grown" rolls have the potential to devalue ALL of the rolls that collectors have in their collections already :ok:
Even Blind Freddy can see that once people realise that these rolls are NOT the "Real Deal" they will start to question the validity of other rolls on the market irrespective of if they are the genuine article or not.

The ONLY reason that people are doing the "Home Roll" thing with this Olympic release is to make more of a profit by making them look like a genuine unsearched roll.
This practice is nothing new and has been the topic of many a discussion and up to date it has been a practice that has been frowned upon with good reason, But now it seems that some people think that this "Home Rolling" is perfectly acceptable behaviour .

Please "Enlighten" Me as to why all of a sudden this is perfectly acceptable behaviour now :ok:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 25, 2016, 06:24:03 PM
Well I don't think it is "perfectly acceptable behaviour". Stating that a seller's description contains no factual errors is not condoning his procedure.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 25, 2016, 06:49:56 PM
QuoteStating that a seller's description contains no factual errors is not condoning his procedure

:agreed:
However admitting to doing something "Shady" most certainly doesn't Legitimise something by admission.
These "home Brand" rolls are most definitely in the "Shady" area I would think, Regardless of who rolled them or how they were rolled :ok:
If these coins were to be offered for sale in capsules, 2x2's or even in coin tubes then I cannot see ANY problem with that whatsoever But to re roll them or to even go to the extent of creating your own design for the paper then this could be seen as "Misleading" to say the very least :ok:

Quote from: 'Nevol' pid='98733' dateline='1474771229'The rolls are in 'Prosegur' paper, so I'd say there's a fair chance they rolled them.  Maybe just another security company trying to get in on the act. :dontknow:

That sort of thinking is what these the sellers of type of listings are counting on.
If there was indeed NO attempt at deception here then the coins would be rolled in plain brown paper or something else and not it some security companies wrappers.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 25, 2016, 08:39:16 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98763' dateline='1474795196'If there was indeed NO attempt at deception here then the coins would be rolled in plain brown paper or something else and not it some security companies wrappers.

You've never made your own rolls, I take it?

Its a fairly major PITA. MUCH easier to use an empty tube. Or are you under the misapprehension everyone has a rolling machine under the bed?
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 25, 2016, 08:51:13 PM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='98769' dateline='1474801756'
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98763' dateline='1474795196'If there was indeed NO attempt at deception here then the coins would be rolled in plain brown paper or something else and not it some security companies wrappers.

You've never made your own rolls, I take it?

Its a fairly major PITA. MUCH easier to use an empty tube. Or are you under the misapprehension everyone has a rolling machine under the bed?

No, I have never made my own rolls and nor do I intend to.
They may be a pain in the bum to roll from scratch and other than for the ease of depositing coins back at the Bank I can see NO other valid reason to re roll them at all.

The methods used to produce these "home Brand" rolls is irrelevant, What we are discussing here is the ethicality of the production of these rolls purely for the secondary market.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 25, 2016, 09:16:26 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98770' dateline='1474802473'NO other valid reason to re roll them at all.

Storage. That's why I did mine. I went from 18 sacks of loose coins to $4 and $10 rolls with descriptions printed on them.

But, a huge pain to do, because we only have two hands. :P

If I was doing it over, and if I had the empty tubes, I would definitely reroll them that way.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 25, 2016, 09:25:27 PM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='98772' dateline='1474803986'
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98770' dateline='1474802473'NO other valid reason to re roll them at all.

Storage. That's why I did mine. I went from 18 sacks of loose coins to $4 and $10 rolls with descriptions printed on them.

But, a huge pain to do, because we only have two hands. :P

If I was doing it over, and if I had the empty tubes, I would definitely reroll them that way.

What you are doing is for a totally different reason to what the sellers of these rolls are doing it for on eBay.
You are doing it because it is the way that you prefer to store your coins, The eBay sellers are doing it to artificially enhance the value of their coins. :ok:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 25, 2016, 10:23:12 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98776' dateline='1474804527'The eBay sellers are doing it to artificially enhance the value of their coins. :ok:

Which is what I remain unconvinced about.

I mean, sure, the black rolls were a commercial attempt at exactly that. And anyone stuffing rolls with crap would be a crook and all that. But someone who tells you exactly what it is, well, is he really responsible for your naivety?

I put it in the same category as tins of bulldust, fresh air or roo poo.

Caveat Emptor.

The funny thing is, as the original anti-packaging zealot, I would expect you of all people to be all about the coin, and not the paper its in. :angel:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: ausproofs on September 25, 2016, 10:51:09 PM
Guys, I think there is lot of discussion here around someone's business venture. I don't approve what they have done if they source the coins in a deceptive way and rolling them and selling them on ebay. However if they have ethically sourcing the coins and selling them with a full disclosure, then thats business. Mr Cotton is a very smart business man... he has the connections and the know how, so he is making money. Some of us who bought the coin packs were selling them for a profit(higher than the purchase price) soon after it was bought.. So whats the difference ? Sorry, but thats what I call business.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 25, 2016, 10:55:13 PM
QuoteThe funny thing is, as the original anti-packaging zealot, I would expect you of all people to be all about the coin, and not the paper its in

It IS all about the coin.
Re packaged and pre searched rolls is something that I am definitely NOT interested in.
If I am searching for that pristine coin the odds of finding one in these types of rolls is extremely slim compared to a genuine Mint roll.
So the "packaging" IS important to me because the odds of finding that special coin are far better if someone hasn't already looked the contents over in a roll and they haven't been handled excessively and this can be pretty much guaranteed in a genuine untouched mint roll :ok:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 25, 2016, 10:57:55 PM
Quote from: 'ausproofs' pid='98781' dateline='1474809669'Sorry, but thats what I call business.

:agreed:

Quote from: 'trout' pid='98782' dateline='1474809913'genuine untouched mint roll :ok:

Which don't exist anymore. Well, except they will again, but at a hefty premium.

For many many years the only rolls we've had have been security rolls. With no guarantees as to contents or condition.

So what's the difference?

You assume that an individual is going to be up to no good. And by inference, that an organisation, be it Armaguard or the RAM, is going to be squeaky clean and above board.

And yet, we know of countless incidents when things were in fact dodgy. Most recently sacks of olympic coins on ebay a week before release. And boxes of carded coins.

Me, I wouldn't trust ANY roll. But then I opened a couple rolls of 20¢ from the 80's only to discover the edges ruined, with the cancer encroaching onto the faces of the coins. The ends looked perfect, and there was no hint of the damage hidden inside.

A roll is just a (not very good) storage and transport solution. Nothing more, and arguably much less. I wouldn't pay any premium for one over the value of the loose coins.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 26, 2016, 05:40:11 AM
I hadn't really thought about the use of security firm wrappers here. On reflection that is definitely a dodgy practice and likely to deceive. In this case the pictures do, as many sellers say, form part of the description.

And the statement "Buy from a Honest seller, all my items have had positive feedback." also sows confusion. It implies that all positive feedback makes him honest but that doesn't necessarily follow. He may well be very honest but that statement proves nothing. And he doesn't have 100% positive feedback -two negatives and one neutral in last six months.

So, not a seller I would recommend.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 26, 2016, 07:02:23 AM
Quote from: 'ausproofs' pid='98781' dateline='1474809669'Guys, I think there is lot of discussion here around someone's business venture. I don't approve what they have done if they source the coins in a deceptive way and rolling them and selling them on ebay. However if they have ethically sourcing the coins and selling them with a full disclosure, then thats business. Mr Cotton is a very smart business man... he has the connections and the know how, so he is making money. Some of us who bought the coin packs were selling them for a profit(higher than the purchase price) soon after it was bought.. So whats the difference ? Sorry, but thats what I call business.

It may be business and it may be legal But ask yourself is it really ethical and would you feel comfortable doing this yourself??
I don't know about anyone else but I still have my coin packs minus a few that I have gifted But re selling these packs is a completely different thing to taking the coins out of the packs to manufacture  rolls that appear to be security rolls or use whatever other official looking wrapper.
One is a case of selling an official Mint product and the other is selling something that appears to be an official product, two very different scenario's.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 26, 2016, 01:58:10 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98793' dateline='1474839143'the other is selling something that appears to be an official product, two very different scenario's.

And where do security rolls fit in then?

They're not official products. The contents aren't guaranteed. Just because there's a shiny desirable coin at each end doesn't mean the rest are the same. And there's no guarantee of condition either. In fact, they COULD be completely dodgy, whether rolled that way deliberately by an employee or repacked by someone afterwards.

Either ALL non-RAM rolls are sus, or they're all fair game and its up to the buyer to be aware and alert. You can't pick and choose.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 26, 2016, 02:05:32 PM
QuoteAnd where do security rolls fit in then?

I know exactly where you could "Fit" the security rolls :diablo::angel:

Selling dodgy rolls in whatever wrapper you like to choose is NOT the same as selling a genuine carded Mint product, Quite simple really :ok:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 26, 2016, 02:11:33 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98814' dateline='1474864532'Selling dodgy rolls in whatever wrapper

You totally missed my point, fishboy. :P

If I flog off my slabs of green Prosegur Coronation rolls, what guarantee is there that they contain UNC Coronations? Or that I haven't noodled them and removed the MS68's? :dodgy:

I'm saying that all rolls are equally suspect. Bags too if it comes to that, since they can be repacked also.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 26, 2016, 02:44:38 PM
QuoteYou totally missed my point, fishboy

On the contrary You are missing the point of what I am trying to say :ok:
The people that are selling the Olympic $2 coins in rolls and I am referring to any coloured, marked or barcoded , Whatever roll that you would prefer or takes your fancy have been created by the sellers and none else as these coins were NOT rolled at all for dispatch/delivery, They came either carded or in $50 bags OK.

These are the rolls I am talking about here :ok:
Now that we have got that bit clear, What  I have been trying to say is that selling these Olympic rolls (please read above) is NOT the same as selling a carded genuine Mint product :):yahoo:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 26, 2016, 04:18:42 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98820' dateline='1474866878'NOT the same as selling a carded genuine Mint product

Nobody said it was.

The way I see it is this:

If I swap a $50 note for 25 $2 coins, I'm not actually 'buying' anything. And I don't care if they're loose, bagged, rolled or even roadkill. Its $50. End of story.

But the moment there's any kind of premium attached, that's when things get complicated, and all sorts of pests crawl out of the woodwork. Because now we're not talking about money anymore, but a 'product'.

And here my opinion probably varies from yours. I regard ALL this stuff, including RAM rolls and olympic packs, as dodgy. Because whether its the RAM, Joe Bloggs or the Trout Mint, the objective remains the same: To extract extra profit by passing something off as something different, purely by the way its wrapped. Even slabs fall into this category, but that's a different discussion.

Its a bit like buying a bulk bag of Mars bars, where each one is in a wrapper marked 'Not for Retail Sale'. Who cares? I want a Mars bar, and I shouldn't be charged two wildly different prices for the exact same thing based solely on what's printed on the wrapper. As long as they both came off the same production line, they're interchangeable, I reckon.

Now, IF the coins are different, say with Specimens or even the high-grade coins that used to go into RAM rolls back in the day, then no problem. But putting the exact same stuffed coins that are in bags into a card and charging 50% more? That's as crooked as a dog's hind leg IMO. And so is the plan to charge a hefty premium for 'genuine' rolls, BTW.

'Genuine' in this case carries no weight whatsoever. :P
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 26, 2016, 04:27:26 PM
And before someone pipes up about the RAM selling some coins lately at face value; therefore no profit. Not true. There is profit and it is called seigniorage (http://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/seigniorage.asp). If those coins don't hit circulation then the seigniorage is all profit.

A few months ago a lady at Denver Mint told me they love Statehood and America the Beautiful quarters -cost about 8¢ to make and a very high proportion immediately disappear from circulation. 17¢ profit and they have to make more to keep numbers up for commerce. Extra profit and job security too!
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 26, 2016, 04:33:38 PM
QuoteBut putting the exact same stuffed coins that are in bags into a card and charging 50% more? That's as crooked as a dog's hind leg IMO. And so is the plan to charge a hefty premium for 'genuine' rolls, BTW.

I have to agree with that.
the Olympic coins are all pretty much crap, I don't know about the parra coins because RAM haven't sent mine yet :dash1: But all the coloured coins that I got from woollies and the ones on the 5 coin carded set are pretty bagged up and NO attempt has been made to look after the coins post minting.
That being said RAM only charged $5 extra over face for the card, artwork and all, The roll sellers are charging over $100 premium over face for the paper roll  :angel:
.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: ausproofs on September 26, 2016, 05:31:49 PM
What I said was if the seller clearly states the coins were rolled by them, then there is no deception. Dont get me wrong, I wont buy them as it is not my cup of tea. However if someone wants to buy the rolled coins and there is a market for that product, who are we to judge the seller ? Cigarettes are not the healthiest consumer product, but some of us do smoke and there is a market. So companies do manufacture them and sell them... thats business and consumer market.. I am not approving or condoning the practice, just starting the facts..
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 26, 2016, 06:13:19 PM
Cigarettes are pretty cheap really, It's that bloody Tax that is the killer.
If everyone gave up smoking today the GST would have to be raised at least another 5% just to cover the lost revenue on Fag tax .
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: ausproofs on September 26, 2016, 06:21:50 PM
Yes, I know... cost of manufacturing cigarettes are very low ... They make a lot of money selling them as well. Tax goes in to the health system etc to support the smoking related illnesses... Government collect truck load of tax as well...
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 26, 2016, 06:28:37 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98828' dateline='1474879399'If everyone gave up smoking today the GST would have to be raised at least another 5% just to cover the lost revenue on Fag tax .

Would it though? I bet it would save more in unnecessary health costs, productivity losses and so on than it would lose in tax. In 2005, these costs added up to $31.5 Billion. Compared to about $8 Billion in taxes raised.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 26, 2016, 06:30:16 PM
Quote from: 'ausproofs' pid='98830' dateline='1474879910'Yes, I know... cost of manufacturing cigarettes are very low ... They make a lot of money selling them as well. Tax goes in to the health system etc to support the smoking related illnesses... Government collect truck load of tax as well...

So as a smoker I really shouldn't have to pay my Medicare or my HBF payments as the tax on my smokes should be plenty :angel::laugh2:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: ausproofs on September 26, 2016, 06:30:53 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98833' dateline='1474880416'
Quote from: 'ausproofs' pid='98830' dateline='1474879910'Yes, I know... cost of manufacturing cigarettes are very low ... They make a lot of money selling them as well. Tax goes in to the health system etc to support the smoking related illnesses... Government collect truck load of tax as well...

So as a smoker I really shouldn't have to pay my Medicare or my HBF payments as the tax on my smokes should be plenty :angel::laugh2:

You wish mate :yahoo:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 26, 2016, 06:39:11 PM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='98832' dateline='1474880317'
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98828' dateline='1474879399'If everyone gave up smoking today the GST would have to be raised at least another 5% just to cover the lost revenue on Fag tax .

Would it though? I bet it would save more in unnecessary health costs, productivity losses and so on than it would lose in tax. In 2005, these costs added up to $31.5 Billion. Compared to about $8 Billion in taxes raised.

I took this to the misbehavers thread before we get even further off topic :angel:

https://www.australian-coins.net/showthread.php?tid=1808&pid=98835#pid98835

SO
back to these third party rolls.
Some of us think that they are OK, some of us think they are a scam and some of us just don't really care "it's Not my problem".
I for one think they are a scam and have said just about everything I have to say about them.
I will watch the thread with interest but I don't think that I have anything else to add here :ok:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 26, 2016, 07:46:52 PM
I have to add that I have made a list of the eBay sellers involved in these dodgy rolls and will never spend a red cent with any of them.
At the end of the day money talks and BS walks, I intend to vote with my wallet on this episode :ok:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: ausproofs on September 26, 2016, 08:37:04 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98842' dateline='1474885012'I have to add that I have made a list of the eBay sellers involved in these dodgy rolls and will never spend a red cent with any of them.
At the end of the day money talks and BS walks, I intend to vote with my wallet on this episode :ok:

Good call... at times thats the best policy. If your moral compass heading that way, thats what you should do. As a side note I have seen how honest you are with your dealings with others and your sales. At the end of the day we have different options, however I think you are true to your words and that is hard to find these days.:wavemulticolor:

But sorry, I still think it is business :zomby:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 26, 2016, 08:38:11 PM
Quote from: 'ausproofs' pid='98845' dateline='1474888024'But sorry, I still think it is business :zomby:

:dead_horse: :angel:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 26, 2016, 09:25:09 PM
QuoteBut sorry, I still think it is business  

I accept that this is your opinion and you are quite entitled  to say so.
Maybe my old school values of trading with people honestly and with dignity are outdated and this is the way (sadly) that business is conducted and is acceptable these days.
I truly hope that I am wrong in this assumption :ok:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: ausproofs on September 26, 2016, 09:40:28 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98851' dateline='1474890909'
QuoteBut sorry, I still think it is business  

I accept that this is your opinion and you are quite entitled  to say so.
Maybe my old school values of trading with people honestly and with dignity are outdated and this is the way (sadly) that business is conducted and is acceptable these days.
I truly hope that I am wrong in this assumption :ok:

You are missing my point... I think it is probably not the best way to conduct business, however when there is demand, there will be supply. It is simple as that. Lot of people dont like killing animals, but meat industry goes on ... so the story goes...
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 26, 2016, 09:53:42 PM
I am pretty certain that I am not "missing the point" here.
Just because there is a demand is absolutely NO excuse to lower your moral standards or expectations :ok:
If something is obviously wrong then it is wrong, Just because a few quid is involved doesn't make it right :angel:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 26, 2016, 11:35:18 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98854' dateline='1474892622'Just because there is a demand is absolutely NO excuse to lower your moral standards or expectations :ok:

Do you have any bank accounts?

