Australian-Coins Forum

Australian Coins, Banknotes and Exonumia => Australian Errors and Varieties => Topic started by: tooloot on July 01, 2016, 09:32:47 PM

Title: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: tooloot on July 01, 2016, 09:32:47 PM
Came across this in a recent noodling expedition. It's a 2008 10c coin with a smooth collar (every other 2008 10c coin I've seen has a ridged collar) and the images on the obverse and reverse seem somewhat distorted/grainy, but not what you'd expect from general circulation. I've never come across something like this before, but it doesn't look like PMD to me. Any advice? Apologies about the quality of the photos - my digital camera isn't working so I needed to use my phone:

(http://imgur.com/DL73wlv.jpg)
(http://imgur.com/emdn2R5.jpg)
(http://imgur.com/abGozlx.jpg)
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: ausjack on July 01, 2016, 10:39:47 PM
Looks like it's had a harder life than me mate but I'd be leaning toward PMD and what they call a dryer coin where the coin has been tumbled around but keep posting because it's how we learn and most of the people here are cool and will try and explain things :good: If the obverse, reverse and side (was nice and square) it could be one missing the reeding but it looks a bit rounded and rough for that sorry. Have a really close look and you might see small patches where the reeding was at some stage. Good luck with the noodling, if your anything like me you have to look at many coins to find anything worth keeping.
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: tooloot on July 01, 2016, 10:58:37 PM
Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='91781' dateline='1467378587'Looks like it's had a harder life than me mate but I'd be leaning toward PMD and what they call a dryer coin where the coin has been tumbled around but keep posting because it's how we learn and most of the people here are cool and will try and explain things :good: If the obverse, reverse and side (was nice and square) it could be one missing the reeding but it looks a bit rounded and rough for that sorry. Have a really close look and you might see small patches where the reeding was at some stage. Good luck with the noodling, if your anything like me you have to look at many coins to find anything worth keeping.

Thanks for that.

One thing I forgot to mention is that (and excuse my complete ignorance for proper terminology) is that the central part of the coin (i.e. the part stamped on both the obverse and reverse within the boundaries of the rim) seem to be dipped more than usual. Another way of describing what I'm trying to say is that if I run my finger across both the obverse and reverse of the coin over the edge (rim) of the coin, the rim appears to be more raised (or the central part appears to be more pressed in) than in your typical 10 cent coin. This is what led me to believe I might have an error coin. Does this change the opinion at all?

I will try to get some better photos and even try to show the raising of the rim
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: ausjack on July 01, 2016, 11:44:13 PM
No worries.

No I'm still thinking PMD because you'll probably find it's higher on the rim due to the wear as it's rounded the edge off so if you measured it it would be slightly thicker than a coin that is in better condition. If you live where you can see a dealer take any coins that you think might be an error and ask for their opinion or if you can go to a coin show and ask a dealer as all we can do is give an opinion on what we're seeing sorry.

The best way I could describe to you roughly what your coin is like is if you were to feel the edge and rim of a normal struck coin and then tap it with a hammer all the way around and then the edge would feel higher and like it's dipping more down onto the fields.

Once you've been noodling for a while it becomes a lot easier to pick an error or suspected error to PMD.
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: Fulvio on July 02, 2016, 12:27:16 AM
Quote from: 'tooloot' pid='91779' dateline='1467374567't doesn't look like PMD to me.

Nah, AJ's right. And it is an acquired skill.. the more coins you look at the better you get at working out what's what.

This kind of damage can come about in two basic ways. As AJ said, being 'tumbled' as if it was in a dryer. And being acid-washed. However the latter wouldn't deform the rims, which narrows it down quite a bit for you.

Consider that real errors break down broadly into things which affect the die, and things which affect a planchet. The former are all the errors and varieties, and the latter are the faults, like cold shuts, rips, tears, flakes, clips, brockages etc etc etc.

Anything which affects the coin after its been struck (even before being issued into circulation) is PMD. There really are no exceptions to this, though one or two things are still desirable to some (like counterstamps, burnt coins and really bad roadkill). Come to think of it, have you looked through the roadkill thread? There's a lot of stuff in there with which to hone your skills. :angel:
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: tooloot on July 02, 2016, 01:56:29 AM
Amazing advice thanks! I'm realizing every day how much more I need to learn - the ability to post here is helping home my skills a lot, thanks!!
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: robbiegal on July 02, 2016, 11:17:56 PM
the pic is sooo huggee
but if i click the photo - i get a smaller image pop up

i have been told that these can be poker machine coins i.e. the edge is worn down

but there can be a mint error the same

the images are too pixcelie to really be able to tell
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: tooloot on July 03, 2016, 06:45:12 AM
Quote from: 'robbiegal' pid='91848' dateline='1467467276'the pic is sooo huggee
but if i click the photo - i get a smaller image pop up

i have been told that these can be poker machine coins i.e. the edge is worn down

but there can be a mint error the same

the images are too pixcelie to really be able to tell

Sorry about the size. I'm constantly being given advice on uploading photos here and something always seems to go wrong!

