I received my CAB magazine in the mail a few days ago and was browsing in particularly Ian McConnelly's article " A lot from a little" page 16.
He discusses a cool 1988 bicentenary one dollar error that at first glance looks to be struck on a thinned edge planchet. I first noticed the missing edge of the legends and most importantly noted the fishtailing clearly visible even on the small image. After reading the article the coin got much more interesting after he mentioned the weight that fits that of a $2 coin -it's a dollar struck on a $2 planchet. The author goes into detail about the coins characteristics but completely fails to mention the fishtailing which I would point out is the single strongest indicator that this coin is a genuine error and not post mint damage.
The next coin to go under the spotlight is a green Remembrance $2 with paint missing. The author refers to the paint as "material" and suggests a grand scheme for this genuine variety. Now I won't hesitate to suggest that everyone reading this post knows exactly what is going on because of the following:
1. It's paint
2. It's painted on
3. Not all the paint adheres
4. Paint comes off with circulation or even being rolled
5. Paint can flake off or be removed with acetone
6. Paint flakes have been found in mint bags
The author suggests we can enlighten him but perhaps he may just browse the Google or join an esteemed coin forum.
It is a bit disappointing to see that sort of stuff in our major coin magazine. Perhaps some peer review is required?
Was the Editor "Out to Lunch" when this particular issue was put to bed??:angel:
I don't subscribe to coin magazines as I am of the opinion that 95% of numismatics is just plain common sense and the other 5% can be garnered via Google or by asking questions on well respected coin forums such as this one and CCF, Also by asking respected dealers questions at shows or reading blogs.
I do however buy them from time to time mainly to oogle at the coin images, A bit like I used to do as a young bloke with Playboy :angel:
I have found on a whole CAB magazine tends to have accurate information in it and I think it is unusual for something like this to be published as the subject of the "Missing Colour" on the $2 coins has been a topic of discussion since the very first pad printed $2 coin was issued.
In fact the "Missing Ink" issue has been with us since the "Mysterious" No ink proof millennium 50 cents came to be :dodgy:
Quote from: 'trout' pid='88998' dateline='1463910308'I don't subscribe to coin magazines as I am of the opinion that 95% of numismatics is just plain common sense
Bingo!
Its also interesting that in many cases its not WHAT is said, but WHO said it that carries weight. Personally, I put far more value in what's said here than in a lot of allegedly weightier venues.
BTW, can I steal that quote for the MNS group? Or better yet, you could sign up and post it there? :diablo:
QuoteBTW, can I steal that quote for the MNS group? Or better yet, you could sign up and post it there? Diablo
Quote away Old Mate :)
Yes that was a surprising read. Not sure how he was so off the mark given all the publicity the first painted $2 got.
Hoping to get a copy tomorrow.