Do you read the financial papers?

EVERY major bank has been embroiled in a series of scandals, from rate fixing to unconscionable conduct to insurance scams. They've been prosecuted and fined, yet the misconduct continues. Heck, CBA, allegedly the most trusted of the lot, has the most blood on its hands, but does anyone boycott them? Don't be silly.

There ARE no moral standards nowadays. There is only profit. Look at your own run-in with the mint's forum the other day for example.

I dislike shifty behaviour immensely. But when I come across it, I vote with my feet. There are plenty of shonky businesses that I no longer support for a variety of reasons. Some I haven't set foot in in 40 years.

And yet, when I announced that Woolies had lost my support because of the olympics coins, I was crucified here. Or have you forgotten?

I'll say it again.. bad behaviour is bad behaviour, regardless of who it is. You can't both support a big business with no morals AND attack a small one for the same thing. All or none.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 27, 2016, 07:21:50 AM
Hmmm
Ok I have slept on this and this is what I can gather out of 7 pages of discussion .

1. What these people that are producing these Phantasy rolls are doing is not illegal but it is considered to be a dodgy practice, I think that everyone here agrees on that.

2.Because some business practices today have become successful by being shady and having loose ethical standards  this practice of home rolling is actually acceptable to some and is treated as a normal business practice.

I don't agree with point #2 but as that seems to be the consensus of opinion here so I must be wrong in my thinking :ok:
But hang on a minuet , If this particular practice is normal and acceptable within the coin community then why haven't the well known and respected dealers offered any of these phantasy rolls up for sale ??
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: markn on September 27, 2016, 08:02:14 AM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98860' dateline='1474926710'Hmmm
Ok I have slept on this and this is what I can gather out of 7 pages of discussion .

1. What these people that are producing these Phantasy rolls are doing is not illegal but it is considered to be a dodgy practice, I think that everyone here agrees on that.

2.Because some business practices today have become successful by being shady and having loose ethical standards  this practice of home rolling is actually acceptable to some and is treated as a normal business practice.

I don't agree with point #2 but as that seems to be the consensus of opinion here so I must be wrong in my thinking :ok:
But hang on a minuet , If this particular practice is normal and acceptable within the coin community then why haven't the well known and respected dealers offered any of these phantasy rolls up for sale ??

Downies and their different manifestations (Macquarie and Sherwood) has been repackaging RAM coins for years and selling them quite successfully and I don't see any of you bringing up their names.  99 Company (and various other companies) did the same thing in the 1960's and 1970's and their PNC's are now quite collectable. There's nothing immoral or illegal with repackaging coins (given that you don't suggest they are an "official" RAM release) and there's certainly no shortage of people who are willing to purchase them.  If Cotton & Co have found a product they can market successfully well good luck to them, if you don't like the product then don't buy it.  I am bemused that it requires any more discussion than that.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 27, 2016, 09:11:08 AM
I think that most of us have been careful NOT to mention  any names here and Just because the practice of repackaging coins has been done in the past doesn't make it any more palatable now or in the future.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: stevo1962 on September 27, 2016, 09:36:52 AM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98860' dateline='1474926710'But hang on a minute , If this particular practice is normal and acceptable within the coin community then why haven't the well known and respected dealers offered any of these fantasy rolls up for sale ??

          One highly respected dealer has

   http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/2016-Roll-of-2-Paralympic-Coins-Limited-to-500-Worldwide-/272379795209?hash=item3f6b19d709:g:OaoAAOSwYIxX3R1W
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 27, 2016, 09:41:07 AM
That one is NOT on My "Go To" dealers list :angel:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 27, 2016, 09:41:36 AM
Mark hit the nail on the head.
Quoteif you don't like the product then don't buy it
If there is a market for this type of product then people are going to service it. If it is legal then we can gripe all we like and that will make no difference.
If there is no market then they will seek to make their money elsewhere.