I'm going to try and get some higher resolution photos of this coin. When it is a minting error (as you said it can be), what types of qualities should I be looking for? Thanks
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: Fulvio on July 03, 2016, 04:27:11 PM
Quote from: 'tooloot' pid='91851' dateline='1467494112'what types of qualities should I be looking for?

That's actually a very good question, that we should do more to address. The information is spread throughout this forum (and elsewhere), but collating it all is another matter. ;)

So, think about the minting process.

You start with liquid metal, which is poured and rolled into a coil of sheet metal. At this stage, there can be temperature differences in the metal, which will produce cold shuts. Places where the metal fails to bond into one cohesive material. Think of the joints in a pull-apart loaf of bread, for example. These cold shuts can be quite small pockets, or long seams right across the sheet. Depending on where the planchets are punched, there could be a lump of metal which falls out, or there could be a rip across the coin, or it might even split in two.

Then the rolls go through a punch press, which cuts the coin planchets from it. Sometimes the rollers which advance the coil misfeed, and planchets could be cut with a piece missing, as it overlaps the previous row. The resulting coins will have a bite out of them, and because of the way metal flows when struck, the opposite end of the coin will show fishtailing, called the Blakesly Effect.

Once the planchets reach the mint and go into the presses, we come to die variations. Dies may be produced which are slightly different to others, resulting in varieties. Or they may be damaged, on the workbench or in use, resulting in errors. These errors will for the most part present as raised areas on the coin, being a mirror image of the die. Dies can also be inserted into the press incorrectly, producing mules struck from mismatched dies, rotations from a die which is not locked in place, weak strikes from too little pressure or strikes where a die is not fitted absolutely square in the press. Loose dies can also move during striking, 'bouncing' and producing a doubled image.

Foreign objects may also enter into the press, such as oil, grease, bits of metal, or even other coins. These will produce a variety of flaws, and are totally random and unique. Coins may also misfeed, and be struck at odd angles or partially out of the collar, or a collar may not engage at all, or partially. More flaws result from these mishaps.

Once a coin has been struck, anything which happens to it is PMD. Rough handling, bag marks, machine damage, scrapes, general wear and tear or deliberate tampering, even if it occurs in the mint building, are not considered errors, and are generally not collectible. That said, a coin which has been abused may still be attractive to some. Burnt coins can be beautiful. Coins with numbers of letters punched into them, or even hand carved may be desirable as objects, but they have no numismatic value.
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: JeffH on July 03, 2016, 05:06:25 PM
That is quite a good, concise summary Fulvio. And I won't mention the red herring of what is an.......and......what is a..........?
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: tania on July 03, 2016, 06:00:57 PM
Thanks for that Fulvio.
It makes a bit more sense to me now.
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: Fulvio on July 03, 2016, 06:17:36 PM
Quote from: 'tania' pid='91880' dateline='1467534657'It makes a bit more sense to me now.

Cool. Its great when everything clicks into place. :yahoo:
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: ausjack on July 03, 2016, 06:22:19 PM
The Australian coin blog is a good place to look as well and Mark has put some really good pic's and descriptions of the errors.
I have one of these clamshells and you can either get what they call a "clamshell" or a "split planchet" where the coin is fully split in half but they're really really rare.
http://www.australian-coins.com/blog/2008/10/split-planchet-errors-part-3.html

Have a look at this section where the errors are and just click on the blue highlighted description that you want to look at
http://www.australian-coins.com/error-coins/coin-errors-misstrikes/
Hope it helps :)
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: Pedro on July 03, 2016, 09:10:00 PM
Very concise and useful explanation of possibilities Fulvio. Excellent! :good:

Pedro
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: tooloot on July 03, 2016, 09:43:19 PM
Fulvio that was great! Thanks for all of the info. And thanks Ausjack for the extra resources.
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: ausjack on July 03, 2016, 09:50:18 PM
No worries mate but Mark is the one to thank as he's the one that's done all the hard work putting it all together but a good site to see what to look for as well as here where you can post pic's and ask questions :winkextra:

Oh and AJ is fine mate, saves typing :good:
Title: RE: 10c coin - Not sure what I've found (if anything)
Post by: Fulvio on July 03, 2016, 10:06:36 PM
Quote from: 'ausjack' pid='91902' dateline='1467548418'a good site to see what to look for as well as here where you can post pic's and ask questions

AJ's right... I'd even go so far as to say the two resources put together (and the Wiki as well, even if its a tad under-done) constitute the premier resource in this field, certainly as far as Australian coins are concerned.

Mark does awesome work, no doubt, as does his better half, PPH. :yahoo: