Have recently finished what ended up being an on and off again research/study/search on these two fellas. This lasted about 7 years and I have nearly finished. Some interesting things surfaced and I thought I'd share. There is a lot to read.
I hope to cover a few other interesting facts on the period as well as some interesting things about Twibble and Mander. I believe Twible, whose name is spelt Twibble in his police reports and newspaper clippings, in fact may not have even met the man known as Roy Manders. In fact I believe Roy Manders existed in a different period. What further sparked me on this little quest was after I had obtained a so called copy of Twibble and Manders handiwork , a rather nicely struck 1927 florin, from the sale of the late Peter Wall collection in 2009, I wanted to learn a bit more, well a lot more and maybe discover the identity of who Roy Manders was.
. I hope to cover a few other interesting facts on the period as well as some interesting things about Twibble and Mander. I believe Twible, whose name is spelt Twibble in his police reports and newspaper clippings, in fact may not have even met the man known as Roy Manders. In fact I believe Roy Manders existed in a different period. What further sparked me on this little quest was after I had obtained a so called copy of Twibble and Manders handiwork , a rather nicely struck 1927 florin, from the sale of the late Peter Wall collection in 2009, I wanted to learn a bit more, well a lot more and maybe discover the identity of who Roy Manders was.
Arthur Twibble (this is how I will be spelling his name from now on as reported from his police record and newspaper clippings.) was in fact born Albert Anderson in Sydney, 10 the month, 1862 according to his police record dated 1913. His religion is recorded but is however unreadable from his charge sheet.
There is also no evidence to support he was a religious person, in fact the only time he is known to attend church was when he was robbing them of their possessions and silverware.
His profession is listed as a carpenter which seems to be true at one stage. More on that point a little later.
His height is listed as 5 feet 5 ½ inches, blue eyes and what little hair was left was noted as sandy. It was also noted that he had a tattoo of AT on the inside of his left forearm. He was never married and had no known children. This information was obtained from his death certificate which in itself will provide some interesting facts. He also had another alias of John Robinson, although the information I could find was about a very rough individual who was convicted of murder, so not a lot is known about his alias at this stage, anyway. Maybe more will come to light at some stage. It is also recorded under the education degree that he achieved R and W, which I understand to be read and write.
Now the journey starts.
A young Arthur Twibble, as he is known at this stage, was first recorded in the newspaper, The Sydney Morning Herald, dated Thursday 26 September, 1878. Quoting mostly from the papers now.
Arthur Twibble (that was the name he gave, and I am unsure how he obtained or when he actually started using that name) was remanded before the Sydney Water Police Magistrate for a stealing offence. He gave his age as 14; however it was more likely to be 16 from his birthdate given. Being small in stature he could probably get away with it. The charge was for stealing 5 quires of notepaper and various other articles from the premises of John Sands to the value of 1 pound 15 shillings. (A quire is a set of 24 uniform sheets of paper or a section of printed leaves in proper sequence after folding, gathering)
How this came about was young Twibble was working as a carpenter for a company by the name of Deacon and Co. who rented the yard at the back of the premises. He was fined 40 shillings or 14 days. What he did I am unsure of, as there is no mention on his police record of this event, possibly because his first recorded conviction is in 1881 in Melbourne, and is under his real name Albert Anderson..
The next few years are a bit all over the place, the year is 1881, location is Melbourne and Twibble is in Melbourne Jail, records indicate he received 14 days jail for breaking windows on the 11 February 1881. At a guess he was probably caught about to do a break and entry and rob the place. Jump to 1st June 1881, and this is where it is a little confusing, remember these are from his police record from 1913 over 100 years ago. Anyway he is charged with stealing receives 3 years hard labour, receiving an additional 2 years hard labour
To be accumulated. Another charge recorded on the 15 July 1881 for burglary and receives another 4 years. I can only assume he either confessed to the burglary offenses later or further charges were laid later on in regards to his earlier activities. All up 1881 he was doing 9 years in Melbourne Goal.
It is now in 1890, still in Melbourne. Here are some interesting pieces of information in regards to his next lot of recorded convictions. He receives a double sentence for 2 different burglaries of the same people, the Laurence Brothers, at 2 different locations. The court appearances, according to The Argus newspaper, dated Thursday 19th December, have Twibble and another man, one William Ballard charged with 2 accounts of burglary, Twibble receives 6 years on the first charge and 4 years on the second charge.
How this came about was Twibble and Ballad had robbed the Laurence Brothers, who traded as a tobacconist and agent, a few weeks prior to getting caught at another location, and escaped with the proceeds. This was still under investigation by the police. A second attempted robbery occurred at another premises also own and operated by the Laurence brothers however this went wrong. Someone was still there. Ballad was apprehended at the scene while Twibble stole a horse and escaped. Ballad received a good beating while being apprehended and was transferred to the prison hospital for treatment and recouperation, while his accomplice was still at large.
Twibble was actually caught out by his own thoughtlessness. In the events of the night, Twibble had stolen a horse and made is escape to a very short freedom so it turns out. 2nd December, following a tipoff about a neglected horse tied up in a front yard, a Constable Seddon was instructed to proceed to the residence and make inquiries. He located the horse, still tied up in the front yard, in Lillian Street, East Brunswick. Twibble was located and in fact brought in on charges of cruelty to an animal. Constable Seddon later returned to Twibble's residence and did a thorough search as instructed.
He located a quantity of electroplate. (coating element)
A silver cup broken down into pieces, which had been stolen from Reverend A McVeen, (told you he went to church), a silver watch bearing the number 9515 and the name of J Hanna scratched into it. The constable, Seddon, also located crucibles, plaster of paris moulds and dies (assuming they are referring to the mould casts here.) for various coins. Now remember we are only in 1890, so there is no official Australian currency minted yet. So what are the dates in the moulds and what coins were they.
Burglary tools a set of keys which are referred to as skeleton keys were also located.
This was the second search of Twibbles residence, the first turned up a large quantity of the stolen merchandise from the Laurence Brothers robberies. Some of the items were tobacco and groceries, which were already packaged ready for delivery to inmates in Pentridge Stockade. This was seen as a major breakthrough in the solving of a speight of robberies and burglaries that had been happening for a time by a desperate gang.
The charges were dropped for the animal cruelty charges and there was no record of the coining implements recorded. I suppose they didn't actually find any counterfeit coins at that time or only the main charges warranted being written in the small space provided on the charge sheet. That is only an assumption or they were pleased in the success of breaking up a major crime spree that the smaller charges were dropped and only the main burglary charges were pursued. Or perhaps the charges were not written on the record sheet because of the lack of room available in the space provided on the charge sheets.
Not a lot is known about the next few charges and years, however they will get a mention as it is all part of the makeup of Twibble and his past. This is a general summarization of the time and charges. They are as follows anyway. The year is now 1898; I know there are some conflicting dates recorded on his official police record. How did that happen with the dates, probably with little education and that'll do attitude by the people recording the charges, or perhaps early parole which I cannot confirm. There could also be time differences where he is being held in custody and until his court appearances. Who knows, after all it is last century.
Dunkkeld/Hamilton/Ballarat jails a total of 6years for the charges of sacrilege, receiving, receiving and receiving.
Sacrilege is stealing something godly. You make up your own mind about his religious beliefs.
We are now approaching the most interesting period and times and will be able to shed some light on his counterfeiting activities, some interesting things emerge here.
Further police records show Twibble was incarcerated again in Melbourne; it is dated 17 April 1905, for a further 10 years.
The paper this time is the Geelong Advertiser, 20th and 22nd March 1905.
The incident and arrests.
6 detectives raid the premises of William Priest at 42 Johnston, Street, Fitzroy, Melbourne, an establishment trading as a green grocers shop. Arrested are William Priest, greengrocer, Rose Dawson, also known as Priest, his wife, they were married in 1901, Joseph Williams, 15 and Arthur Twibble, who gave his age as 45. (1905 would put him at about 43 according to his records anyway.)
Upon searching the premises it was revealed the downstairs was used as a green grocers shop, while upstairs was indeed a rather elaborated coining plant. While searching upstairs, Twibble tried in vain to bar the door and stop the police from searching his room. He was unsuccessful in his attempt. Twibble's own room turned up about 60 counterfeit coins, mainly half crowns and shillings. There were also a number of others which were intended to represent the half sovereigns. These were in various stages of completion and were not gilded yet. It is also noted, when searched he had 30 bogus shillings and 16 half crowns on his persons. Every the elusive criminal, Twibble stated it wasn't his coat and he had simply put it on by mistake in the confusion.
Other items located included crucibles (mixing bowl), chemicals, an electric battery and a lathe. The lathe was homemade and was fashioned from an old sewing machine and mounted on a large board. This was used to Mill the edges of the coins. Still in 1905 remember. This procedure was noted as primitive but effective. In another room, the kitchen, 2 plaster of paris moulds were located, both about 4 inches in thickness. Inside the moulds were a genuine half crown and shilling being used for the purpose of moulding spurious coins. Also located was cyanide, silver, more moulds and various other metals.
When questioned Twibble admits to a previous 8 counterfeiting charges since 1881 and yet no record is on his official police record. I can only assume now that it was a lesser charge at the time and didn't fit in the space provided for the charges. Going with this assumption. Priest also admits to having been charged with counterfeiting under various names on 12 previous occasions.
I know, remember it is 1905.
Rose Dawson and Joseph Williams were later let go. Twibble and Priest were convicted. Twibble receives 10 years for having coining implements in his possession. I am assuming that is the shortened hand written version on his record. So we now know he was counterfeiting half sovereigns, half crowns and shillings. It's s till 1905. No Australian coinage still. This is an important fact. Also he admits to 8 previous convictions, although I am now thinking there wasn't enough room on his record sheet for all his indescressions.
This makes sense; all his notes are hand written with little space. He does however have about 8 previous convictions, including break and entering etc., so make your own assessment. We do know now that he was counterfeiting and what they were. Still 10 years is 10 years, or not.
First known evidence of what he was capable of coining, and it's back to jail.
Time flies and the year 1913 pops up. 1905 plus 10 years does not make 1913. A major conflict is about to occur, mainly 1914 WW1. Twibble is at this time is about 51 years of age.
What also turns up is information about the number of skilled immigrants arriving in Australia because of the pending dramas in Europe. Some were known to be counterfeiters.
More at a later date.
Anyway he is about to be charged again. This time he has journeyed back to Sydney.
Sydney, not Melbourne, obviously he was after a fresher start, or maybe had something to do with the early release date in Melbourne. What also may have occurred is that there may be differences in dates in regards to time served and their official court dates and sentencing, or he escaped, well that is another possibility.
The date recorded is 9th September, 1913 which would be the date of his conviction and start of his new jail term. Albert Anderson, this time charged using his own name and Arthur Carter, 26, were brought before the courts on August 25th, 1913 with having counterfeit coins in their possession. Anderson or Twibble and Carter were arrested with 45 bogus florins in their possession, while Carter was charged with uttering. Police would prove this was being done on a large scale and that they were part of a large gang of counterfeiters working and operating together. The coins were made of a base metal and had a thin coat of silver coating.
More interesting facts are about to emerge. What is about to be revealed is the very first known records of Arthur Twibbles coining of Australian florins. Yes, believe it.
The charges read uttering counterfeit coins and having counterfeit coins in his possession, which probably is a very broad charge. The judge is also recorded as saying, " It is with regret he couldn't give him another 10 years". He is given a 7 year stay for this little venture.
There is listed the dates of the florins confiscated.
They are 1 x 1910, 12 x1911, 32 x1912 intended coins known as florins. These 1911's were made up from 3 moulds. 8 were from 1 mould, 2 from a second mould and a further 2 from a third mould. The 1912 consisted of 10 from one mould, 10 from a second mould and the remainder of 12 from a third mould. There you have some of it. This does tell you a fair bit and does ask a few more questions and assumptions. Not a lot of further information has been found, however I am assuming a search was done of his living quarters and this turned up the moulds which some kindly policeman and newspaper reporter took note of, for which I am and will be eternally grateful.
It is also noted at this stage no 1913 florins were found. The year is 1913.
So Twibble has spent a fair part of his life incarcerated, from the records I have that is approximately 43 years, give or take a few months and days. He is about 51 years old now in 1913.
You do the maths, that's a fair bit of time.
While the last chapter was only all small period of time with little know, it did turn up some very interesting information on what year coins and denominations Twibble was known to have counterfeited of Australian currency at the time.
Twibble did a bit of travelling between Sydney and Melbourne. His police records and jail time confirm this. Needless to say while travelling it is possible Twibble was passing his handiwork along up and down the coast to unsuspecting people. Let's face it money was tight back in those days and a florin, was a lot of money even if you suspected it might be a bit dodgy.
Now there is some limited reporting of Twibble in this period of his life upon release from prison.
It is now 1920, and Twibble has ventured back to Melbourne.
16th October, 1920. Twibble is brought up before the Melbourne magistrate - Mr Justice Mann.
The charges read on the 20th September 1920 at Brunswick, Twibble was caught with coining implements and bogus coins.
When questioned, he answered he was an ill carpenter (true he was employed back in 1878 as a carpenter) and that up until that time he had been working for the last 2 years. (On the chain gang doing hard time, my guess) We also know by now he has a bit of a disregard when it comes to telling the truth. He went on to say after he became ill he also found himself penniless and had made a few of these coining moulds to tide himself over. He also admitted to 12 previous convictions and has undergone more than 40 years imprisonment.
Mr Justice Mann stated, "You appear to be a confirmed coiner and to have served many long sentences. You will be imprisoned for a period of 5 years with hard labour, declared a habitual criminal and will, at the expiration of your sentence be detained in a reformatory prison during the Governors pleasure.
No information in regards to what he was coining for this period however going from past ventures, you could possibly assume it may be florins again. At this stage I am coming to believe Twibble was, apart from the early dates recorded from 1913, using whatever real dated florins he had available to him at the time as I can't find any record of other known dates recorded.
Wednesday 27th October 1920. This information comes from a paper at the time, The Argus. (I am partially quoting in some parts here)
Arthur Twibble again makes the news in Melbourne from behind bars. He was attempting to flee custody, make a jail break. (Thinking acdc music jail break)
An attempt to escape from the Melbourne jail was made yesterday by Arthur Twibble, 60 years of age. (I have his age at about 58) (See your singing jail break now, aren't you)
While in the Melbourne goal waiting to be transferred to another prison, Twibble came into possession of a fine saw and at about 4 o'clock yesterday morning, sawed through one of the thick iron bars that guard his cell window, and made an opening large enough to squeeze through. (Remember he is only 5 ft. 5 ½ inches,)
He then manufactured a rope by tearing the bed clothes into strips. Taking the improvised rope he then squeezed through the bars and was making his way towards the prison wall. A warder heard a noise, and on investigation saw Twibble stealing across the yard. Finding himself detected, Twibble surrendered to the warder, stating "The game is up".
That is all I have on this period, that's not to say with further digging of records in Melbourne archives somewhere, there wouldn't be more titbits to emerge. Most of the information I have has come from police records located in Sydney. Why Sydney, because that is where my interest was first aroused by the novel, The Shadow.
Upon his departure from Melbourne jail, possibly sometime in 1925, not a lot of information has come to light. Maybe he was working as a legitimate carpenter again who knows. He was obviously trying to keep a low profile. We are now heading into the years of Frank Fahey, the undercover policeman from the novel by Vince Kelly. The time is now 1928. Now between what I have read of the book and my own research, there seems to be a few conflicting areas which I hope to explain correctly. This is the so called era of Arthur Twibble and Roy Manders. Some areas of the book can be confirmed, but not all at the same period of time. For instance on page 57 of the novel, The Shadow, it says detectives raided the room of one Edgar Reginald Stokes, also known by the alias of James John Ritchie, a known coiner and was found dead in dead in his room from cyanide poisoning. This is correct however research shows that it was in fact in 1931 and not 1928 that Stokes's body was found. More on that later. There are also a few more discrepancies between what has been written by Vince Kelly and what has been uncovered by newspaper clippings and archive material.
Let me begin with what I have unearthed in my search and then we will compare the other version in The Shadow.
The time period I have is 4th September, 1928.
2 people were arrested, Arthur Twibble, 68, (prone to giving his age incorrectly), by my calculations he is about 66) and Joseph Perry 19, labourer were charged with making 100 counterfeit florins and having 7 moulds for making florins. So we can assume he was possibly casting florins again, as there is no mention of a coining plant, as such, in this report.
Bail, believe it or not was set at 300 pounds for Twibble and 150 pounds for the young Perry.
So I believe they remained in jail. A certain amount of time between being caught and being sentenced. Here's why I think. Investigations were still on going. Travelling was also not what it is today.
Saturday 6th October 1928, the hearing of Arthur Twibble, 68, carpenter and Joseph Perry 19, labourer, were charged with
First charge. Making 100 counterfeit coins, namely florins.
Second charge. Having 7 moulds for coining.
Third charge, having uttered 1 florin.
Twibble pleads guilty to charges 1 and 3 only.
On sentencing, Twibble unsuccessfully appealed for a lighter sentence due to his age.
"That is the trouble" said his honour, "You will probably not live to come out of jail after serving your sentence." He is given a sentence of 5 years, hard labour.
"I never had much to live for "replied Twibble, "now I have even less."
Perry pleads guilty to the first charge and receives 12 months hard labour.
Perry's sentence is suspended under The First Offenders Act. Mr Spoule of RD Meagher, Spoule and Co- appear for Perry.
Additional information known is the coins and moulds made had the Kings head on one side and a coat of arms on the other and are called florins. No dates were given.
The lead up to being caught also differs from the books version to that of the court records.
There were probably a large amount of counterfeit coins turning up in Sydney at this time, but not because soully of Arthur Tribble and his accomplice Joseph Perry. No doubt his picture had been distributed as described previously in the shadow. I have no record of DS Jake Miller as mentioned by Kelly. I do however have an account of DS Alchin as being present at the apprehension.
September 4th accounts of events according to Detective Sgt Young and Detective Sgt Alchin who locate Twibble on Henderson Road, Alexandria. He was questioned and caught with 19 counterfeit florins on his persons.
His initial response was he had bought them obviously going for the lesser charge of uttering. Twibble was taken into custody.
On searching Twibble's room in City Road, DS Young located 2 leather bags in his room. Another 34 bogus florins were located, along with some copper coins, (most likely genuine items as there is no mention on the charge sheets), a couple of moulds (which turns out to be eventually 7) and various other items used for coining.
Joseph Perry was also found there. When questioned he said "I know nothing about it. I didn't even know Twibble was making crook money."
No it gets even more interesting.
Later at the detectives offices, Perry, changes his whole story and says him and Twibble had made about 100, (that magic number again) on many occasions in a cave near Helensburgh. They would principally pass them in hotels and to barrowmen in the city. They had also travelled to Melbourne and he had known Twibble for about 12 months. With this information he has given up freely, is this the reason why he never went to jail.
At the court appearance a list of items were exhibited as well as witnesses being called.
The items consisted of
A number of counterfeit coins, (no date or denomination given although we do know there were florins previously) (pictured in the book although they are unclear in the old photo)
Moulds (pictured also), a vat of antimony ( a white lustrous metallic element used in alloys and medicines.
a ladle, 1 pair of goggles,(pictured), pliers ,plaster of paris,2 boot polish tins, a tent,( not pictured) trousers( also not pictured) ,2 leather bags, ( not pictured either)and a tin of animal fat. (unsure from picture).
The witness's called were DS Young and DS Alchin, who gave their version of events. Also called was Mister Walter John Wood, bank clerk for the Commonwealth Bank. It is reported he told the court, the coins confiscated were indeed counterfeit florins and he had seen similar coins paid into the bank recently. He also stated some of the coins were a very good imitation. (He may have been referring to the ones being processed through the banks as well)
The cave is located about 2 miles from Helensburg in mountainous country. This was also mentioned in the book.
DS Young and Loomes accompanied Joseph Perry to the caves location at Helensburg.
The going was pretty tough and hazardous.
There at the site, some 20m yards from the entrance of a cave under a rock, was a fly of a tent , 2 blankets and 2 pairs of trousers. Inside the cave 2 candles, several moulds , some metal and 11 coins resembleming florins, ( a secret hidden stash uncovered).
These items were passed from Loomes to Perry who confirmed, after examining them closely, confirmed that, "That was some of the stuff". There is still no mention of Frank Fahey. He may have been omitted on purpose because of his undercover status.
It is noted that Twibble did not accompany the trio to the cave. Any thoughts as to why this may have happened. Also from the count of florins found I calculated from the numbers, 19, 34, 11 mentioned, that is about 64 florins found. That leaves approximately 36 unaccounted for. In the picture I count approximately 51 or 52 images of coins, it is an old photo and is hard to be definite about it. They may not have pictured all the evidence or there may be some still outstanding.
Perry also states they had visited the cave about 7 or 8 times, each time making about 100 florins. These figures also differ to that implied by Kelly and Fahey at his stage.
Page 61 quotes a raid at Redfern and they located 2 leather bags, coining equipment and utensils and claims it is a coining plant. In the bags they found hundreds of pounds worth of florins and shillings. There were also some spurious sixpences. I have not found any evidence that Twibble was making any denomination lower than the florin from 1913 onwards. With a little more silver in the alloy all the coins would have passed any scientific tests used by the banks for detection of bogus coins. This I believe had nothing to do with Twibble and Perry, but may have been the result of Roy Mander.
Hence the legend of Twibble and Manders has begun.
So Perry escapes a jail sentence, Twibble gets 5 years hard labour and no mention of Frank Fahey or Roy Manders by my account as yet.
I was also unable to locate any further information on Joseph Perry. I may have been looking in the wrong places or he may have also used an alias I am unaware of.
It is with great sadness I have to bring to you the death of Albert Anderson also known as Arthur Twibble.
Albert Anderson alias Arthur Twibble died in Sydney Prison, as mentioned in the book, The Shadow, on 7th March 1930.
His death certificate number is 1930/000276 under the name of Anderson. It is dated the 11th March , 1930, the date on which he was buried.
He is buried in Cementary at Rookwood NSW.
He was, according to his death certificate, 69 years old. He leaves no family and was never married.
Just some reminder notes, and information on Stokes which I believe are relevant to this time period. Why now, because he gets a mention in this period as well.
Edgar Ronald Stokes, alias James John Ritchie was sent to a jail in Sydney at the beginning of 1928. He received 2 years for break and entering. He was released at the end of 1930. He may have known or met Twibble at some time in this period.
He had only been out for about 8 months before he was found dead in his lodgings, in August 1931. This differs somewhat to the account in The Shadow. The books account is he , Fahey , was given the name of Stokes to tail, that was implied in 1928 and his body is found later in a room.
My records show that after his death, while searching his room, at Surrey Street, Darlinghurst, police located 73 bogus florins hidden in the back of a wireless. Moulds were found in the chimney. A race book, which is an interesting piece of information in itself, was also located with horses picked out for the Kensington races. It is believed he was going to unload there.
Other items located were plaster of paris , milling wheel, white metal, coal, cyanide and nitrate of silver. There was not enough ventillation in the room. He was 27 years old and worked previously as a barrowman.
The florins were all dated 1928 and 1931.
Police do not know how he learnt how to counterfeit, however there very many books on precious metals, processing and electroplating found in his room. Obviously he could also read.
According to a section on page 56, Stokes was a criminal with a long record of criminal history and was suspected of previously counterfeiting.
The Redfern connection
This is where I believe some of the facts from the book start to run into each other. They are bits and pieces of real events made to look like one event.
In the book, The Shadow, I believe the chapter about Twibble and Roy Manders was delberately written that way to make the reader believe they knew and worked with each other. This , from my research, is far from the truth. Arthur Twibble's name gets 2 mentions up until the time he dies. I believe as a comparison to Manders operartion and the quality of the coins being turned out.
A little later on the quality and craftsmenship is also compared. After rereading that section of the book, Twibble's name doesn't get mentioned , however his accomplice, he, his, his cobber etc get substituted about 14 or so times. Why not include his name if indeed he was relevant to the partnership. The only date gets mentioned is back in 1928, where he goes back to finding Twibble in Sydney. 1928 was when Twibble was being tailled and finally apprehended.
According to the book, Fahey says " I always felt sorry for Roy( he remembers Manders name) If his cobber (cobber forget his name did you Frank) hadn't framed him he would never had been caught. If you believe the account by Kelly, he claims Manders had a limit of making 11,000 pounds in counterfeit money. He had reached his goal, when his accomplice, ( no name again) virtually begged him to restart the plant up again as he was broke. (he, no name again. At least you know he was a male individual)
Roy Manders coin of choice was the florin. He was said to have at least as much silver in his bogus coins with the quality being as good as the mint was turning out.
A lot of florins and no date is mentioned of what they are.
From a newspaper article in The Sydney Morning Herald dated Thursday 3rd September 1931.