That only leaves the question of the originally mentioned seller using security firm wrappers for coins he has rolled himself. I guess that is a matter for Prosegur and Armaguard but suspect they would not be that interested in a small operator like this.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: robbiegal on September 27, 2016, 10:01:02 AM
Quote from: 'stevo1962' pid='98864' dateline='1474934812'
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98860' dateline='1474926710'But hang on a minute , If this particular practice is normal and acceptable within the coin community then why haven't the well known and respected dealers offered any of these fantasy rolls up for sale ??

          One highly respected dealer has

   http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/2016-Roll-of-2-Paralympic-Coins-Limited-to-500-Worldwide-/272379795209?hash=item3f6b19d709:g:OaoAAOSwYIxX3R1W

oh i thought that this mob are a part of the cotton and co subsidiaries or something like that ?


Quote from: 'markn' pid='98861' dateline='1474929134'
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98860' dateline='1474926710'Hmmm
Ok I have slept on this and this is what I can gather out of 7 pages of discussion .

1. What these people that are producing these Phantasy rolls are doing is not illegal but it is considered to be a dodgy practice, I think that everyone here agrees on that.

2.Because some business practices today have become successful by being shady and having loose ethical standards  this practice of home rolling is actually acceptable to some and is treated as a normal business practice.

I don't agree with point #2 but as that seems to be the consensus of opinion here so I must be wrong in my thinking :ok:
But hang on a minuet , If this particular practice is normal and acceptable within the coin community then why haven't the well known and respected dealers offered any of these phantasy rolls up for sale ??

Downies and their different manifestations (Macquarie and Sherwood) has been repackaging RAM coins for years and selling them quite successfully and I don't see any of you bringing up their names.  99 Company (and various other companies) did the same thing in the 1960's and 1970's and their PNC's are now quite collectable. There's nothing immoral or illegal with repackaging coins (given that you don't suggest they are an "official" RAM release) and there's certainly no shortage of people who are willing to purchase them.  If Cotton & Co have found a product they can market successfully well good luck to them, if you don't like the product then don't buy it.  I am bemused that it requires any more discussion than that.

Now I am confused
i mentioned downies ages ago with respect to them packaging single coins or small packs - never rolls, i have never seen a downies roll. Downies don't claim special association or packing on behalf of the RAM, mind you.

I thought this discussion was around emptying a RAM roll - chubb, prosegur etc and then REFILLING  the empty paper roll with coins of choice. then selling that chubb, prosegur roll as a look alike government authorised/issued roll. Not quite homemade as it is a refilled authorised paper wrap roll.

sure it's business
and given the acceptability of the buying and selling within the coin business as unethical practice in toto
then best we forget about having any sense of integrity as obviously it does't matter

therefore all the argy bargy about services such as look alike services i.e. APCGS versus PCGS don't matter - and you can pop your APCGS slab into your PCGS registry because integrity and source guarantee - well doesn't flamin well matter does it ???


so now, it's all just a case of buyer beware but more fool you if you complain as all it becomes is - oh just another whinger here
maybe that member is just too old and not progressive enough

i am astounded that the members here who are so PCGS focused in their collecting are also so accepting of more covert coin selling modes
it really blows me away
from one form of absolute snobbery to the other extreme of - well doesn't matter who gets ripped off - as well, because that's the coin business???

shame shame
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 27, 2016, 01:24:50 PM
I think that nobody really cares RG as long as it doesn't impact on them, which is a bit of a shame really.
Pretty much an "I'm all right Jack" attitude  :(
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: markn on September 27, 2016, 02:50:57 PM
Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='98867' dateline='1474936262'I thought this discussion was around emptying a RAM roll - chubb, prosegur etc and then REFILLING  the empty paper roll with coins of choice. then selling that chubb, prosegur roll as a look alike government authorised/issued roll. Not quite homemade as it is a refilled authorised paper wrap roll.

Maybe I missed something,  isn't Cotton & Co wrapping coins in their own paper?  Nothing to do with the RAM or a security company or anything?  Their own packaging?  That's quite different to wrapping coins in RAM paper or security company paper.  Two completely different things.  Repacking coins in your own branded material is acceptable.  Re-rolling in someone else's wrappers isn't.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 27, 2016, 02:54:32 PM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='98880' dateline='1474953657'That's quite different to wrapping coins in RAM paper or security company paper.  Two completely different things.

:agreed:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: robbiegal on September 27, 2016, 03:14:50 PM
Quote from: 'markn' pid='98880' dateline='1474953657'
Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='98867' dateline='1474936262'I thought this discussion was around emptying a RAM roll - chubb, prosegur etc and then REFILLING  the empty paper roll with coins of choice. then selling that chubb, prosegur roll as a look alike government authorised/issued roll. Not quite homemade as it is a refilled authorised paper wrap roll.

