I know there's a few members/dealers here that deal with PCGS but wondering if there are any NGC dealers:huh:
PM me prices if there are please :beg:
Which coins are you thinking of getting graded Mate ??
probably a few of the wedding coin set to start cobba.
Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='94851' dateline='1471444940'probably a few of the wedding coin set to start cobba.
I would wait and see how they attribute mine first Mate, I should have the results in a Month and will post them on the Wedding set thread :ok:
I wonder if PCGS dealers have an exclusivity clause in their contract which prevents them from dealing with other TPGs? Kind of like how you can't be a Holden and a Ford dealer.
I am thinking that many of the dealers have painted themselves into a corner by "Bagging" NGC over the years and are now stuck with PCGS. :angel:
Yes, bagging NGC and hyping PCGS too much.
Quote from: 'r9453' pid='94860' dateline='1471469368'Yes, bagging NGC and hyping PCGS too much.
A pretty stupid move really as both TPG's are highly rated and respected and in the US both companies are rated as the two top tier graders.
In Australia however there is a perception that NGC is a second grade TPG now because of all of the hype over the last few years.
Both NGC and PCGS have graded over 33,000,000 coins and I think that NGC has actually graded a few more than PCGS at this stage.
It makes me think that this perception that PCGS is way better than NGC is purely an Australian thing.
It has nothing to do with their quality of grading. NGC has graded few Australian coins and they grade aussie coins the same way they grade US coins.. PCGS have graded large amounts of Aus coins .. also PCGS in the past gradedcoins harsher than NGC. Also the way (what they look for in order to attribute a grade) is slightly differentfrom what I can see...
Quote from: 'trout' pid='94856' dateline='1471445939'Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='94851' dateline='1471444940'probably a few of the wedding coin set to start cobba.
I would wait and see how they attribute mine first Mate, I should have the results in a Month and will post them on the Wedding set thread :ok:
Yes it will be interesting so can't wait to see what happens.
Enter "Australia" in the Location box here NGC dealers (https://www.ngccoin.com/services/dealer-listing.aspx) to get;
1. Universal Coin Company (http://www.universalcoinco.com.au/)
2. Tasmanian Numismatics
Shop 11, 113 Main Road, Moonah, 7009, Australia
Phone: 61 416 226 844
Email: info@tasmaniannumismatics.com.au
Thanks Jeff :good: shame the web sites are connected :scratch_one-s_head:
Quote from: 'r9453' pid='94858' dateline='1471463355'I wonder if PCGS dealers have an exclusivity clause in their contract which prevents them from dealing with other TPGs? Kind of like how you can't be a Holden and a Ford dealer.
I know dealers who are authorised dealers of both.
Eric
NGC is as widely respected as PCGS, but at the end of the day, certain markets prefer PCGS to NGC while others prefer NGC to PCGS. Think about what grading service the collector wants when choosing a grading service to send your coins to. In Australia, collectors prefer PCGS. In Asia and South Africa, NGC seems to be the go. In the US, it seems to be about 50/50, although some series sell better in one holder over the other.
Eric
Thanks Eric :good: funny how different places like different companies.
The only problem that I have with the NGC slabs is that you cant put the lid on the PCGS blue box with an NGC slab in it.
Also you cant add them to a PCGS set registry pissing contest either :)
Other than that I am just fine with having NGC grade my coins. :good:
Yes I found I had to turn my one and only ngc slab on it's side so it took up two spots but now I have one of the wooden boxes and they fit ok in them :)
Even if I was (but I'm definitely not) I don't think I need everyone to know I'm on the top of the pops as some sort of status thing.
Being on top spot in the set registry IS good fun But it isn't the be all end all of collecting.
Being top dog in a coin series or set does give you a "Buzz" But it is only a fleeting thing as there is normally a better set out there that hasn't yet been graded or added to the set registry that will knock you out of 1st place :)
At the end of the day it is your collection and if you are happy with it then it doesn't matter if NGC or PCGS has graded the coins or if you are top of the wazza in the set registries . :ok:
I'm happy with both my graded and raw coins and probably get more enjoyment from my raw :)
99% of my graded coins are the ones I sent away myself, There is quite a lot of satisfaction for Me to hunt these Gems down raw :)
A few of my best coins however had already been slabbed and I have No problem buying them in either PCGS or NGC plastic.
whither NGC or PCGS has graded the coin to Me is irrelevant, The coins themselves are the important bit :ok:
Yep, very true mate as it's the coin I'm after not a holder :winkextra:
My raw coins in their saflip cozzies give me the most enjoyment for many reasons, but just being more accessible and easier to store being the two greatest advantages I think. Nothing better than rolling a few pennies and florins down the hallway to frighten the cats :shock: :angel: nah just joking folks :biggrin: I'm not averse to slabs though and actually have two of the little blighters :whistle2: but if I do go down this path I'll be sticking with the varieties only, mainly because for some types there are so few around in high grade and it's not always a requirement to attain MS to be somewhere near the pointy end. I do agree the thrill of the hunt is a major part of the enjoyment.
Quote from: 'drakesterling' pid='95265' dateline='1471816917'I know dealers who are authorised dealers of both.
Getting back to the OP, I wonder if any of these double dealers are in Australia? It seems unlikely there are any exclusive NGC dealers here.
If you are wanting to have more than just a handful of coins graded then why not consider signing up with NGC or PCGS and send your own submissions in to be graded ??
The money you pay for your annual membership is pretty much reimbursed with the free submissions that come with the membership packages :ok:
It's Not that hard to do and will work out to be a cheaper option than going through a dealer .
Jeff's post #11 has two dealers that send to NGC but I don't think I'd worry about sending to Tasmania.
I have thought about it but then you need credit card etc (and not easy to get on DSP) and it all became very confusing and just way too hard for me :(
Just saw this thread...
FYI I did once ask Strand Coins (because they graded Benchmark Collection) and the guy there told me they don't do submissions for people. It was a one off thing with those coins. His "boss" traveled all the way to the US with a suitcase full of Benchmarks coins and submitted them for grading in person while he waited for a few days. (May be if I asked the "boss" I would get a different answer.)
Seriously people, It is neither that hard or more expensive to submit your own coins to NGC. :ok:
If you send your coins in through a dealer the "Minimum" you will be paying is what it cost to have the coins graded and dealers are not in the business of providing a free service so there will be an added fee for their services on top of the grading fees.
If you only have one or two coins that you want graded then fair enough , use a dealer to submit them.
However if you have 4 or more that you want done , Do your homework and sus out the costs to use NGC/PCGS yourself.
I think you will be surprised how much you can save doing the submitting yourself.
Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='95367' dateline='1471898415'I have thought about it but then you need credit card etc (and not easy to get on DSP) and it all became very confusing and just way too hard for me :(
AJ,just noticed your post,if your still reading Threads here you can get a Debit Visa/Mastercard from most Banks,exactly the same as a Credit Card except you have to have the funds in your Acct. for each transaction.
Since i've retired i've cancelled 2 of my 3 Credit Cards and just keep one for the sake of my Cr. rating.All my business now is with a Mastercard Debit Card,best thing i've done,should have done it 20 years ago.
Apologies if you know all this and hope to see you posting again.
Quote from: 'kchan1111' pid='101001' dateline='1478337642'Just saw this thread...
FYI I did once ask Strand Coins (because they graded Benchmark Collection) and the guy there told me they don't do submissions for people. It was a one off thing with those coins. His "boss" traveled all the way to the US with a suitcase full of Benchmarks coins and submitted them for grading in person while he waited for a few days. (May be if I asked the "boss" I would get a different answer.)
i would believe that story as you can do walk in & wait to take submissions with pcgs
Quotei would believe that story as you can do walk in & wait to take submissions with pcgs
It will still take 2 days and cost $125 USD per coin to do that :angel:
Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='101009' dateline='1478342762'Quote from: 'kchan1111' pid='101001' dateline='1478337642'Just saw this thread...
FYI I did once ask Strand Coins (because they graded Benchmark Collection) and the guy there told me they don't do submissions for people. It was a one off thing with those coins. His "boss" traveled all the way to the US with a suitcase full of Benchmarks coins and submitted them for grading in person while he waited for a few days. (May be if I asked the "boss" I would get a different answer.)
i would believe that story as you can do walk in & wait to take submissions with pcgs
I believe that part. But the part where he traveled with a suitcase carrying several hundred k worth of pre-decimals was interesting.
Quote from: 'trout' pid='101006' dateline='1478342179'Seriously people, It is neither that hard or more expensive to submit your own coins to NGC. :ok:
If you send your coins in through a dealer the "Minimum" you will be paying is what it cost to have the coins graded and dealers are not in the business of providing a free service so there will be an added fee for their services on top of the grading fees.
If you only have one or two coins that you want graded then fair enough , use a dealer to submit them.
However if you have 4 or more that you want done , Do your homework and sus out the costs to use NGC/PCGS yourself.
I think you will be surprised how much you can save doing the submitting yourself.
The dealer would get bigger volume discount if he sends more coins in, so offering this service to the casual submitter would help lower his costs. But how much he is prepared to pass on the savings with you is another question.
I wouldn't mind getting an Athenian owl tetradrachm one day since only NGC slabs them that's why I am interested. But if I am getting one it wouldn't be good enough for slabbing probably.
QuoteI wouldn't mind getting an Athenian owl tetradrachm one day since only NGC slabs them that's why I am interested. But if I am getting one it wouldn't be good enough for slabbing probably.
I would be getting that one slabbed in a heartbeat, with the amount of counterfeits around it would pay to get it authenticated :ok:
Great choice for an ancient BTW :)
Quote from: 'trout' pid='101015' dateline='1478346268'QuoteI wouldn't mind getting an Athenian owl tetradrachm one day since only NGC slabs them that's why I am interested. But if I am getting one it wouldn't be good enough for slabbing probably.
I would be getting that one slabbed in a heartbeat, with the amount of counterfeits around it would pay to get it authenticated :ok:
Great choice for an ancient BTW :)
Eric pointed out at Petersham show that slabbing ancients is kind of pointless because NGC "does not guarantee authenticity, genuineness or attribution, nor is any guarantee of these aspects implied. NGC Ancients will only holder coins it considers genuine at the time of submission, but it cannot guarantee the authenticity, genuineness, type, attribution or date of any coin it holders."
https://www.ngccoin.com/specialty-services/ancient-coins/guarantee.aspx
But at least at the time of slabbing you have a third party opinion I suppose. Makes it more important that you buy from somewhere reputable with a guarantee. i.e. not ebay! imho, why wouldn't anyone want a slab protecting a valuable coin anyway.
The Greek owl design is iconic. Wouldn't mind one one day!
QuoteNGC "does not guarantee authenticity, genuineness or attribution
I did Not know that, That IS interesting.
Quote from: 'trout' pid='101067' dateline='1478422726'QuoteNGC "does not guarantee authenticity, genuineness or attribution
I did Not know that, That IS interesting.
Think this is only for ancients though. And there are different terms and conditions for NGC Certified Gold, NGC Authenticated Bullion (discontinued) und NGC Shipwreck Certification.
https://www.ngccoin.com/coin-grading/ngc-guarantee/
The guarantee still applies to regular Decimal/Pre decimal coins though :good:
At the moment PCGS graded coins are more widely accepted by collectors in Australia and seem to attract better prices than the NGC graded coins.
I personally think that it make NO difference which company has graded the coin and the urban myth that NGC grades a coin one point higher than PCGS would is "Hogwash".
If you think about it a few years ago "Slabbed" coins were pretty much shunned by collectors regardless of who had graded them, I know that I did :)
With what has been happening at PCGS over the last year with the ridiculously long turn around times, the increase in stuff ups and in my personal opinion the overgraded coins coming out of the Hong Kong office I have decided to get my coins graded by NGC from now on.
Sure at the moment the NGC graded coins won't attract the same values that an equivalently graded coin in a PCGS slab would But collectors opinions do change over time and I do believe that the NGC slabs Will become more widely accepted by Australian collectors in the future.
In the meantime my turnaround times are leap years ahead of PCGS and I will save a small fortune in grading fees and return postage fees by using NGC instead of PCGS. :yahoo:
Quote from: 'trout' pid='101085' dateline='1478476621'The guarantee still applies to regular Decimal/Pre decimal coins though :good:
Yep. Definitely.
Look at this...
http://monetariumadelaide.com.au/shop/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=9_2_16&products_id=57
Graded by NGC as MS61, only AU58 at PCGS. I can understand 1 point difference. But this is UNC and aUNC! Massive difference to price. At $60k this is priced as MS.
If you look up this coins cert # you will see that there are 2 different images, One of them is a lot older than the other So it looks like this particular coin has been cracked out at least twice.
I wonder what the original grading was before it was sent to NGC then back to PCGS ??
If NGC graded it MS61 then they obviously couldn't see any wear on the coin and gave it a bagged up and nasty MS61 grade.
If PCGS decided that there was indeed wear on the coin then the AU58 is a pretty generous grade given all the numerous bagmarks and a 55 would be a closer grade.
I am thinking that because of this coins rarity PCGS would have looked back at its original grading of this coin and have stuck with it pretty much.
I would love to know what this was originally graded at.
These are the 2 images from the cert#
(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10019/24052612_max.jpg)
(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10019/24052612_Large.jpg)
Quote from: 'trout' pid='101088' dateline='1478482898'in my personal opinion the overgraded coins coming out of the Hong Kong office I have decided to get my coins graded by NGC from now on.
Sure at the moment the NGC graded coins won't attract the same values that an equivalently graded coin in a PCGS slab would But collectors opinions do change over time and I do believe that the NGC slabs Will become more widely accepted by Australian collectors in the future.
:yahoo:
Is there any easy way to tell if a coin is HK and not US graded?
The chance that PCGS may falter and NGC becomes more accepted is partly why my NGC coins remain in NGC slabs and won't be crossed over.
QuoteIs there any easy way to tell if a coin is HK and not US graded?
Not really but I suspect that the coins that you look at the cert# for that have the image of both sides of the coin in the slab come from the Hong Kong office :ok:
We have adopted this slabbing culture from the US and over there NGC and PCGS slabs are treated equally because both companies have a proven track record.
NGC is actually the preferred TPG in the States for Non US coins.
I am thinking that PCGS is the preferred TPG in Aus because they were the first slabs on the market and it took a lot of time and effort by the slabbing pioneers here to get these graded coins accepted by collectors and they now have a vested interest in keeping PCGS as the top Dog TPG here.
There are also the collectors that have invested time and money in building their PCGS set registries and they cannot add a NGC graded coin to those sets.