Detective Nye said he and several other policemen visited 85 Elizabeth Street, Redfern on August 23rd. At about 2.30 pm on Sunday searched the premises.
3 occupants found there and questioned. They uncovered a complete coining plant.
In a room at the rear of a kitchen, Nye found a bowl containing 5 sticks of silver , 8 counterfeit florins, portion of a kerosine tin containing another 5 counterfeit coins, (probably florins), pieces of glass, cyanide and a small box labelled nitrate of silver.
When asked who owned the items , the one later identified as Smith replied " I am stiff.I have only been at it for about ½ hour and gotten caught."
Over a fire in the kitchen stove , Nye found a saucepan containing molten metal. They were found to have been in operation mode when the police entered. 1 man was engraving a mould, another was examining spurious coins and a third threw 3 moulds into the fire, but they were recovered without to much damage. Bogus florins, shillings and sixpences were found. No date mentioned of the coins. The three men Samuel Jepson, 53 dealer, Charles Smith, 27, labourer, Joseph Jenkins ,31, dealer, were all taken into custody. When searched, Smith was found to have had a partly made plaster cast for counterfeiting in his possession. Other plaster casts were found in the fire. Spurious coins were found on each of the defendants. 3 bogus florins were found in Jepson's right hand coat pocket. Smith had moulds with a shilling and a sixpence embedded in them in his coat pocket, and 4 florins and other coins were found in his left hand trousers pocket. (Have to the love the details coming to light, even where the coins were found in which pockets.)
Jenkins was searched by Constable Walker, he had 5 counterfeit florins in his trousers pocket.
They were sentenced on the 16th October 1931, all received 18 months jail.
What has that got to do with anything, only that the location mentioned was Redfern and there were others making bogus coins. I don't believe anyone there is Roy Manders.
(Flashback, remember Edgar Reginald Stokes, well he is still deceased ,just checking)
And don't forget the chinese. There was a small syndicate who were known to be distributing 1928 shillings.
Another one. August 25th , one Phillip Seaegg, 39, dealer, was charged with having 10 moulds used for counterfeiting the court was told by Sgt Napper. The moulds were that of florins, shillings and sixpences. Police also showed Seaegg the moulds from Stokes room, he denies knowing anything. It is also alleged that Seaegg had introduced Stokes to a landlady in Surrey Street. The same residence were Stokes body had been found.
November 1932, Sydney, NSW.
A coining plant was found in an old foundry at Alexandria. This modern apparatus was the first of it's kind to be ever found in the Commonwealth. Scotlandyard is being asked to trace the source of the machinery and 20 coin making discs. (Machinery, dies,)
During the raid, an engineer was arrested in a room excavated under 8 inches of concrete.
A trapdoor had been cunningly hidden.
In the room were electric cables, a long hand press and 2000, yes 2000 counterfeit coins.
The entrance was hidden under an old butter box, which was only found by luck when Detective Boswell kicked it out of frustration.
Who was this person or persons who were operating this well organised setup.
The story a raid on premises in Mitchell Road , Alexandria, on November 11, 1932 was carried out by police who broke down the door and arrested 4 people present.
Arrested were Harold Roy Williams, 38, engineer, James Wallace, 31, cook,
Gordon Andrew Gordon, motor salesman, and Louis Somme, 63, die sinker.
Somme was charged with having been indirectly involved in the making of counterfeit coins.
It would also be alleged that Somme had 22 coin making dies which had been adapted to making heads side of the florins. It is believed about 5,000 pounds (monetary value not weight) in coins had been made in the last 18 months. He was also said to be recycling his dies.
After hearing the reports from the police involved, (no mention of Fahey), three people, Gordon, Wallace and Somme were granted bail. Williams was denied bail.
I give you the identity of Roy Manders.
Harold Roy Williams was charged with having made 2141 counterfeit coins resembling florins between 1st March 1931 and 11th November 1932. Williams offered little resistance during the raid and was in fact very cooperative with the police. He instructed the police to be careful when entering the pit because of the loose wires there. He also assisted in the dismantling of the machinery which included punching, marking and rolling machines a press and a large quantity of bogus coins.
The trial begins. December 8th, 1932 at Redfern Police Courts, one of the accused Gordon Andrew Gordon takes the stands and proceeds to tell about his involvement.
He goes on to say he was hired to install the machinery which he believed was going to a mining site near Ballart. Sometime later he discovered the true purpose of the equipment. Yeah right. He also stated Wallace had dug the underground apartment in which the equipment was concealed.
He was told the first lot of coins turned out had not been a success. On another occassion he saw hundreds of coins. He also denied that there had been any threat made to him by the police to give his version of events.
Mr John Yeldman represented Williams and Mr Clifton R. Penny represented Somme.
Also giving evidence was the chief technical officer from the Melbourne mint, Mr Ernest Clucaf, who stated the coins were not made by the mint but were of a standard silver.
Williams and Somme were both sentenced to 18 months imprisonment.
Go back to the book, Roy Manders was given 4 years imprisonment, how can he be Manders, then.
It is a very simple explanation. In February 1933, police successfully appealed against the length of time given to Somme and Williams. The court of appeals agreed and extended Somme's term to 3 years and Williams sentence was extended to yes you got it, 4 years.
Meet the real Mr Roy Manders, I believe.
Williams was only operating for a short period of time after Twibbles death which was in 1930.
I don't believe the two ever had contact or even knew each other as is implied.
An article from a Sydney News Paper dated May 1932.
It reads Official figures released show that since May last year no fewer than 65 arrests have been made by detectives in combating the epidemic of counterfeiting which has flooded the whole State with countless bogus coins.
The police are of the opinion that the manufacture of homemade coins has been made attractive to criminals by the leniency of the penalties imposed. Some of the thousands of coins passed off upon the public have deceived experts of the mints, banks and police department. It is likely that the police the police of all states will collaborate in a recommendation to the federal Government that the coining laws be reviewed. This will explain why the police appealed the sentences of Williams and Somme.
Sydney February 1939.
Almost perfect counterfeit coins were being passed in such numbers that police suspect a modern plant was in existence. They were that they had to be submitted to the commonwealth Bank for testing. The florins were found to contain about 65% of genuine silver. Who's work was this. Maybe coins by Manders were still being circulated in 1939 or did Williams recommence his operations again. It was reported in the novel that Roy Manders had a target of 11, 000 pounds , which he had achieved. Court records have a specific amount mention, however no dates are provided.
Base metal and silver coating. Occasionally real florins and shillings were used in the coating process.
fixed the spelling :)
This is the modified version :)
https://www.australian-coins.net/gallery/displayimage.php?album=369&pid=12267#top_display_media
Oh my gosh, this needs my glasses, a cold drink and the kids in bed!
Having not read it all yet, is it going in CAB or to print/internet anywhere? It's certainly a lot of text and might benefit of being in a more manageable state for reading.
This is the modified version, got pics and other bits and pieces. Never really got up to the stage of what to do with it. It's still not quite finished yet. Always open to suggestions.
It will take me time to read before I can make a comment.
Must have taken time to put all that into the forum?
A huge effort there Gnome. It will take a few reads to digest it all. It must have taken you forever to trace all this info.
Quote from: 'gnome' pid='84605' dateline='1455692015'This is the modified version, got pics and other bits and pieces. Never really got up to the stage of what to do with it. It's still not quite finished yet. Always open to suggestions.
Great post Gnome.
One of the best I've seen on this forum.
This would make a great CAB magazine article.
I've been fascinated with the story behind these forgeries since I first saw them in the mid 70s.
Would be very interested in seeing the full version etc.
Great work gnome. I haven't finished reading it all yet, but will do so in bits 'n' pieces.
It would make a great article for our Coin Wiki. :good:
Thank you for sharing! :wavemulticolor:
Yeah,great effort,a Family Friend is a retired Coin(mainly Stamps thou.) Dealer and often talks about depression era fakes/forgeries,he would be interested in reading it for sure,i would have to copy to my computer and increase Text size if thats OK..?.
Brilliant work Gnome. A great read. :good:
Pedro
Thanks for the comments, appreciate it. :)
That's a good read Gnome. It is interesting to note that on each occasion there was a discrepancy over Twibbles age, it was always two years.:)
Thanks, yes there are a few variances between the newspaper reports and his police file. It was a bit trying at times to piece everything together, but had some fun doing it.
Excellent work.
What gives away the coins in your photos as fakes?
G'day Mr T, there are some pics in my gallery photos to have a look at.