Maybe I missed something,  isn't Cotton & Co wrapping coins in their own paper?  Nothing to do with the RAM or a security company or anything?  Their own packaging?  That's quite different to wrapping coins in RAM paper or security company paper.  Two completely different things.  Repacking coins in your own branded material is acceptable.  Re-rolling in someone else's wrappers isn't.

yup
my understanding was that no one was talking about the guys making 'private genuine circulated in cooperation with the RAM rolls' for lots of cash bizzo

this thread is about an ebay seller who sells 'repacked/repurposed' two dollar rolls that are authorized by the Australian government and distributed through the security companies after they roll the loose coins into set sized rolls. the said seller then empties the rolls and is now repacking them with the olympic coins (has been doing it since the coins were released. the seller states that he/she is honest and that the rolls are repacked with uncirculated coins from mint bags.

the Ay's - say sure its a good thing, it's good for business, the seller is an entrepreneur and honestly telling the customer that it is not a ram roll but a rerolled/refilled empty ram roll

the Nays' - say well this is somewhat deceptive and is duping the buyer into thinking that they are buying an overpriced investment roll when in fact the roll doesn't exist. the nays also say well, if this is Ok  then all forgeries should then be OK so then why bother with ascertaining  authenticity or genuine item provenance

and so on
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 27, 2016, 06:05:30 PM
Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='98885' dateline='1474955090'if this is Ok  then all forgeries should then be OK

Ah, but there's the crux of the matter.

They're NOT forgeries. They're quite real, just in a different packet, that's all.

I have 3 or 4 'rolls' of these coins, which I was unable to swap for sealed bags. Its not going to happen now either.  So what to do? They're UNC, taken from sealed bags, but they're not IN sealed bags. I can't get them packed into bags (well, I could, but that would be dodgy), and I don't want to spend a fortune on individual mounts for them.

So why shouldn't I roll them into Armaguard wrappers?
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 27, 2016, 06:44:24 PM
QuoteSo why shouldn't I roll them into Armaguard wrappers?

Stop shit stirring Fulvio :angel:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 27, 2016, 06:51:56 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98893' dateline='1474967664'Stop shit stirring Fulvio :angel:

Why? :angel:

And its a serious question. I have a tub full of Armaguard tubes next to me right now. ;)
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: JeffH on September 27, 2016, 07:03:42 PM
trout, you beat me to it. I was just going to be more discreet and accuse him, of being a provocateur.

QuoteI have a tub full of Armaguard tubes next to me right now.
They do make good garden mulch when shredded.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 27, 2016, 07:24:37 PM
Me too but I didn't know how to spell "provocateur".:angel::laugh2:

QuoteThey do make good garden mulch when shredded.

The tubes or Fulvio?? :diablo::)
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: robbiegal on September 27, 2016, 07:30:27 PM
and on and on it goes

:dash1:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 27, 2016, 07:59:54 PM
Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='98904' dateline='1474970427'and on and on it goes

Where she stops, nobody knows!

Roll up! Roll up! :wavemulticolor:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: tania on September 27, 2016, 08:29:52 PM
All you guys are making me laugh. Just what I needed.
Thanks.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: runway on September 27, 2016, 08:52:54 PM
Go your hardest with this seller rolling in Prosegur paper
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/152249572921?euid=0fbf098f20884928b07e29625352162c&bu=43180920413&cp=1&sojTags=bu=bu
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 28, 2016, 07:45:31 AM
All these Olympic $2 home rolled offerings are Rip Offs, It doesn't matter what paper they are rolled in the chances of finding a high grade coin amongst them is extremely slim.
In fact the chances of finding the better grade coins in the 5 coin packs or the carded parra packs are far better than these rolls or the bags because they would have had far less handling and wouldn't be as "bagged Up" as a result.
The very reason why collectors buy rolls is that usually they contain the better coins, This is definitely NOT the case with the Olympic coins :ok:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 28, 2016, 08:41:41 AM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98932' dateline='1475014531'The very reason why collectors buy rolls is that usually they contain the better coins,

Oh? I thought that was the reason for buying mint sets. Only they turned to rubbish a while back as well, didn't they? :P
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 28, 2016, 08:45:02 AM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='98937' dateline='1475017901'
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98932' dateline='1475014531'The very reason why collectors buy rolls is that usually they contain the better coins,

Oh? I thought that was the reason for buying mint sets. Only they turned to rubbish a while back as well, didn't they? :P

Hmmm
I don't recall the 2000 UN 20c being included in any Mint set :angel:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Basil on September 28, 2016, 08:54:47 AM
I wonder how the colour will stand up on these Coins in cheap paper that was designed for short term storeage.
I can't believe people thinking these Coins will somehow be worth money in the decades ahead,once the novelty wears off a pristine eg. may be worth a $ or 2 over face IMO.
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 28, 2016, 09:03:00 AM
QuoteOh? I thought that was the reason for buying mint sets. Only they turned to rubbish a while back as well, didn't they?

The Mint Sets usually ARE the best source for the better grade coins, This years Changeover sets that I received  unfortunately didn't live up to that expectation :ok:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 28, 2016, 09:33:21 AM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98939' dateline='1475018102'I don't recall the 2000 UN 20c being included in any Mint set :angel:

I don't recall it ever existing in the first place. :P

Check your years, fishboy! :dodgy:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 28, 2016, 09:39:44 AM
Ok 1995, Smartarse :angel:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 28, 2016, 09:51:03 AM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98949' dateline='1475021384'Ok 1995, Smartarse :angel:

Smartest arse in town, and don't ye forget it, podnah! ;)
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: robbiegal on September 28, 2016, 10:16:55 AM
Quote from: 'runway' pid='98913' dateline='1474975374'Go your hardest with this seller rolling in Prosegur paper
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/152249572921?euid=0fbf098f20884928b07e29625352162c&bu=43180920413&cp=1&sojTags=bu=bu

this is what we are talking about  

apparently they are genuine,  according to Fulvio's logic
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 28, 2016, 11:42:37 AM
Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='98957' dateline='1475023615'apparently they are genuine,  according to Fulvio's logic

What's not genuine about them? Were they struck in a Chinese mint???

Look, these coins are going for around $4-5 each. Whether they're loose, bagged or rolled makes no real difference to that.

Sure, there may be doubts as to the contents of rolls, since you can't see the coins. But again, there's nothing inherently 'fake' about them just because of how they're wrapped. :P

Put it another way..

I could sell you a loose coin, and hand it to you loose, in a ziplock bag, in a 2x2, in a Saflip or sealed in a recycled chip packet. It would still be the same coin, at the same price. So who cares?
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: r9453 on September 28, 2016, 11:57:08 AM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='98964' dateline='1475028757'I could sell you a loose coin, and hand it to you loose, in a ziplock bag, in a 2x2, in a Saflip or sealed in a recycled chip packet. It would still be the same coin, at the same price. So who cares?

What flavour chips?
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 28, 2016, 12:06:20 PM
Just what is your agenda here Fulvio??
You seem to be taking a lot of trouble defending and trying to legitimise these re rolled coins, Normally anything even a little bit suspect and you are all over it.
I am not being rude here I am just asking the question that many of us are thinking :ok:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 28, 2016, 12:34:36 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='98968' dateline='1475030180'Just what is your agenda here Fulvio??

To make people use their brains, that's all.

Because there's a lot of bullshit floating about, and it isn't helpful. There are enough genuine issues to contend with without adding crap to the pile that isn't actually relevant.

I have no intention of ever buying any of these things, BTW. Nor do I think anyone else should. Then the market would sort it all out. If there are no buyers, the sellers will move on to something else.

But clearly, there ARE people who will buy. And I can rationalise their approach too, even if I don't agree with it. However you don't seem to look at it that way at all. In your mind, these things are devil spawn created by evil masterminds to subvert the numismatic world or something. Whereas they're nothing of the sort.

Is that agenda enough for you? :P
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on September 28, 2016, 12:55:55 PM
QuoteIs that agenda enough for you?

It will do for now :P
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: autocoupler on September 28, 2016, 02:12:21 PM
Quote from: 'r9453' pid='98966' dateline='1475029628'What flavour chips?

Would salt and vinegar be unhelpful? :angel:
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: Fulvio on September 28, 2016, 04:51:51 PM
Quote from: 'autocoupler' pid='98974' dateline='1475037741'Would salt and vinegar be unhelpful? :angel:

No problem, as long as the bag is thoroughly washed. And maybe acetoned too. ;)
Title: RE: Third party rolled coins
Post by: trout on November 12, 2016, 06:53:45 PM
Here are some more Cotton and co offerings :dash1:
AJ emailed me this screenshot.

(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10019/CaptureFB_1_2800229.jpg)