Australian-Coins Forum

Australian Coins, Banknotes and Exonumia => Australian Errors and Varieties => Topic started by: serial on July 11, 2016, 09:38:30 PM

Title: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: serial on July 11, 2016, 09:38:30 PM
So I was searching a bulk lot today and I think I have found one of these. Problem is I have never seen one before. the picture in renniks shows a bar that is sharp and distinct. the one I have seems like a late state die as the bar is more blob like but it certainly lines up with the bar location. I will put a pic up when I have a chance to take one and good light but in the mean time has anyone got one of their own? pictures of one or even a link to a quality picture of one??
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: ausjack on July 11, 2016, 09:43:29 PM
Yeah Emu has one on his site
http://www.thesandpit.net/index.php?option=1961bar_shilling

Hopefully your will be like one of the varieties he mentions here, down the bottom of the page :good:

Here's one on quicksales that's a little different again.
https://www.quicksales.com.au/vshops/item.aspx?itemid=21091542&shopid=12196
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: serial on July 11, 2016, 09:56:38 PM
IS that his site! I didn't know
this is the best I can do with my light how it is
(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/11197/1961_bar_in_wool_shilling_a.JPG)
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: robbiegal on July 11, 2016, 10:44:35 PM
gee AJ
your link reminded me that I haven't been back to check my store on quicksales for about a year or more!
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: ausjack on July 11, 2016, 11:10:11 PM
Yes the sandpit is Emu's site and it looks the goods serial, well done :good:

Oh well better late than never RG :)
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: serial on July 11, 2016, 11:16:07 PM
I cant believe I found it,
I only glance at the 60's coins when I sort bulk lots!
one less coin to have to find
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: robbiegal on July 11, 2016, 11:34:03 PM
i asked my hubby if he has any - he said that he thinks he does and that they show up in the other 1960 years or something
i will have have to raid his albums - he has them so orderly that i should be able to look through them

i have 2 x 1960 shillings
no errors on mine

Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='92381' dateline='1468244411'Yes the sandpit is Emu's site and it looks the goods serial, well done :good:

Oh well better late than never RG :)


you did well spotting the type of error so quickly!
the seller who you linked to is a chap that I have bought coins off for donkey's years
he is one of the old school and knows what he is doing as well
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: Nevol on July 12, 2016, 09:27:13 AM
The second one that AJ gave a link to looks like a 'manufactured' bar to me.:dodgy:

On the first link and on serials coin, the bar is almost vertically above the upstroke of the N, but in the second link it's above the I.  

Also in the second link, there appears to be a 'hit' mark immediately to the left of the bar, making the bar a little heap if displaced metal. :dodgy:

It would be good to know if there are any other markers. The bar on serials coin is very fat. :dontknow:

Is this bar known to move around?
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: trout on July 12, 2016, 12:50:16 PM
I didn't know that this variety existed until I read this thread.
The "Bar" on Emu's and Serials coin look to be in the same position and are the same length.
Maybe the "Fatness" of Serials coin can be the result of die deteriation as the rest of his coin doesn't look that well struck up.
Maybe an email with a couple of images sent to Emu will help to tell if this is a new find.
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: Fulvio on July 12, 2016, 01:15:07 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='92406' dateline='1468293616'Maybe the "Fatness" of Serials coin can be the result of die deteriation as the rest of his coin doesn't look that well struck up.

I'm still trying to get my head around die damage at the bottom of the incused design rather than on the surface or edges of fields.

I'm just not seeing it, unless it was a) deliberate, b) a really-well-targetted dropped tool or c) a cold shut in the tool steel that broke away.

c) wouldn't look that neat.
b) would have required the eye and arm of Superman.
a) by a process of elimination seems most likely. No idea why, but if you're going to do one, why not more than one?
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: robbiegal on July 12, 2016, 01:48:44 PM
here is what we are talking about
Quotes and pics from the Sandpit
In conclusion, the "true" 1961 bar shilling has the bar starting just to the left of the second upright of the N and is vertical. Accept no substitutes. And if your ever find a 1960, you know who to call....
(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10035/1961bar_renniks.JPG)
Serials eagle eyes coin
(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10035/1961_bar_in_wool_shilling_a.JPG)

Peter's coin examples of right above left and so on on the N
(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10035/1961bar_r.JPG)(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10035/1961bar_false3.JPG)
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: serial on July 12, 2016, 04:51:37 PM
ok better light now and better pics, looking at the pics I think the bar is caused by a die chip/crack/gouge that eventually evolves to where mine is.
I have handled hundreds if not thousands of shillings and this is the 1st one like this I have seen
1st a normal one
(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/11197/1961_normal_wool_shilling_a.JPG)
then the wool one
(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/11197/1961_bar_in_wool_shilling_c.JPG)
(http://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/albums/userpics/11197/1961_bar_in_wool_shilling_b.JPG)
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: trout on July 12, 2016, 05:04:26 PM
I have asked Emu to look in on this thread and to give his advice on this coin. :ok:
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: robbiegal on July 12, 2016, 05:47:16 PM
yeah Serial
it is a top error regardless to the academics of identifying the error type
although the sheeps' wool around it looks notably flatter
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: Fulvio on July 12, 2016, 07:22:53 PM
Quote from: 'serial' pid='92426' dateline='1468308097'the bar is caused by a die chip/crack/gouge that eventually evolves to where mine is.

Yes, absolutely. It has to be a hole in the die in order to produce a lump on the coin. The question is how the damage occurred in a recess when every die damage error we've seen has been on the surface (field) or edges of the design.

And I'm not buying that the thick one is a progression of the thin bar either. Not without some real close examination. If it were, there's be a heap of these around, in all sorts of states, as there is with rabbit ears or other progressive damage.

For now I'm leaning towards deliberate or possibly accidental damage at the hands of a worker rather than metal fatigue or a random impact.

BTW, care to kill the duplicate image, RG?
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: robbiegal on July 12, 2016, 08:35:03 PM
done
BTW, care to kill the duplicate image, RG?

i don't buy the accidental or deliberate damage by a mint worker
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: ausjack on July 12, 2016, 08:58:09 PM
The only thing that is making me wonder about this is where I put the arrow as the other coins don't seem to have this mark so high but then if it is the die wearing out then that explains it a bit
(http://i63.tinypic.com/nvedlc.jpg)
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: trout on July 12, 2016, 09:14:48 PM
Quotealthough the sheeps' wool around it looks notably flatter

This is what is making me lean towards this being PMD.
It looks like the coin has taken a hit with something with a gap in it, This would explain the flat depressions either side of the "Bar" and the other mark just above it on the upper fold of wool.
If this was a cud or a growing cud then either side of it would be the normal coin design and not flattened like this one is.
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: robbiegal on July 12, 2016, 09:22:50 PM
great photos Serial
It makes it sooo much easier to identify errors when the photos are crisp and clear like yours
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: nealeffendi on July 12, 2016, 09:47:03 PM
Quote from: 'trout' pid='92445' dateline='1468323888'
Quotealthough the sheeps' wool around it looks notably flatter

This is what is making me lean towards this being PMD.
It looks like the coin has taken a hit with something with a gap in it, This would explain the flat depressions either side of the "Bar" and the other mark just above it on the upper fold of wool.
If this was a cud or a growing cud then either side of it would be the normal coin design and not flattened like this one is.

Can't agree. A blow strong enough to move that much metal would surely leave other damage such as bending the coin or knackering the queen.
The real proof as a true variety will be when a second example is found.
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: serial on July 12, 2016, 10:14:18 PM
this is not pmd, original surfaces are present.
the appearance of damage either side is an optical illusion and I assure you I can tell the difference.
what I find most funny about this coin is my inability to find sales of any other coin. plus I cannot find a single example of the coin quite as sharp as the one in renniks

Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='92447' dateline='1468325823'
Quote from: 'trout' pid='92445' dateline='1468323888'
Quotealthough the sheeps' wool around it looks notably flatter

This is what is making me lean towards this being PMD.
It looks like the coin has taken a hit with something with a gap in it, This would explain the flat depressions either side of the "Bar" and the other mark just above it on the upper fold of wool.
If this was a cud or a growing cud then either side of it would be the normal coin design and not flattened like this one is.

Can't agree. A blow strong enough to move that much metal would surely leave other damage such as bending the coin or knackering the queen.
The real proof as a true variety will be when a second example is found.
this is why I am trying to find another one, trying to establish if it is a variety or an error coin with a large cud. I am leaning towards a cud
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: trout on July 12, 2016, 10:41:55 PM
OK then, So Not PMD and very similar to Emu's coin.
There Must be more of these out there and hopefully will be found at varying stages from what Emu's coin looks like to what Serials coin looks like.
I have a bucket full of 50% silver coins and will have a squiz tomorrow, Now that I know what to look for maybe just maybe there might be one of these chucked in there.
I would imagine that there are many of us that were blissfully unaware of this error/variety existed that have a stash of silver coins that they can explore.
Happy Hunting Guys :good:
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: serial on July 12, 2016, 10:59:25 PM
I handle at least 3kg of scrap predecimal a week
I pick through it entirely looking for variants eg 46 florins big o 6, error coins etc. Been noodling lots for a long time now. This is the 1st one I have ever seen ever!
I really hope that someone can find another one as I feel this is like a fantail 6d. Extremely rare and undervalued in the renniks
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: trout on July 12, 2016, 11:04:50 PM
I would think that there are many errors and verities that are grossly undervalued because they are not widely known.
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: robbiegal on July 13, 2016, 11:54:09 AM
my theory that I have been pondering is:
(see what Neil thinks)

The original bar error is a smaller version of a die bubble that has begun to break off

Serials coin is 'possibly from when the die was finally quite damaged and the die bubble has completely broken away, hence the fail in the sheeps' wool in that area

that area (the flattened part) looks rough which is what can happen in a spot that isn't fully struck up. The metal had flowed into the recess of the die bubble and in doing so has taken the metal away from the design and into the 'lump'that we see but is in fact a recessed dip in the die itself.

it might also be a chip but I reckon this one fits the bubble theory better

die bubbles do occur in dies and the metal can fatigue and break away (an example is the 'dot'on the queens neck 1964 Y penny)

my feeling is that it is an interesting curiosity but perhaps not of great value in terms of errors
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: nealeffendi on July 13, 2016, 05:37:18 PM
Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='92466' dateline='1468376649'my theory that I have been pondering is:
(see what Neil thinks)

The original bar error is a smaller version of a die bubble that has begun to break off

Serials coin is 'possibly from when the die was finally quite damaged and the die bubble has completely broken away, hence the fail in the sheeps' wool in that area

that area (the flattened part) looks rough which is what can happen in a spot that isn't fully struck up. The metal had flowed into the recess of the die bubble and in doing so has taken the metal away from the design and into the 'lump'that we see but is in fact a recessed dip in the die itself.

it might also be a chip but I reckon this one fits the bubble theory better

die bubbles do occur in dies and the metal can fatigue and break away (an example is the 'dot'on the queens neck 1964 Y penny)

my feeling is that it is an interesting curiosity but perhaps not of great value in terms of errors

Doesn't work out. If it was a bubble in the die that began to break off then the defect would show up as incuse on the coin. If it was a fully burst bubble (leaving a crater in the die) then yes it would produce a raised feature (such as the bar) but then would it be so neat with nicely tapered sides?
The Frankenstein queen..... is it from metal fatigue on the die? (don't know either way).
Now if the die had been accidentally damaged (such as getting whacked into by another die when a batch was being annealed) then the defect might be a neat bar.
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: robbiegal on July 13, 2016, 05:56:20 PM
good points
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: ausjack on July 13, 2016, 06:01:12 PM
Either way it went wouldn't one think that there should be more examples around :scratch_one-s_head:
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: serial on July 13, 2016, 06:32:17 PM
Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='92488' dateline='1468398672'Either way it went wouldn't one think that there should be more examples around :scratch_one-s_head:

I would say so, how many is anyone's guess. I would say that it wouldn't have been long after mine that they would have retired the die. Given that this year numbers in the 10's millions I imagine they will be hard to find
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: ausjack on July 13, 2016, 06:46:29 PM
Yes you don't hear of many people talking about them, I can't remember where I seen some one mention them as it was a few years ago but it might have been CCF.
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: trout on July 13, 2016, 09:49:36 PM
No luck in the junk buckets finding one of these :(

I have to add however that I really enjoyed handling a bunch of coins without a care about fingerprints or dropping them for once :good:
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: Fulvio on July 14, 2016, 01:05:48 PM
Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='92482' dateline='1468397238'Now if the die had been accidentally damaged (such as getting whacked into by another die when a batch was being annealed) then the defect might be a neat bar.

Yes, but my point was this would then be on the SURFACE of the die, the field of the coin. Or along an edge in the design. Which is where just about all the cuds occur. Actually, other than the 'Uluru' Outback dollars, I'm hard pressed to think of other examples of holes in the design part of a die right now.
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: nealeffendi on July 14, 2016, 04:26:39 PM
Quote from: 'Fulvio' pid='92526' dateline='1468467348'
Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='92482' dateline='1468397238'Now if the die had been accidentally damaged (such as getting whacked into by another die when a batch was being annealed) then the defect might be a neat bar.

Yes, but my point was this would then be on the SURFACE of the die, the field of the coin. Or along an edge in the design. Which is where just about all the cuds occur. Actually, other than the 'Uluru' Outback dollars, I'm hard pressed to think of other examples of holes in the design part of a die right now.

What about the halfpennies of 1921 with the denticle patterns? Might they not also be dents in the die from making contact with another die? Also the 1964? (IIRC) pennies with 1, 2 or 3 denticle patterns. Careless workshop employees when handling dies during hubbing or annealing might cause one hardened die to make a glancing blow against another softer die and leave a ding. Especially easy to do when trying to manipulate very hot dies with tongs and heavy gauntlets.
I also have seen 1920 pennies with faults that represent damaged dies (most likely due to a tool or other hard piece of metal whacking the die).
Title: RE: 1961 bar in wool shilling
Post by: Fulvio on July 15, 2016, 12:58:01 AM
Quote from: 'nealeffendi' pid='92530' dateline='1468479399'What about the halfpennies of 1921 with the denticle patterns? Might they not also be dents in the die from making contact with another die? Also the 1964? (IIRC) pennies with 1, 2 or 3 denticle patterns. Careless workshop employees when handling dies during hubbing or annealing might cause one hardened die to make a glancing blow against another softer die and leave a ding. Especially easy to do when trying to manipulate very hot dies with tongs and heavy gauntlets.
I also have seen 1920 pennies with faults that represent damaged dies (most likely due to a tool or other hard piece of metal whacking the die).

Not really being a predecimal collector, I'm afraid I'm unfamiliar with those particular coins. Pictures?

However, in general terms, sure, impact damage occurs all the time. But whether its a die clash, dropped tool, careless cleaning or whatever, it mostly affects the high parts of the die, which is the field of the coin, or the edges of the design. For something to reach down into a crevice with enough force to leave a mark such as we're discussing, even with soft metal, well, I'm having a hard time explaining that.