Bought this raw off of eBay a little while back. A couple of "experts" have tried telling me it was post mint damage. I thought it was worth sending to PCGS to see what they said.
(http://www.mycoinalog.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/australia-1979-2c-clipped-planchet-pcgs-ms64rb-slab.jpg)
(http://www.mycoinalog.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/australia-1979-2c-clipped-planchet-pcgs-ms64rb.jpg)
Lovely coin Mark!!!
Enough even to raise the hairs on the back of Lizzie's neck!!
If you anyone could find a possible way for that to be PMD then I'd eat my hat! (Ooops, touched it and it turned to skittles!!).
gee I think they are a little generous with ms64
cool coin however I would have passed on it personally not knowing if it was real or not
I think unicorns observation is the healthy way to approach error coins, eg how would have the damaged been caused PMD. I personally can thin of no way
Quote from: 'serial' pid='94182' dateline='1470885748'I think unicorns observation is the healthy way to approach error coins, eg how would have the damaged been caused PMD. I personally can thin of no way
There are quite a lot of people, including sadly, some who should know better, who really have no clue at all.
Usually we see them manifest as eBay vendors of "RARE Mint Errors" which are fakes, shed jobs or PMD, but sometimes as in this case, the opposite occurs.
The answer, of course, is knowledge. As a certain famous sleuth said,
"How often have I said to you that when you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth?". The trick is to be knowledgeable enough to be capable of eliminating the impossibilities. :angel:
Very nice pickup, Mark. If (when?) it goes on the market, what might it be worth, do you think?
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='94187' dateline='1470889656'Very nice pickup, Mark. If (when?) it goes on the market, what might it be worth, do you think?
Probably not much more than I have in it sadly. Clips are one of my favourites and I can appreciate the scarcity of a coin like this but sadly not many others do. Gross mis-strikes seem to do a lot better in the market place. I'd probably value this one at $300 or so. It's going to the pool room though :)
Quote from: 'serial' pid='94182' dateline='1470885748'gee I think they are a little generous with ms64
The reverse picture doesn't do it any justice, it's cock-eyed in the grommet and impossible to get it flat to the plane of the camera. It graded exactly as we expected it to.
Quote from: 'markn' pid='94189' dateline='1470889786'Probably not much more than I have in it sadly. Clips are one of my favourites and I can appreciate the scarcity of a coin like this but sadly not many others do. Gross mis-strikes seem to do a lot better in the market place. I'd probably value this one at $300 or so. It's going to the pool room though :)
Yeah, you're dead right. Flaws are massively under-appreciated, as people just don't seem to 'get' the concept of a truly unique coin. I too would rather a spectacular flaw than something you can get thousands of any day of the week. But we're a minority I'm afraid.
Anyway, I just printed those pics off (B&W, sadly), and will show them off at tonight's 'errors and varieties' night at MNS. I'll also take in my mule, wavy 2 and a handful of others. And hopefully Goldy will show up with his clockface if I start hassling him right now. ;)
Is that the roadkill wavy? It truly is unique in its own way.
Quote from: 'JeffH' pid='94204' dateline='1470894554'Is that the roadkill wavy? It truly is unique in its own way.
No, but now you've given me an idea. If I can find it. :wavemulticolor:
Nice one Mark, I see most the errors sold pretty bloody quick that you put on the PP page and amazed how quick as I looked and thought WOW I didn't even get to see the prices, well done :good:
Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='94216' dateline='1470902226'Nice one Mark, I see most the errors sold pretty bloody quick that you put on the PP page and amazed how quick as I looked and thought WOW I didn't even get to see the prices, well done :good:
I just take the pictures, PPH sells them :)
Nicely done Mark :good:
To be quite honest, If I came across that coin I would have just tossed it into my odds and sods bucket as a curiosity because I wouldn't have known exactly what it was.
Knowledge is King Mate, Good on you :yahoo:
Quote from: 'markn' pid='94226' dateline='1470905225'Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='94216' dateline='1470902226'Nice one Mark, I see most the errors sold pretty bloody quick that you put on the PP page and amazed how quick as I looked and thought WOW I didn't even get to see the prices, well done :good:
I just take the pictures, PPH sells them :)
It must be the quality of the pic's that helps sell them :angel: But being nice coins also helps :winkextra: